Themes: Choices and Consequences
Choice, or at least the illusion of it, underlies every aspect of “The Lady, or the Tiger?” On a narrative level, the king's arena is designed entirely around the interplay between choices and consequences. When someone commits a crime, they are placed in the arena and must decide their own fate by choosing a door. The king’s tribunal can be interpreted as the logical extreme of a legal system that seeks to remove human bias from the equation; since the accused is responsible for choosing which door to open, the king and the audience can be absolved of blame for the end result.
However, the true choice does not take place during the tribunal. Punishment is a foregone conclusion no matter what the result of the trial; behind one door is death, and behind the other door is an unasked for bride. Either way, the accused criminal’s life is irrevocably changed. The criminal’s choice occurs the moment they decide to commit a crime. Everything past that point relies upon the king’s judgement and pure chance. The king is responsible for sentencing the accused criminals, and he is the one who writes the laws, making him the primary power behind the punishment. Furthermore, the story indicates that he actively enjoys the aesthetics of the arena. The tribunal doubles as a form of entertainment for both the king and the audience, making the choice between the doors insignificant in the face of the broader spectacle of the king’s vision of justice.
This dynamic is altered during the courtier’s trial, as the princess’s foreknowledge of the doors’ contents upends the luck-based nature of the tribunal. She alone has the ability to determine the courtier’s fate, and she must make the choice between sending him to his death and sending him into the arms of another woman. However, the outcome of her choice is left ambiguous. Instead, Stockton asks readers to determine the outcome, placing the final burden of choice on them.
Expert Q&A
What actions does the princess take in "The Lady, or the Tiger", and what are her motives for either saving or sentencing the young man?
In "The Lady, or the Tiger?", the princess directs her lover to one of two doors, but the story leaves which door ambiguous. Her motives for pointing to the door with the tiger include jealousy and hatred towards the maiden, as well as a desire for the young man to die rather than be with another. Conversely, her motives for pointing to the door with the maiden include love for the young man and defiance against her father's cruelty.
Which textual evidence best reveals the king's arena's lose-lose reality?
The piece of textual evidence that best reveals the lose-lose reality of the king's arena in "The Lady, or the Tiger?" is the fact that if the accused chooses the door with the maid, he will be compelled to marry her, even if he already has a wife or lover. It is clearly a loss for the accused to open the tiger's door, but it may also be a loss to open the other. Thus, either door can lead to punishment.
Why is the princess's internal conflict central to the story?
The princess's internal conflict is central to "The Lady, or the Tiger?" because it demonstrates complex themes of loyalty and betrayal. The princess holds a great deal of power because of her position, and she can use it to either save her lover or send him to his death.
How does the author's description of the princess's nature influence her decision?
The princess's semi-barbaric nature, inherited from her father, significantly influences her decision. Her possessive and jealous traits, coupled with hatred towards a maiden she suspects of flirting with her lover, drive her actions. The princess, having the power to determine which door holds the beast or the maiden, might choose the tiger's door to prevent her lover from marrying the maiden, reflecting her violent tendencies and intense jealousy.
Why does the princess in "The Lady, or the Tiger?" hate the lady behind the door?
The princess hates the lady behind the door because she is jealous of the possibility that the lady will get to marry the princess's beloved courtier. The princess believes that the attractive maiden and the courtier admire each other, and she does not want to see her lover happily married to another woman. The princess also knows that her lover would enjoy his life with the beautiful maiden, which further infuriates the semi-barbaric princess.
What motivates the princess in "The Lady, or the Tiger?" to lead the man to a particular door?
The princess in "The Lady, or the Tiger?" is motivated by a complex mix of jealousy and love. Knowing the secret of the doors, she must choose whether to direct her lover to the door with the tiger, ensuring his death, or to the door with the maiden, leading to his marriage to another woman. Her jealousy towards the maiden and desire to control her lover's fate drive her decision-making, leaving the outcome ambiguous and open to interpretation.
What does the phrase "No matter how the affair turned out, the youth would be disposed of" mean in "The Lady, or the Tiger?" and does it suggest fair justice?
The phrase "No matter how the affair turned out, the youth would be disposed of" indicates that the young man, a commoner, would be removed from the princess's life regardless of the outcome in the king's arena. This reflects the "semi-barbaric" king's belief in his own form of justice, which is not fair since the youth's fate is manipulated by the princess. His "crime" was loving above his status, questioning the justice of the situation.
What do the following quotes reveal about "The Lady, or the Tiger?"?
"And so I leave it with all of you: which came out of the opened door—the lady or the tiger?"
"If you decide which it was—the lady or the tiger—you find out what kind of person you are yourself."
Does the princess in "The Lady, or the Tiger?" send the young man to the lady or the tiger?
In "The Lady, or the Tiger?" it is implied that the princess likely sends her lover to the tiger, leading to his death. The narrative emphasizes her semi-barbaric nature, inherited from her father, the king. Her jealousy towards the lady behind one of the doors and her passionate yet unsentimental disposition suggest that she could not bear to see her lover with another woman, thus choosing the tiger.
What lesson does the princess learn in "The Lady, or the Tiger?" by Frank Stockton?
The princess in "The Lady, or the Tiger?" learns the secret of the doors, knowing which conceals the tiger and which the lady. The story explores her internal conflict over whether to direct her lover to a gruesome death or a life with another woman she despises. This moral dilemma highlights themes of jealousy, love, and choice, leaving readers pondering human nature and the complexity of emotions as the story ends ambiguously.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
