The Lady, or the Tiger? Themes
The main themes in “The Lady, or the Tiger?” are choices and consequences, power and judgement, and love and jealousy.
- Choices and consequences: The king’s justice system is based on choices and consequences. Those who choose to commit a crime must then choose the door that will decide their fate.
- Power and judgement: The king has absolute power, and he utilizes it to establish a system of judgement that absolves him of any blame.
- Love and jealousy: The princess’s jealousy of the lady complicates her love for the courtier, and calls into question the power of love to overcome selfishness.
Themes: All Themes
Themes: Choices and Consequences
Choice, or at least the illusion of it, underlies every aspect of “The Lady, or the Tiger?” On a narrative level, the king's arena is designed entirely around the interplay between choices and consequences. When someone commits a crime, they are placed in the arena and must decide their own fate by choosing a door. The king’s tribunal can be interpreted as the logical extreme of a legal system that seeks to remove human bias from the equation;...
(Read more)Themes: Power and Judgement
From a purely philosophical standpoint, the king’s tribunal is the ultimate form of poetic justice; however, the tribunal does not exist within a vacuum. Though the ultimate decision between the doors lies with the accused, the laws of the land and the choice of sentencing is in the hands of the king. The flaw of the system is not in the method of judgement, but rather in the absolute authority of the king to subject anyone he finds disagreeable...
(Read more)Themes: Love and Jealousy
Love and jealousy are presented as extensions of one another, and the capacity for betrayal is only deepened by the emotional stakes of the courtier’s trial. No one would deny the love between the princess and the courtier, and the courtier’s obvious faith in the princess makes itself known when he unhesitatingly chooses the door that she indicates. The two young lovers are presented as being able to understand one another without the use of...
(Read more)Themes: Justice
In "The Lady, or the Tiger?" the theme of justice is explored through the king's arbitrary and whimsical method of trial. The king's system relies on chance rather than evidence, reflecting his "semi-barbaric" nature. Justice is portrayed as a spectacle, devoid of fairness and reason. The story questions the true nature of justice, leaving readers to ponder the moral implications of the king's decisions.
The king's method of administering justice...
(Read more)Expert Q&A
Themes, Conflicts, Symbols, and Irony in "The Lady, or the Tiger?"
"The Lady, or the Tiger?" by Francis Richard Stockton explores three major conflicts: the internal struggle within the princess, who must choose between sparing her lover by directing him to a door with a lady or succumbing to jealousy and leading him to a tiger; the external conflict between the king and the courtier, as the king disapproves of their relationship; and the societal conflict, where the courtier faces a barbaric justice system. The story's open ending highlights the theme of choice and its consequences.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
