Student Question
What is the irony in "there will be a scar, that is unavoidable" in The Kite Runner?
Quick answer:
The irony in the statement "there will be a scar, that is unavoidable" lies in Amir's physical scar mirroring the emotional scars from his past. Amir's upper lip scar resembles Hassan's childhood surgery scar, symbolizing Amir's redemption after confronting Assef. This external scar represents his internal guilt and cowardice. Additionally, it is ironic due to its similarity to Hassan's scar, highlighting their bond as half-brothers and showing Amir's unexpected connection to Hassan.
This statement is made to Amir as he is recovering from his injuries after his encounter with Assef. His scar is on his upper lip and looks like Hassan's scar from his childhood surgery. It is ironic on two counts.
First, Amir's scar on the outside finally represents the scars on his heart from what he had endured and done years ago. He was scarred by his father's treatment of him and by his cowardly action toward Hassan. Now, the scar he wears on the outside shows his redemption. He finally stood up to Assef on behalf of Hassan (by rescuing Sohrab).
Secondly, the scar is ironic simply because it is so close to Hassan's. Amir has just learned from Rahim Khan that he and Hassan are half brothers; so the scar serves as one more bond between them. It demonstrates that Amir was not so different from Hassan after all.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.