Summary
In The King of Torts, Clay Carter finds himself at a crossroads. At just thirty-one, he is a disillusioned public defender languishing in the grim environment of Washington, D.C. Clay's journey from an overwhelmed idealist to a millionaire attorney illustrates the moral complexities and seductive allure of power and wealth.
Disillusionment and Struggles
For five years, Clay Carter has toiled as a public defender in crime-heavy Washington, D.C. Living modestly, he drives an old Honda and owns just two gray suits. His apartment, situated in a less desirable part of town, reflects his stagnant financial state. While his Georgetown Law School peers revel in lucrative careers, Clay clings to a meager income. His disenchantment with his work grows as he finds himself defending clients whose honesty is questionable, and whose guilt seems apparent.
Amidst this professional dissatisfaction, Clay's personal life is also complicated. He is romantically involved with Rebecca Van Horn, a woman who appreciates his physical presence but desires a more affluent lifestyle. Her wealthy parents see Clay as a failure, and he feels out of place in their elite social circles. The future appears bleak until a violent encounter in the city unexpectedly alters Clay's trajectory.
An Unlikely Opportunity
In a twist of fate, Clay is assigned to represent Tequila Watson, a young man who killed a drug dealer in broad daylight. With a case that appears unwinnable, Clay reluctantly takes on the challenge. During his investigation, he encounters Max Pace, a mysterious figure with multiple aliases. Pace, representing a pharmaceutical company, presents Clay with an unusual proposition. The company has been testing "Tarvan," a drug intended to cure addiction, but with disastrous side effects in some cases, as evidenced by Watson's behavior.
Pace offers Clay a lucrative opportunity to approach victims' families for settlements, ensuring that the details remain out of the courtroom. Despite initial reservations, Clay agrees, lured by the promise of ten million dollars. This pivotal decision marks the beginning of Clay's transformation from a defender of justice to a lawyer driven by financial gain.
The Rise to Wealth
With his newfound wealth, Clay opens a law office, assembling a team of lawyers and assistants. His success grows rapidly as he travels across the country, negotiating settlements with major corporations. The media dubs him the "New King of Torts," a title reflecting his prowess in mass tort litigation.
Clay's mentor is Patton French, a successful attorney known for his extravagant lifestyle. French, working out of Mississippi, epitomizes the materialism that Clay now embraces. With Rebecca marrying another, Clay forms a superficial relationship with Ridley, a woman more interested in shopping sprees than meaningful conversation. Ridley becomes a symbol of Clay's new life, one characterized by luxury and excess.
Moral and Legal Consequences
Despite his apparent success, Clay's story takes a dark turn. Old-fashioned lawyer Dale Mooneyham warns Clay about the dangers of greed, particularly in mass tort litigation. "Class actions are a fraud," Mooneyham asserts, predicting future legal reforms that will eliminate the financial windfalls that attorneys like Clay exploit.
These warnings become prophetic as legislative efforts seek to cap punitive damages and centralize mass tort cases at the federal level. Critics, like Janet Maslin of The New York Times, argue that while some corporations deserve scrutiny, massive financial penalties could push businesses into bankruptcy, impacting countless employees.
Downfall and Reflection
Clay's fortunes unravel when federal agents expose a stock-trading scheme orchestrated by Max Pace. Unbeknownst to Clay, Pace manipulated stock prices through insider information related to Clay's lawsuits. As Clay faces lawsuits and federal scrutiny for similar dealings, his empire collapses.
The...
(This entire section contains 796 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
once-celebrated "King of Torts" is now derisively called the "King of Shorts," reflecting his fall from grace. Burdened by debts and legal battles, Clay's associates abandon him, leaving him isolated and facing possible jail time.
Grisham's Impact and Critique
Upon its release, The King of Torts quickly topped best-seller lists, showcasing Grisham's ability to weave compelling narratives about the legal world. Although his characters may lack depth, Grisham excels in revealing the darker sides of the law and business. Through Clay's story, he critiques the excesses of the legal industry and the potential for reform.
Grisham's novel raises questions about the ethical boundaries of mass torts and the impact of unchecked greed. It suggests that while financial compensation is necessary for those harmed by corporate negligence, the system should not enable exploitation by attorneys. As Clay's story concludes, readers are left to ponder the balance between justice and greed in the legal system.
Review Sources
The Boston Globe, February 25, 2003, p. E6.
Forbes 172, no. 2 (July 21, 2003): 20.
Library Journal 128, no. 19 (November 15, 2003): 114.
The New York Times, February 3, 2003, p. E7.
The New York Times Book Review, March 9, 2003, p. 22.
People 59, no. 5 (February 10, 2003): 49.
Publishers Weekly 250, no. 5 (February 3, 2003): 56.
The Washington Post, February 3, 2003, p. C1.