Student Question

How does King Lear metaphorically represent the frailty of mankind?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

It is a metaphor for the frailty of mankind precisely because through its plot and the horrific suffering that Lear is forced to endure mankind is shown to be truly frail in the face of forces that are beyond its control and ability to comprehend. This tragedy, perhaps more than any other Shakespeare tragedy, is shaped by disasters that visit upon the characters catastrophic consequences. This can be related to the key theme of justice, and various characters in the play wonder about whether there is any such thing as justice, or if the world is antagonistic or even indifferent to humanity.

Gloucester, for example, draws the following comparison to the relationship between humans and the gods:

As flies to wanton boys are we to the gods;

They kill us for their sport.

Even though Edgar believes that "the gods are just" and maintains a belief in a view of the world where each person is punished or rewarded according to their deeds, his confident certainty is massively undercut by the way in which the play shows the death and punishment of both the wicked and the good characters. The ultimate image of this, which is perhaps the most desparate and bleak image out of Shakespeare as a whole, is that of Lear cradling the dead Cordelia in his arms. The massive uncertainty that the ending of the play leads us with as to whether the forces of good or chaos win at the end of the day underscores the inherent frailty of mankind in a world where there appears to be very little justice.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What metaphors exist in King Lear that point to frailities of life?

I think that one of the most compelling metaphors is the figure of King Lear, disheveled and wandering, seeking to grasp what identity is in his context.  The metaphor of this old man, once of power and of control now reduced to a wandering vagabond who howls at storms and can no longer activate anything resembling power over his world is a very powerful metaphor that speaks to how frail and transitory being is in the world.  King Lear's characterization speaks to how power, greed, and coveting that which represents materialism can embody happiness in the temporary, but is overall a shallow pursuit.  King Lear gains knowledge and understanding about what constitutes valid pursuits, worthy endeavors, and true emotional connection all too late.  His entire being is a metaphor for how frail consciousness is in the world.  It is Shakespeare's genius that he presents Lear as a character who holds insight and meaning, but when it is all too late.  At the point in his life when he could have possessed such elements in a worthwhile manner, he lacks them and when he does gain them, it is too late to construct anything resembling transcendent meaning.  This metaphor for human consciousness is a really compelling one in how it forces rumination and reflection about what it means to be human and what it means to place value on that which is important.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on