Student Question

Why does Dana refer to her final return to Rufus on July 4 in Kindred as "reverse symbolism"?

Quick answer:

Dana refers to her final return to Rufus on July 4 as "reverse symbolism" because, while July 4th symbolizes American independence, her return to the past signifies the opposite—enslavement. This ironic twist highlights the contrast between the holiday's meaning and Dana's lack of freedom when she is transported back in time. Despite this irony, her final return ultimately leads to her liberation, as it marks the last time Rufus will call her back.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

It is an example of “reverse symbolism” because Fourth of July is Independence Day, and Rufus called Dana back to a time when she would be considered a slave.

Symbolism is when something stands for something else.  In this case, Independence Day does not stand for freedom, but instead for slavery.  This is why Dana calls it reverse symbolism.

Dana has gotten used to being called back to the past every once in a while.  Yet she has no control over when she goes, how long she stays, or when she gets to leave.  She knows that she can only be called when Rufus’s life is in   danger, so whenever she comes to the past she will be in a difficult situation.

We had fifteen full days together this time.  I marked them off on the calendar...  With some kind of reverse symbolism, Rufus called me back on July 4. (“The Rope”, part 2, p. 243)

When Dana goes back in time, she has no freedom at all.  She has to pretend she is a slave, and try to find ways to cope with living in a time when she has no rights. 

Ironically, since this is the last time Rufus will call her, she actually will become free as a result.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial