Student Question

What type of racism is portrayed in the book Kim?

Quick answer:

The racism portrayed in Kim involves a belief in racial superiority, with emphasis on the protagonist's whiteness despite his Indian upbringing. However, Kipling is more of a culturalist, believing in English civilization's superiority rather than racial superiority. The novel features examples of supposedly superior whites acting foolishly, challenging strict racial hierarchies. Kipling's views, while racist by modern standards, differ from Nazi-like racial ideologies, as seen in works like "Gunga Din."

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Racism in Kim, and in Kipling in general, is a difficult question not because it does not exist -- it does -- but because it is a different racism than the type we are accustomed to.

Kipling definitely felt that there was such a thing as "race" or "blood," and that it made those of the white "race" superior. We are reminded all through Kim that the protagonist is white, despite his Indian acculturation, and that those with darker "blood" are lesser. Such an attitude is unarguably racist.

However, Kipling is better called a culturalist rather than a racist, with the remarks about "blood" and "race" a relic of the less sensitive way such concepts were bandied about in the pre-Nazi era. Kipling believed in English "civilization" more than in the "white race," and like many imperialists assumed it was a skill that could be learned by subject peoples. Kim contains many examples of the supposedly superior "white" English behaving like fools; for instance, the shallow and silly remarks the English soldiers make when they capture Kim (ch. 5 - 6). Kipling, in fact, makes many remarks that are incompatable with Nazi-like racial superiority. One only needs to try to rework the last lines of his notorious poem "Gunga Din" from the viewpoint of a Nazi speaking of a Jew to see what separates Hitler from a writer who ends by declaring "You're a better man than I am, Gunga Din."

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

References

Approved by eNotes Editorial