Editor's Choice

Which event is the turning point in Julius Caesar: Caesar's assassination or Antony's address?

Quick answer:

The turning point in Julius Caesar is Antony's address, not Caesar's assassination. Brutus's decision to let Antony speak is crucial; although Brutus initially sways the crowd, Antony's speech dramatically shifts public opinion, highlighting Brutus's misjudgment. This pivotal moment marks the conspirators' loss of control and sets the stage for the ensuing chaos and conflict.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Brutus's speech in Act III and his misguided decision to allow Mark Anthony to speak to the mob constitute the play's turning point. At this stage in the play, things could go either way; it isn't obvious which side will prevail. Caesar has been brutally murdered; the common people, the plebs, are angry, confused and fearful. They loved Caesar and so it's essential for the conspirators to quell the masses, to prevent widespread disorder from breaking out. Brutus's speech appears to do precisely that. He goes out of his way to convince his restive audience that he loved Caesar as much as they did; he only participated in his assassination because he genuinely believed that his old friend wanted to make himself king and the people of Rome slaves.

On the face of it, Brutus's speech is a success, but the Roman mob is notoriously fickle. Brutus seems not to realize that the people can be just as easily swayed by an opponent. He's allowed the instant acclamation of the mob to cloud his judgement, ironic indeed given his general contempt towards the common people. Brutus has also made the fatal mistake of accepting at face value Mark Anthony's apparent acquiescence in Caesar's assassination. Underestimating both Mark Anthony and the Roman people is a fatal mistake by Brutus, one that represents a significant turning point in the play. Up until now, the conspirators have had it all their own way, but once Mark Anthony finishes one of the most famous speeches in all English-speaking drama, the tables have turned dramatically and there's to be no going back.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Oooh!  Great question.  While I think careful readers of this play could adequately argue for either one of these choices, I believe the greatest point of tension is not Caesar's death (which happens relatively early on and the play is not the play without the consequences of Brutus' decision to allow Antony to live and to speak at the funeral), but Brutus' veto of Cassius' concerns regarding Antony's threat to the conspirators.  Brutus is not the judge of character that Caesar is.  He sees all people for the good in them...with the exception of Caesar's greed and ambition, the reason Brutus chose to join the conspirators.

Antony follows Brutus' boundaries for speaking at the funeral to a "T".  He speaks well of Caesar, and does not speak "ill" of the conspirators, although he repeats, with a different tone of voice, how "honorable" Brutus and the others are.  This repetition drives home that they are NOT honorable, but traitors to the state and butchers to Caesar.  All events unfold accordingly.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial