Act 2, Scene 1 Summary and Analysis
Summary
A sleepless Brutus paces his orchard, considering an impossible dilemma. Though Caesar must die to protect Rome from dictatorship, Brutus has “no personal cause to spurn at him, / But for the general.” He fears kingship may bring out Caesar’s dominating, cruel streak, the way a bright day “brings forth the adder.” If one thinks of Caesar as a serpent’s egg, he says, then killing that egg before it “hatches” would be prudent. Brutus’s soliloquy is interrupted by his servant Lucius, who brings him one of the forged letters planted by Cinna at Cassius’s prompting. The letter exhorts Brutus to “awaken” and “speak, strike, and redress” against tyranny, urging him to come to a decision. As the sun rises, Lucius informs Brutus that the date is the ides of March.
Cassius enters and introduces Brutus to Trebonius, Decius Brutus, Casca, Cinna, and Metellus Cimber—the “conspirators.” Brutus asks everyone to bring forward their hands and join together in a noble cause. According to Brutus, the group do not need an oath to bind them, as Cassius suggests, because their honest intentions are oath enough. Cassius tells Brutus that Mark Antony should be assassinated along with Caesar, as he is a “shrewd contriver” who may later prove their undoing. However, Brutus shoots down Cassius’s suggestion, saying that Antony without Caesar is as powerless as the limbs of a body whose head has been cut off. Brutus also wants to avoid excessive violence, exhorting the conspirators to “carve” Caesar like a dish fit for the gods rather than fall on him in a savage frenzy.
To ensure that the superstitious Caesar arrives in the Capitol after the tumultuous previous night, Decius Brutus says he will go to Caesar’s home to flatter and coax him into attending the Senate. The group leave. Portia, Brutus’s wife, enters the scene, entreating Brutus to tell her the reason behind his recent secretive and agitated state. Kneeling before Brutus, Portia stabs herself in the thigh to prove she is worthy of his confidence. Moved, Brutus promises to tell Portia all “the secrets of [his] heart” in time. Cais Ligarius arrives to accompany Brutus to the Capitol.
Analysis
Scenes 1 and 2 of act 2 flesh out the characters of Caesar and Brutus, the play’s two tragic heroes. The tragic flaws in both their characters are established, setting up the stage for their eventual fate. Though scene 1 opens with Brutus in a state of great flux about his decision to oppose Caesar, Brutus rather quickly arrives at the conclusion that he has no choice but to assassinate Caesar. Ironically, “noble” Brutus, Caesar’s most beloved friend, is the first in the play to clearly suggest Caesar’s murder. Later in the scene, Brutus describes Caesar’s murder in particularly graphic terms, asking the conspirators to “carve” him as a dish fit for the gods, perhaps revealing a latent cruelty. Further, in an extremely important decision that has far-reaching consequences, Brutus shoots down Cassius’s suggestion of killing Antony along with Caesar. Brutus’s unshakeable belief in the loftiness of his ideals makes him obtuse toward himself and others. In his refusal to view himself objectively, Brutus is closer to Caesar than he thinks.
Expert Q&A
What literary devices does Shakespeare use in Brutus's soliloquy in Julius Caesar, Act 2, Scene 1?
In Brutus's soliloquy in Act 2, Scene 1 of Julius Caesar, Shakespeare employs literary devices such as metaphor and simile to convey Brutus's internal conflict. Brutus uses the metaphor of a snake to represent Caesar, suggesting that crowning Caesar is akin to giving him the power to harm. The simile compares Caesar to a serpent's egg, which should be destroyed before hatching to prevent danger. These devices illustrate Brutus's self-deception and rationalization for assassination.
Why, according to Brutus, don't the conspirators need an oath? What can be inferred about Cassius, Casca, and Brutus in Act 2, Scene 1?
According to Brutus in Act 2, Scene 1, the conspirators do not need an oath because it would undermine the nobility of their cause - the assassination of Caesar. Brutus believes their shared commitment should be enough. Brutus is portrayed as noble but politically naive, seen in his decision not to kill Antony. Cassius is inferred to be a clever politician, aware of Antony's potential threat, while Casca is viewed as somewhat "dull", often merely agreeing with others.
Brutus's deliberation at the beginning of Act 2, Scene 1 in Julius Caesar
At the beginning of Act 2, Scene 1 in Julius Caesar, Brutus deliberates about the necessity of assassinating Caesar. He reasons that although Caesar has not yet become a tyrant, the potential for him to gain absolute power poses a significant threat to Rome. Brutus concludes that it is better to kill Caesar preemptively to protect the Republic from possible tyranny.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.