Illustration of the profiles of a young woman and an older woman facting away from each other

The Joy Luck Club

by Amy Tan

Start Free Trial

Themes: Immigration and Cultural Conflicts

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Suyuan, Lindo, An-mei, and Ying-ying are all first-generation immigrants who struggle to find a balance between Chinese and American cultures. Lindo speaks for all of them when she announces that “Chinese thinking is best.” These women have tried to hold onto their Chinese ways. They value tradition, respect, obedience, and above all, family. They retain their stories and customs and foods. They continue to speak their languages, even as they strive to learn English. They want to keep their Chinese minds and ways.

At the same time, though, the women have left China behind. They have learned English, and they have adopted some American ways. They wear American clothing. They attend a Baptist church. Ying-ying married an American man, who called her “Betty.” America changes them. They are Chinese yet not completely Chinese. Lindo even reflects on how, when she returned to China, people saw her as a foreigner. She wonders if she has lost some of her Chinese face.

To their daughters, however, these women remain so Chinese that it is embarrassing. The younger women want to be completely American. Jing-mei insists that she does not want to be Chinese, even though her mother insists just as firmly that she always will be. Waverly laughs at Chinese customs. Her mother wanted to provide both American circumstances and Chinese character, but Waverly and her siblings largely rejected the latter. Rose marries an American man, as does Lena, but neither of them is happy. Lena is only half-Chinese and has long felt the split within herself between American and Chinese thinking.

By the end of the novel, however, each of the younger women has made some kind of reconnection with her immigrant mother and Chinese heritage. Jing-mei feels Chinese during her trip and experiences Chinese family life firsthand. Waverly looks in the mirror with her mother, accepts their connection, and decides to go to China with Rich for their honeymoon. Rose discovers her mother’s hidden strength and her own as well. Lena learns her mother’s wisdom and the reasons for her struggles. Each one embraces, at least to a point, her Chinese culture.

Expert Q&A

In "A Pair of Tickets" from The Joy Luck Club, how does Amy Tan use images of change, including photography, to develop the idea of "becoming Chinese"?

Change is a theme in "A Pair of Tickets" by Amy Tan. Images used in the story indicate change, such as Jing-Mei's passport picture and the Polaroid pictures she takes.

What does Jing-mei mean by "true Chinese" and does her understanding of it change throughout the story?

Jing-mei's identity as a Chinese American is tested and strengthened over the course of the novel. She starts out anxious about her heritage and whether she can "pass for Chinese," but ultimately feels more closely connected to her Chinese background than she had anticipated.

What details seem familiar and exotic to Jing-mei when she arrives in Guangzhou in "A Pair of Tickets"?

When Jing-mei arrives in Guangzhou, she finds many familiar elements, such as Western-style clothing, crowded buses, and American-style hotel amenities, reflecting her life in San Francisco. However, exotic details also stand out, like the shorter stature of locals, the Cantonese dialect, bamboo scaffolding, and shampoo resembling hoisin sauce. These observations highlight the blending of her American and Chinese identities, emphasizing both familiarity and exoticism in her journey of self-discovery.

Amy Tan's depiction of the American Dream, Chinese-American culture, and generational conflict in The Joy Luck Club

In The Joy Luck Club, Amy Tan explores the American Dream, Chinese-American culture, and generational conflict by depicting the struggles and triumphs of Chinese immigrant mothers and their American-born daughters. The novel highlights cultural clashes, differing values, and the pursuit of success, revealing the complexities of identity and the intergenerational transmission of hopes and expectations.

Why is the opening scene apt for Jing Mei’s remark about "becoming Chinese"?

Why is the opening scene an appropriate setting for Jing-Mei's remark that she is "becoming Chinese"? The Joy Luck Club, where Jing-Mei takes her mother's place, is a symbol of her mother’s past. By stepping into this club and engaging with the stories of its members, Jing-Mei begins to “become Chinese.

In The Joy Luck Club chapters 1–8, how does the writer convey the importance of tradition and culture through An-mei's experiences?

An-mei's experiences highlight the significance of tradition and culture through symbolic events and familial connections. Her scar, from spilling hot soup, serves as a permanent reminder of her mother and the shame tied to her role as a concubine, illustrating how tradition marks individuals. Additionally, her mother's act of cutting her arm to honor her own mother underscores the deep, enduring ties between daughters and their ancestors, reflecting the pervasive influence of cultural heritage.

In "The Joy Luck Club", what stops Jing-Mei from embracing her identity and how does she overcome it?

Jing-Mei struggles to embrace her Chinese identity due to her mother's pressure to succeed and constant comparisons to others, which make her feel inadequate. Her lack of understanding of the Chinese language and culture also contributes to her alienation. However, after joining the Joy Luck Club and replacing her mother, she gains appreciation for her heritage. This realization is solidified when she travels to China to meet her half-sisters, helping her fully embrace her identity.

Why does June May constantly compare China to America in The Joy Luck Club?

June May frequently compares China to America due to the cultural clash she experiences between her Chinese heritage and American upbringing. Her mother's unrealistic expectations, based on traditional Chinese values, exacerbate this conflict, leading June to struggle with her dual identity. Poor communication with her mother further complicates her understanding of her family's background. This cultural dichotomy is a central theme in The Joy Luck Club, highlighting the generational and cultural tensions faced by the characters.

What seems familiar and exotic to June upon her arrival in Guangzhou, and why does she compare China to America?

Upon arriving in Guangzhou, June finds a mix of the familiar and exotic. She is surprised by China's modern aspects, like skyscrapers and hotel amenities, contrasting her expectations of antiquity. This realization makes her reflect on her identity, as the "Chineseness" within her emerges. June also compares China to America, noting the blend of past and present, and is struck by her sisters' resemblance to their mother, challenging her perceptions of them as infants.

Can you explain the multiculturalism in the Joy Luck Club?

Rose is the person who realizes that "she was American too." Rose's mother also feels that she is American. So her mother tries to stop her from dating a white boy. But, Rose thinks that she has the right to date any guy she wants because she is American too. Her mother later tells her that if the relationship with the white boy continues, the boy will be less understanding when they have their first child because they are not Chinese. Rose then decides to break up with him.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Themes: The Mother-Daughter Relationship

Next

Themes: Loss and Grief

Loading...