Illustration of the profiles of a young woman and an older woman facting away from each other

The Joy Luck Club

by Amy Tan

Start Free Trial

Student Question

What do magpies symbolize in The Joy Luck Club?

Quick answer:

In "The Joy Luck Club," magpies symbolize duplicity and the contrasting perspectives of joy and sorrow. They are strategically associated with deception and hypocrisy, highlighting characters' feelings of betrayal and disillusionment with traditional values. The story of magpies hatching from a turtle's tears reflects the idea that one person's sadness can lead to another's happiness. This dual symbolism aligns with the differing Western and Eastern views of magpies as bad omens and good luck, respectively.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Magpies (black birds belonging to the crow family) represent duplicity in The Joy Luck Club. The author strategically places stories and mentions of magpies near real-life occurrences of deception and hypocrisy. This helps the reader to feel the true dimension of the main characters' sense of betrayal, their disillusionment with all the values that they were taught to cherish but grow to find repugnant.

For instance, An-mei tells her daughter Rose a story that her own mother told her, namely that a turtle ate her tears and laid eggs which hatched as magpies. The point of the story was to convey that one person's sadness creates another person's joy. This is a positive interpretation of the story. However, in real life, one would argue that Rose, An-mei, and indeed all the women in the book are entitled to their own happiness, and should not have to settle for the so-called comfort of providing someone else with joy.

Why does the author use magpies to convey opposing meanings? In Western tradition, magpies are considered a bad omen, yet in Eastern tradition, they are considered good luck. The difference in global attitude towards the magpie is a symbol of contradiction and deception. One object, one story, one life, can be viewed from multiple perspectives, and to limit it to one is, in fact, a deception. This is something many characters in the book face, as they find that what they were taught to expect and value in life is not necessarily what they find to be truly important.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial