Setting
Jane Addams: Pioneer for Social Justice opens its narrative with the journey of Jane's parents to the bustling town of Rockford, Illinois. It vividly recounts Jane's formative years spent amidst the serene landscapes of Cedarville, Illinois, and her scholarly pursuits at the esteemed Rockford Female Seminary. The story unfolds predominantly in the vibrant city of Chicago, spanning from the momentous day when Addams inaugurated the Hull House settlement on September 14, 1889, to the echo of her legacy following her passing on May 21, 1935. Throughout, the narrative shines a spotlight on Addams's unwavering dedication to uplifting the impoverished community of Halsted Street.
Style and Technique
Jane Addams: Pioneer for Social Justice showcases the artistry of a masterful storyteller, weaving a tapestry of vibrant and meticulously detailed stories. Meigs transforms individuals into vivid characters, their personalities brought to life through their deeds, while skillfully selecting incidents that captivate and illuminate key facets of Addams’s worldview and experiences. However, the author's penchant for presenting each episode in its entirety occasionally muddles the timeline, causing the narrative to swirl in a series of interwoven spirals. Furthermore, while Meigs's deep admiration for Addams and her ideals infuses the narrative with fervor, at times this zeal feels like an overzealous nudge for readers to embrace Addams’s vision.
Historical Context
Meigs paints Jane Addams as a visionary striding far ahead of her era, a beacon of ideas that once sparked controversy during her lifetime but found a welcoming embrace by the 1930s and stood triumphantly vindicated by 1970. Addams is depicted as a profound influence on Franklin D. Roosevelt's policies and on the evolution of modern social theory. Meigs delves into the various controversies that swirled around Addams, yet portrays her as besieged by the frenzy of the public, the greed of avaricious businessmen, the corruption of politicians, and the hostility of a spiteful press. In essence, Meigs elevates Addams to an idealized status, glossing over her part in stirring opposition. Nevertheless, the biography seems unlikely to stir up disputes today, as it skims over Addams's adversaries, often depicting them as proud or misguided souls. Moreover, the once incendiary issues of the early 1900s now stir only faint echoes of emotion.
It's unmistakable that Meigs holds Addams in high esteem, aligning her perspectives with those of her father's esteemed friend, Abraham Lincoln. She resonates with Addams's conviction in the value of a "useful" life dedicated to providing essential social services. Like Addams, Meigs champions the inherent worth and dignity of every individual, consistently underscoring the notion that those aided by the settlement were "clients," not mere recipients of charity. Meigs illustrates how Hull House naturally evolved to serve its neighborhood and only incidentally became a vanguard of social reform and a crucible for training social workers.
Meigs also highlights the unwavering personal integrity of Addams. She recounts how Addams was deeply affronted by offers of donations tied to abandoning her reformist pursuits. Her response was a blend of indignation and sorrow at the thought of betraying her principles, sometimes lacking finesse in such matters, even embarrassing a Hull House benefactor who had orchestrated a much-needed donation.
Addams's steadfast integrity often spurred her to contest "routine conventions," like her challenge to the "alderman system" of patronage and graft in Chicago. Her attempts to unseat John Power, the alderman for Hull House's ward, met with failure, leading her to recognize that genuine reform awaited the people's readiness. However, her efforts earned her the respect of Alderman Power, who offered any support Hull House might need. Yet, as Meigs stresses, Addams's principles would not permit her to accept aid from Power.
Meigs observes that Addams...
(This entire section contains 709 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
throughout her life had a "tendency to support unpopular causes." Appointed to the Citizens' Arbitration Committee during the Pullman strike of 1893, she allied herself with the trade unions. This stance prompted Chicago newspapers to dub her a "dangerous liberal," and estranged her from George Pullman, once a friend of Hull House, who withdrew his support and became a lifelong adversary.
Addams's insistence on fair treatment for anarchists proved even more contentious. She secured legal representation for the sister of an unarmed anarchist fatally shot by a policeman, and later, after President William McKinley's assassination, she was asked to check on an anarchist newspaper editor detained by Chicago police. Though she gained permission from Mayor Carter Harrison for the visit, and the editor was eventually cleared, Addams faced denunciation.
Among Addams's collaborators in the crusade to better factory conditions was Illinois governor John Altgeld, who became the state's pariah when he pardoned three men imprisoned for their roles in the 1886 Haymarket Riot. At his funeral, few dared to speak, yet Addams did, standing among only three willing to do so, once more accused of anarchist sympathies, which cost Hull House the backing of Mrs. Potter Palmer, a formidable Chicago society figure.
Throughout her enduring advocacy for pacifism, Addams often courted unpopularity. Her steadfast principles granted her considerable political clout. Theodore Roosevelt, even as he vehemently criticized her book Newer Ideals of Peace (1907), acknowledged her as a persuasive argument for women's suffrage. At the Progressive Party convention in 1912, Roosevelt invited her to second his presidential nomination. Active during that campaign and again in 1916, she endorsed Woodrow Wilson, viewing him as the peace candidate. Her staunch opposition to U.S. involvement in World War I earned her accolades while neutrality held sway, but vilification once America joined the fray. She further stoked public ire by raising funds to assist Herbert Hoover and the Relief Commission in alleviating famine in postwar Germany.
Bibliography
Addams, Jane.Forty Years at Hull-House. New York: Macmillan, 1935. Released soon after Addams's passing, this single volume artfully melds her renowned autobiographies: Twenty Years at Hull-House (1910) and Second Twenty Years at Hull-House (1929). Within its pages, Addams shares intimate reflections and narrates her encounters with social reform and the settlement house movement.
Carpenter, Humphrey and Mari Prichard. "Meigs, Cornelia Lynde." In The Oxford Companion to Children's Literature. New York: Oxford University Press, 1984. A concise biographical entry.
Davis, Allen F.American Heroine: The Life and Legend of Jane Addams. New York: Oxford University Press, 1973. An "intellectual biography" that endeavors to "delve into the legend of Jane Addams, while also connecting the legend to the factual tapestry of her life, revealing how the two became intricately linked."
Visual Education
Jane Addams. Famous Women of America Series. Chicago: Society for Visual Education, 1974. The Singer Education Division crafted this filmstrip, record, and teacher's guide, complete with vocabulary drills, reflection and discussion questions, and ideas for further exploration. Narrated through Ellen Starr's perspective, the story illustrates "the metamorphosis of Jane Addams's childhood vision into the tangible reality of the Hull Mansion settlement house."
Literary Accounts
Judson, Clara Ingram.City Neighbor: The Story of Jane Addams. New York: Scribner's, 1951. A narrative chronicling pivotal moments in Addams's life, highlighting the evolution of her character and the formation of her ideals.
Lasch, Christopher, ed.The Social Thought of Jane Addams. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill, 1965. A timeline and compilation of Addams's insights on social challenges.
Liberal Tradition
Levine, Daniel.Jane Addams and the Liberal Tradition. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1980. An exploration of Addams's journey and influence, developing the assertion that she was "a significant driving force" in the surge of social reform during twentieth-century America.
Linn, James Weber.Jane Addams: A Biography. 1935. Reprint. New York: Greenwood Press, 1968. Penned by her nephew and literary trustee, this biography delves into Addams's personal and familial archives.
