Discussion Topic

The hardships and problems faced by the Jamestown settlers

Summary:

The Jamestown settlers faced numerous hardships, including hostile relations with Indigenous peoples, severe food shortages, disease, and harsh environmental conditions. Many settlers succumbed to starvation and illness, exacerbated by their lack of farming skills and fresh water. The "Starving Time" during the winter of 1609-1610 was particularly devastating, reducing the population drastically and threatening the colony's survival.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What hardships did the Jamestown settlers face?

In May 1607, 104 settlers established a permanent colony at Jamestown. Life for these settlers was very hard and, by the end of the first year, only 38 of these men and women survived. Here are some of the hardships they faced:

  • The Jamestown settlers faced food shortages because they spent their early days searching for gold instead of farming.
  • The water around Jamestown was brackish and not suitable for drinking. It was also a breeding ground for mosquitoes, causing serious illness among the settlers, especially malaria, dysentery and typhoid.
  • Many members of the local native tribe, the Powhatans, were sceptical and wary of the settlers. Though the settlers were able to establish trade with the natives, relations between the two were not always good. According to Captain John Smith, some natives were warm and hospitable while other discharged arrows. 
  • The settlers faced cold and harsh winters, especially in their first year. 
Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

Problems for the Jamestown colonists began almost as soon as they arrived in Virginia. At first, their chosen site of settlement seemed to have the necessary advantages, such as a deep water anchorage and natural defenses. However, they soon found that these were outweighed by some serious flaws.

First of all, the site of the colony had little in the way of fresh water. The water in the nearby river was frequently too salty for human consumption. It also took some time before the colonists made the link between refuse disposal and unsafe drinking water. Until 1610, they frequently deposited refuse too close to their limited supply of drinking water, which led to outbreaks of disease.

Furthermore, malaria and other possible mosquito-borne illnesses were common, since the local marshy environment was an ideal home for this parasitic insect. With limited medical supplies and knowledge, many of the colonists succumbed to diseases in the first years of settlement.

Although initial relations with the local Powhatan were promising, things began to sour by 1609. Faced with famine, the English settlers frequently requested food from the Indigenous population, something that the Powhatans soon began to bristle at. Relations became so strained that most colonists refused to leave the fort during the winter of 1609-1610 out of fear of being killed by their Indigenous neighbors.

Although they had sent for supplies in 1609, the resupply ship from England had wrecked on Bermuda. As a result, food supplies dwindled even more and colonists were forced to eat whatever they could scrounge, including leather, horses, and, in some extreme instances, each other. This period became known as the "starving time." When the resupply party finally arrived in Jamestown the following spring, they found the colony barely clinging to existence. The fort was in near ruins, and most of the colonists were dead.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

As seems to have been a recurrent situation in the British colonization of the Eastern seaboard, the Jamestown colonists arrived in Virginia with very little preparation for what they were about to face. Many died, and it is remarkable that any survived at all.

While early colonists included working-class people with needed skill sets, such as carpentry and masonry abilities, other colonists were upper-class men who thought that coming to Virginia would mean easy money: they would find gold and return to England wealthy. They did not want to work and became a drag on a society with extremely limited resources, leading the colony to establish rules linking getting fed to doing work.

The early colonists faced hostile Indigenous cultures that did not want to tolerate a permanent settlement in their territory, a problem exacerbated by the primitive understanding the English had of how to approach cultural difference. A related problem was the assumption that farming in Virginia could be done as it had been in England, with little anticipation of the effects of different climate and soil on crop yields. This assumption also meant that other priorities took the lead in determining where to establish the colony. Fearful of Spanish raids, the colonists made moving inland up the James River and away from Spanish view a priority, picking a swampy, mosquito-infested area in which to settle.

In the end, the colonists were both lucky and able to learn enough about what was needed to survive to gain a foothold, despite large losses of life early on.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

The Jamestown colonists encountered a number of very serious problems over a prolonged period of time. First and foremost, the native soil was not to their liking, as it was completely different from what they had experienced at home. Inevitably, this made it difficult for the first settlers to grow crops, which in turn led to severe food shortages.

The swampy atmosphere of Jamestown also presented severe difficulties to the settlers. It soon became clear that this particular patch of the New World was a breeding ground for mosquitoes, which spread diseases that took the lives of many of the newcomers.

Medical knowledge at that time was rudimentary, to the say the least. But in any case, the English settlers, hailing as they did from much cooler climes, had no experience of dealing with such diseases. This left them especially vulnerable to diseases spread by mosquitoes.

In addition, the Jamestown settlers had to deal with Indigenous tribes who were naturally upset at the encroachments upon their land. Native Americans launched regular attacks upon Jamestown, killing numerous settlers. Hostilities between the two sides escalated until 1622, when the Powhatan Confederacy launched an all-out assault on Jamestown, killing almost 350 men, women, and children in the process.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

The first settlers of Jamestown endured the problems of hostile Indians, starvation, and poor leadership and government. Jamestown was the second English Colony in the New World (Roanoke being the first) and the Indians attacked the settlers within 3 days of arrival in May of 1607. An uneasy truce kept warfare down to periodic guerilla raids on both sides, and by 1609 the settlers have supplies from England and corn from the Indians, with whom they began trade. But by winter, as Indians refuse to trade corn, the 500 settlers are starving, and provide the only examples of European cannibalism in Virginia. By spring, less than 100 are alive. Many Englishmen take refuge with the Indians, under their chief, Powhatan. By summer, the governor of Virginia, Lord De La Warr, attempts to negotiate for their return, but Powhatan replies with "noe other then prowde and disdayneful Answers." The governor raids Indian villages, kills the inhabitants, including the queen of one of the tribes, who was stabbed to death. Throwing her children into the James River, he begins "shoteinge owtt their Braynes in the water." Astonishingly, he also orders all Indian corn to be cut down in the field to induce starvation among them! By 1612, the governor orders Englishmen "...to be hanged Some burned Some to be broken upon wheles others to be staked and some to be shott to death," for leaving Jamestown and living among the Indians.

American Slavery, American Freedom, Morgan, 1975

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

The colonists arrived at Jamestown on May 13, 1607. At that time, historians estimate that over 14,000 Powhatan Indians lived in Virginia. One of the most apparent problems facing the colonists was communicating with the existing inhabitants. These early settlers also experienced major food shortages and poor medical care resulting in disease and illness. After 8 months only 34 of the original 104 were still alive. It is estimated that 1 out of every 6 settlers dies within the first year at the settlement.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

As well as the hunger and dangers posed by the Native Americans, the settlers at Jamestown faced an additional hardship when an accidental fire broke out. This happened in January of 1608 and the fire destroyed all but three of the houses that the settlers had built. Also destroyed were the storehouse and ammunition. (See the reference link provided.)

As a result of the fire, the settlers now had to face the rest of the winter without adequate shelter. They also had to rebuild everything that had been destroyed. Given that they faced so many other problems, like a lack of food, this placed a significant burden on the settlers. We can only imagine how the fire must have impacted on their morale.

It was also around this time that Captain Smith arrived with an additional 100 settlers. Although he brought supplies with him and a number of skilled workers, the need to provide housing for these extra people must have weighed very heavily on the settlers’ minds.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

The early years of the Jamestown settlement were especially harsh, so much so that something like three quarters of the original population died within the first three years. The biggest problem for the English settlers was that they were unfamiliar with Virginian soil. This made it impossible for them to grow sufficient crops to feed themselves. Emergency supplies were sent from England, but they took way too long to arrive, and when they finally did, it was often too little, too late.

Settlers also had to deal with regular attacks from disgruntled indigenous tribes. Jamestown had, after all, been founded on land that belonged to the Native Americans, and, not unreasonably, they took objection to this. They staged deadly incursions into Jamestown in the hope of intimidating the English settlers and getting them to pack up and leave. They were unsuccessful in this endeavor, though they did succeed in decimating the settler population. On one particularly notorious occasion, the Powhatan tribe, who'd previously been on relatively good terms with the settlers, massacred a quarter of the Virginia colony in a single day.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

The Jamestown settlers faced a number of hardships; three of the most prominent hardships were food shortages, disease, and hostile Indians. The colony was originally founded as a money-making enterprise, so the early settlers did not place enough emphasis on growing food. The lack of food caused the Jamestown settlers to become malnourished, which in turn made them more susceptible to diseases such as typhoid and dysentery.

Additionally, the local Powhatan Indians were often quite hostile to the Englishmen at Jamestown. During the winter of 1609-1610, these Indians placed Jamestown under siege; this intensified the lack of food the Jamestown settlers faced, because they could not even leave the fort to hunt wild game. Only 60 of the 300 (or 500, depending on the account) Jamestown settlers survived the winter, which became known as the "Starving Time."

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

The settlers at Jamestown faced many problems. One of these problems was a lack of food. The settlers were not familiar with the land, and the area in which they settled was not the best area for farming. Additionally, not everybody farmed. There were people who searched for minerals because there was an expectation back in England that this colony needed to be profitable. Thus, instead of everybody working to produce enough food, some people were searching for minerals.

The effect of disease was another issue the settlers faced. The settlers didn’t have immunities to diseases in the Americas. As a result, many died of diseases such as malaria. The development of the colony was not an easy one. Many who originally came did not survive. The problems of a lack of food and disease were very difficult to overcome.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

The settlers at Jamestown faced many challenges.  One challenge was dealing with unfriendly Native Americans.  Because of this concern, the settlers felt unsafe venturing away from their settlement.  This was a big concern because the settlers needed food.  This brings us to a second problem which was the lack of food.  The settlers at Jamestown didn't have enough food.  Because they felt unsafe moving away from the settled area, shortages of food were a big concern.  Many colonists died from a lack of food.  A third issue the colonists faced was weather.  One reason why there was a shortage of food was because the area was experiencing one of the worst droughts ever in this region.  This made growing crops very difficult.  In addition, the winters were brutal.  Many colonists died from the hardships they faced during the harsh winter.  The colonists faced many challenges while they were at Jamestown.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

Off the top of my head, good drinking water seems to have been a challange.  Many of the earliest Jamestown colonists died and it is thought to have been from drinking the stagnant water in the James River on whose bank they built their settlement.

Posted on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

The general problem that the Jamestown settlement faced was that they were unable to feed and care for themselves.  The other major problem was that they picked a bad place for their settlement.

The site that they chose was not very good.  It was near to a swamp and the swamp was a good breeding place for disease.  This was especially true because they used it as a sewer as well.

The settlers were also not very well suited for being settlers.  They were not craftsmen and farmers.  Instead, most of them were more upper class and were not used to doing the kind of work that would allow them to survive.  This is why, for example, John Smith had to impose his famous rule where he said that only those who worked would get to eat.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

Jamestown was a very troubled colony. The adventurers who came initially had no idea about farming—their plan was to find gold or a waterway to China, thus securing themselves riches with the least amount of work. Many colonists starved to death as a result.

There was also the problem of malaria and yellow fever. The colonists decided to settle in a backwater, where the natives knew better than to live in. As a result, malaria killed several every fall and weakened still more. This was a problem throughout the American colonies, as the cause of malaria was unknown for many years.

There was also the problem of relations with the Native Americans. This did not start with the colony; rather, it was only after the colony was established and English agriculture started to adversely affect Native American life that the natives and the whites went to war with each other. Though the Powhatan people had some victories against the colonists, they were no match for the diseases of the English.

There was also the problem of profitability. The English tried various staples including silk, but it was tobacco that became their major cash crop. While tobacco was a globally traded commodity, it was not be enough to save the investors in Jamestown. The colony was a royal colony within a few years of its founding.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

The 144 Englishmen who established the colony at Jamestown in 1607 went there with the purpose of finding gold. As a result, the colonists spent very little farming and this created one of their first problems: they did not have a steady food supply in place and were threatened with starvation. 

The location of the Jamestown colony, on swampy, marshland, also created another problem very early on. Swarms of mosquitoes descended on the colonists and brought with them numerous cases of malaria. If that wasn't bad enough, they also faced a cold, harsh winter. By the end of the first year, only 38 of the original of the 144 colonists had survived.

Once the colony was established, more and more people began to arrive. This exacerbated the problem of low food supplies. Reports suggest that one colonist was so hungry that he ate his own wife. 

Financially, the colony proved a complete disaster. Having failed to find gold, the colonists turned to the production of tobacco but this was not enough to make the colony successful. In 1624, King James I declared the Virginia Company, the sponsors of the Jamestown colony, bankrupt. 

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

Actually, poor diplomacy with the Indians was NOT a problem, in fact the colony proudly would have disappeared from starvation had it not been for help from the local Pumunkey Indian tribe. The Indians grew several varieties of maize (corn) and not only showed the colonists how to plant it; but also traded with them for hatchets, metal tools, swords and muskets.

Aside from this the initial problems confronting the colony were:

  • Most of the people who settled the colony were townspeople who did not know how to farm. They only learned how from the Indians.
  • Others were of the gentlemanly class who had come to search for gold and considered physical labor beneath them, even when necessary for survival.
  • The settlers all lacked hunting skills. The area was plentiful with game animals; yet they did not have the ability to hunt for them.
  • As noted above, supply ships from England were largely undependable.

The colony probably would have collapsed were it not for the leadership of John Smith. Smith was difficult and quarrelsome, but had been chosen by the London Company to manage the colony. With iron fisted rules, he forced the colonists to work and they thereby survived; until Smith was injured and had to return to England for medical treatment. Their worst days were after Smith left, the so-called "starving time" when they ran out of food. Things were so bad that one man who had married an Indian woman killed her and salted her down for food. During the winter of 1609-1610 out of 600 settlers, only 80 survived. They were saved this time by the arrival of Sir Thomas Gates who also imposed hard nosed discipline.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

Early Jamestown was almost a failure like the colonies before it. Some of the apparent problems were poor diplomacy with the natives, which resulted in armed attacks, poor agricultural planning, which resulted in starvation, and poor water supplies which caused dysentery.  As a result, the colony almost died out.  Ships from England failed to arrive on as scheduled; and finally, the colony originally had little to keep it economically viable through trade with England.

Another part of the problem were the unrealistic expectations harbored by some of the colonists, many of which were of the landed gentry in England looking to expand their estates, and were not willing to engage in the hard labor of farming.  However, under good leadership, and the discovery of tobacco as a valued commodity, the colony survived and was thriving by the 1620's.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

In 1607, 144 English men and boys travelled to America and established a colony called Jamestown. Their motivations for leaving England were purely financial: they believed that America was rich in gold and they wanted to make money but, from its earliest days, the colony was plagued by problems.

To begin, the Jamestown colony was financed by investors from the Virginia Company of London who threatened to remove their financial support, should the colonists not find any gold. As a result, the colonists spent the majority of their time searching for gold instead of farming and maintaining a steady supply of food. When winter came, the colonists were completely unprepared. Hunger soon followed and the camp was further ravaged by malaria and a host of other infectious diseases - which historians now know were caused by the camp's unhealthy swamp location and a contaminated water supply. 

When more colonists arrived in 1608, food supplies became even more scarce and existing diseases ravaged many of its newest ranks. By the end of the first year, only 38 of the original 144 colonists still survived.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What problems did the Jamestown colonists face?

The first settlers at Jamestown encountered many problems. One issue the settlers faced was a lack of food. Part of the reason for this was that the settlers spent a lot of time looking for gold. They knew that if the settlement was not profitable, those who supported the establishment of this settlement would withdraw their financial support of it. As a result, not enough time was spent raising crops. Therefore, hunger was a big issue.

Along with a lack of food, there were other issues. The spread of disease throughout the settlement was one of these issues. Malaria led to the death of many settlers. The winters were also harsh. The settlers weren’t prepared for the harsh winters. This also led to the death of many of the settlers. With all of these issues, the death rate was much higher than the survival rate.

The settlement was also not successful financially. Eventually, the colony went bankrupt and was taken over by the King of England.

There were many problems with the settlement at Jamestown.  

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on