Illustration of Jack Worthing in a top hat and formal attire, and a concerned expression on his face

The Importance of Being Earnest

by Oscar Wilde

Start Free Trial

How does Wilde contrast the characters Algernon and Jack in The Importance of Being Earnest?

Quick answer:

Wilde develops a contrast between Algernon and Jack through the use of irony. Despite the fact that the two men do remarkably similar, unethical things, only Algernon is open about his lack of integrity while Jack adopts a superior moral tone that his actual behaviors do not support.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In my mind, Algernon and Jack are a lot more similar than they are different, which makes sense considering that they are actually—unbeknownst to them for most of the play—brothers. Ironically, Jack seems to adopt a higher moral tone than Algernon, despite the fact that they basically do the same...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

thing: invent a person who gives them an escape from uncomfortable or restrictive social engagements and responsibilities. Both men lie about their identities—each one claiming to be the elusive (and totally imaginary) Ernest Worthing—to woo the women they love: both Gwendolen Fairfax and Cecily Cardew both claim to have always wanted to marry someone by the name of Ernest. Both even try to arrange secret baptisms so that they can be rechristened with the name Ernest! Algernon, at least, seems somewhat more forthcoming about his relative lack of integrity; he seems to take very little seriously in life and makes a joke out of anything. Jack, however, maintains this sort of holier-than-thou attitude despite the fact that he is just as dishonest as Algernon. He really has no right to think of himself as somehow more ethical or proper than Algernon because the two are remarkably similar; thus, Wilde develops a contrast between them through the use ofirony.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does Oscar Wilde present the characters of Jack and Algernon in The Importance of Being Earnest?

Wilde presents these characters via indirect characterization.  No one directly describes Jack or Algernon; readers (or viewers) must mine their conversations for clues about their characters and motivations.  It is not difficult, given the nature of their first conversation with one another in the play.  For example, Jack insists that, "When one is in town one amuses oneself.  When one is in the country one amuses other people.  It is excessively boring."  Then, a few lines later he declares that all his neighbors are "Perfectly horrid!" and that he never speaks to any of them.  Contradictory statements like these help us to understand that Jack is a somewhat ridiculous character.  He doesn't seem to really mean anything he says because he is just as liable to contradict it in the next breath.  Likewise, he admits (after the debacle with the cigarette case) that his name is actually Jack when Algernon has only ever known him as "Ernest," because he has invented a younger brother by this name so that he has an excuse to come to town and do all the things Jack cannot do (i.e. gamble, drink, and so forth).  Jack feels obligated to maintain a high moral tone because he is the guardian of a young woman named Cecily, but -- via Ernest -- he can get up to all the somewhat less moral behaviors in which he longs to indulge in the city.  Thus, we learn that he is quite dishonest and has a bit of a dark side that he hopes to conceal forever from his family and friends in the country.

We learn about Algernon's character in a similar manner.  We know that there are cucumber sandwiches at the beginning of Act 1, and he will not allow Jack/Ernest to eat them because they have been specially prepared for Algernon's Aunt Augusta.  However, Algernon eats them all himself throughout the course of the scene!  Then, when Aunt August arrives for tea, Algernon seems seriously displeased and surprised that there are no cucumber sandwiches when he has actually eaten them all himself.  We learn, then, that he is likewise ridiculous and dishonest.  He has also invented an friend, named Mr. Bunbury, so that he can escape Aunt August as often as he wishes, saying that he must attend his poor invalid friend.  He and Jack are very similar in these ways.

It is through listening in to their conversations and the utterly ridiculous statements they make about social convention, love, marriage, and the like that reveal to us who they are.

Last Updated on