Themes: War
The Iliad is an epic poem that exalts a nation’s grand conflict, delineating the "heroes" from the "villains" from that nation's perspective. In ancient Greece, epics were the prevalent form of literature, unlike the more intimate poetry we often see today. By celebrating warfare and a simplistic model of masculinity, Homer adhered to the traditions of his time. However, his depiction of the Trojan War doesn't ignore the brutal truths of war and its toll on individuals.
Homer portrays Paris as a coward—he desires Helen but lacks the courage to fight in the war his actions sparked. The hesitance of Artemis and Aphrodite to participate serves as comic relief. In contrast, Achilles and Hector fully engage with war, accepting its motivations and consequences. Achilles fights driven by anger and later for revenge, while Hector battles for honor and his convictions. Both prefer a warrior's death over a long, peaceful existence. Athena is depicted as a goddess willing to support the war's grandeur. For Homer’s mostly military audience, combat demonstrated a warrior's honor and integrity, while avoiding it signaled laziness, fear, or selfishness.
The "wars" within The Iliad extend beyond the battle between Troy and Greece. Achilles and Agamemnon clash over issues of pride and honor, leading Achilles to ultimately abandon his comrades, highlighting both his warrior spirit and his selfishness. Similarly, Hector and Paris argue over Paris’s refusal to take responsibility and join the battle he helped ignite. These internal conflicts are as crucial to the epic as the physical confrontations on the battlefield.
While Homer is invested in the Trojan War and its resolution, The Iliad also serves as a cautionary tale. Horrific deaths are prevalent, as seen with Patroclus and Hector; women become spoils of war, enslaved or prostituted by the victors; a plague devastates the Greek camp, killing many soldiers; and as the war drags on, fatigue and despair take root. Achilles notes that all men, brave or not, face the same fate. Homer suggests that how a man lives holds more significance than death itself. The epic leaves the question of whether war is worthwhile unresolved, presenting a tension between the desire for peace and the need to fight for justice. Each side has legitimate reasons for fighting, yet a conflict that could have been resolved with a simple fistfight escalates into a full-scale war while the instigator remains on the sidelines. Homer reveals that war, its causes, and its consequences are far more complex than a straightforward hero tale can capture.
Expert Q&A
How did Hector die in Homer's Iliad?
Hector's death in the Iliad occurs when he faces Achilles outside the walls of Troy. Despite his fear, Hector confronts Achilles, leading to a duel where both exchange spear throws. Ultimately, Achilles kills Hector by thrusting a spear into his neck. From a divine perspective, Hector's fate was predetermined by the gods, notably Zeus and Apollo, who had destined his downfall despite their previous protection.
Why was it dangerous for King Priam to ransom Hector's body in the Iliad?
It was dangerous for King Priam to ransom Hector's body because he had to cross enemy lines and enter Achilles' camp, risking his life. Achilles, in deep grief over Patroclus' death, was desecrating Hector's body as revenge. Despite divine interventions urging both to proceed with the ransom, Priam faced the threat of being killed by Achilles, who was in a volatile state. The act required immense courage and vulnerability from Priam.
Why does Apollo assist Hector and the Trojans in the Iliad?
Apollo assists Hector and the Trojans in the Iliad due to his anger at the Greeks for dishonoring his priest, Chryses. Agamemnon's disrespect towards Chryses prompts Apollo to send a plague to punish the Greeks. This conflict leads to Agamemnon taking Achilles' prize, Briseis, causing Achilles to withdraw from battle. Apollo's support for Troy creates an imbalance, making Hector and the Trojans more formidable against the Greeks until Achilles returns.
What message does Homer convey through his vivid portrayal of the Trojan War in the Iliad?
Homer's portrayal of the Trojan War in The Iliad highlights the values of courage, honor, and glory in his society. Despite the vivid depictions of war's brutality, Homer does not convey an anti-war message; instead, he emphasizes that the horrors of war amplify its honor and heroism. Additionally, the epic underscores the divine influence over human conflicts and the tangible consequences of abstract emotions, such as love and desire, leading to catastrophic outcomes.
What role does war play in the Iliad and is it presented as good or bad?
What is the reason for the Greeks and Trojans' conflict in the Iliad?
The conflict in the "Iliad" arises from both human and divine causes. On the human level, it is sparked by Paris of Troy abducting Helen from Menelaus, prompting the Greeks to wage war to reclaim her. On the divine level, the gods' involvement stems from a beauty contest judged by Paris, who chose Aphrodite over Hera and Athena, leading to divine discord and siding against Troy. Thus, the war combines personal vendetta and divine manipulation.
What was the main focus of Homer's Iliad?
The main focus of Homer's Iliad is the end of the 10 year-long Greek siege of Troy, beginning with Achilles's refusal to fight and ending with his slaying of the Trojan prince Hector. In its 24 books, the poet explains the events that led to the war, as well as rendering in grisly detail the conditions on the ground and deeds of both human warriors and the gods.
What does the Iliad teach us about war?
The Iliad teaches us that fighting in war is central to honor and manhood, but that it exacts a high price. It also teaches that the gods are close at hand and are the ones who make the final decisions about who wins and loses.
In Homer's Iliad, why are the gods fighting over Troy?
The gods in the Iliad are involved in the Trojan War due to personal biases and familial ties. Some gods support sides because they have children fighting, like Aphrodite with her son Aeneas for the Trojans, and Thetis with Achilles for the Greeks. Others are motivated by grudges, such as Hera and Athena against Paris. The gods' allegiances shift, reflecting their human-like behavior and personal vendettas.
Does Homer glorify violence or express sorrow behind the brutality in The Iliad?
Homer's depiction of violence in The Iliad reflects the cultural values of his time, where war was seen as honorable and necessary. Although Homer portrays violence graphically, it is not glorified; rather, it is a means to resolve conflicts. He humanizes both Greeks and Trojans, showing the tragedy of war through characters like Hector. Phrases like "darkness covered his eyes" suggest Homer's awareness of the gravity of death, emphasizing sorrow over glorification.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
