Themes: Fate and Chance
The concept of fate, or destiny, is mentioned explicitly over forty times in the Iliad. It appears in expressions like “red death and strong fate seized his eyes.” The most notable and extensive discussion of fate is found in Book 16 (starting at line 433), where Zeus ponders whether to save his son Sarpedon from his destined demise at the hands of Patroclus. Fate also plays a vital role in the poem's “subtext,” the underlying narrative that readers can infer “between the lines.”
Homer's portrayal of fate is somewhat ambiguous. Often, as when Zeus balances “two fateful portions of death” on his scales, or when Achilles considers the two possible outcomes of his life in Book 9, it seems that a person's destiny is set at birth and unchangeable, even by the gods. However, in Sarpedon's story, Hera's words at line XVI.444 and thereafter suggest that Zeus could alter destiny but chooses not to, possibly because he fears the ridicule of other gods or the potential chaos that could result.
Expert Q&A
How do gods and goddesses influence human life and destruction in the Iliad?
The involvement of the gods and goddesses in human life in the Iliad can be seen as devious and manipulative. They treat the combatants in the Trojan War as pawns in a game of chess, to be moved around as and when the gods feel like it. This undoubtedly aggravates the situation, leading to more death, bloodshed, and destruction.
What is Zeus's will in the Iliad?
Discuss fate vs. free will in the Iliad.
In the Iliad, the tension between fate and free will is central to the Trojan War's narrative. Homer acknowledges fate's power, as seen in the "will of the Gods," suggesting that humans cannot alter their destinies. Characters like Hector illustrate this tragic understanding. However, Homer also emphasizes free will, portraying characters striving for greatness (arete) through autonomy. Thus, while fate limits them, their pursuit of freedom defines their humanity.
What is the significance of how gods treat humans in the Iliad?
In the "Iliad," gods treat humans with capriciousness, reflecting their own flaws and biases. They wield immense power over human affairs, often intervening based on personal favoritism, yet they are also affected by the mortal conflict. This intervention often shows gods behaving more like flawed humans, while humans like Hector and Achilles demonstrate noble qualities, creating an inversion of expected roles. This dynamic highlights the complex interplay between divine and mortal realms in Homer's narrative.
The role and definition of fate in Homer's Iliad
In Homer's Iliad, fate is portrayed as a predetermined and unchangeable destiny that governs the lives of gods and mortals alike. Characters often acknowledge their fates, which are decreed by the gods and cannot be altered, emphasizing the inevitability of their paths and the limited control they have over their own lives.
The significance of divine intervention in Homer's Iliad
Divine intervention in Homer's Iliad significantly influences the plot and character actions. The gods frequently intervene in human affairs, supporting their favored mortals and altering the course of events. This constant divine presence highlights the belief in the gods' control over fate and destiny, emphasizing the limited power of humans in the face of divine will.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
