In the Iliad's first book, what are Achilles's and Agamemnon's views on their personal responsibilities and the Greek's common welfare?

Quick answer:

In book 1 of the Iliad, in the quarrel between Achilles and Agamemnon over the girl, what is Achilles’s view of his responsibility for himself and for the common welfare of the Greeks? What is Agamemnon’s view? In other words, what are their positions here about the situation as it affects themselves, each other, and the rest of the Greeks? Quote at least three words or phrases directly as evidence. In book 1 of Homer’s Iliad, there is a quarrel between Achilles and Agamemnon over a girl named Chryseis. The quarrel demonstrates their selfish and sacrificial views.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In book 1 of Homer’s Iliad, the quarrel between Achilles and Agamemnon over the girl demonstrates their selfish and sacrificial views. Agamemnon thinks he deserves to keep Chryseis. Chryseis’s father, Chryses, asks Agamemnon to give her back. Agamemnon is insulted. He replies with indignation and threats. According to Achilles, Agamemnon thinks of himself as, in Caroline Alexander's translation, “the best man in the army.” His big ego prevents him from sacrificing his prize. Agamemnon asks Achilles, “Do you intend—while you yourself have a prize—that I just sit here / without one?”

The view of Achilles seems to be that Agamemnon needs to get over himself. He wants Agamemnon to understand that he is responsible for the predicament of the soldiers. Achilles tells Agamemnon that neither he nor the other Greek soldiers fought the Trojans out of personal animosity. “But we followed you, O great shameless one, for your pleasure,” says Achilles. Achilles and the soldiers sacrificed for him, so Agamemnon should take their welfare into consideration.

Agamemnon is aware that his actions have had horrible consequences, like a long plague. Agamemnon is “willing to give her back” so that his “men be safe rather than perish.” Yet Agamemnon’s willingness to surrender Chryseis is conditional. He wants another prize of “equal value.” Since no such prize is offered, Agamemnon holds onto Chryseis.

Agamemnon's selfish views enrage Achilles. He threatens to kill Agamemnon. Eventually, Achilles takes reasonability for deescalating the quarrel. Begrudgingly, Achilles lets Agamemnon have Briseis, his “prize,” so that Chryseis can return to her dad.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial