Discussion Topic

Differences between Homer's Iliad and the movie Troy

Summary:

The movie Troy differs from Homer's Iliad in several key ways. The film condenses the timeline, omits the gods' direct involvement, and alters character fates, such as Agamemnon's and Menelaus' deaths, which do not occur in the epic. Additionally, the movie focuses more on the romance between Paris and Helen, while the Iliad emphasizes the broader conflict and heroism.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What are the differences between the movie Troy and the Iliad?

While the film retains the enmity between Achilles and Agamemnon, and the causes of the Trojan war, it departs significantly in the way that it aligns Achilles and Hector with a more modern, melodramatic "Hollywood" attitude toward honor and honorable conduct. At times the film characters directly contradict the behaviors of their written counterparts, specifically in ways that are meant to make them more sympathetic to the audience, even though it comes at the expense of the principles of the original story and our ability to believe the film.

One example of this is the absence of the character Chryseis, and Achilles's attitude toward Briseis. In the Iliad , Chryseis is a Trojan woman given to Agamemnon as a spoil of war, but her father is a priest of Apollo, who calls upon the god to avenge the capture of his daughter, and Agamemnon is forced to return Chryseis. This...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

hurts his pride, and he takes Briseis, another Trojan girl, who had been given to Achilles and was apparently perfectly happy with Achilles. In the film, Chryseis is not featured, and while Briseis is initally given to Achilles, he has a single conversation with her before she is taken by Agamemnon, sparking a violent reaction from Achilles that seems wholly disproportionate to the investment he has, or should have, in Briseis. This seems to paint Achilles as a "gentleman" figure, defending Briseis as a woman beset by male aggression, when in fact the written character had no problem seeing women as property to be won and traded in war; his great dispute came from the fact that taking her was a blow to Achilles's pride, rather than a human rights violation.

Another similar "ennobling" of the characters compared to their written counterpart involves Paris's duel with Menelaus. In the Iliad, Paris is said to be boastful, but cowed when he sees Menelaus parting the Greek lines to face him. Hector reproaches Paris, and Paris returns to fight, seemingly at terms with his fate. Menelaus bests him, but Aphrodite causes Paris to disappear before Menelaus can kill him. Because the film eschews the presence and intervention of gods that is so prevalent in the Iliad, Paris is made to survive the encounter by means of Hector killing Menelaus, purely because Paris is "my brother!", said with a tone of melodramatic severity. We are meant to understand that the violation of the treaty, and the fact that this act will plunge Troy back into war, killing thousands, is less important than the bond of brotherhood or the fact that Paris proved himself a coward moments earlier.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

One of the major differences between the movie and Homer's epic poem is that the Iliad ends with the funeral of Hector, whereas the movie goes on to portray other events (e.g., the wooden horse) that do not occur in the Iliad.

Likewise, by the end of the movie, Menelaus, Achilles, and Priam are all killed, whereas all three are alive at the conclusion of the Iliad.

A final major plot difference that is Paris and Helen escape the fall of Troy in the movie, whereas no such thing happens in the Iliad or anywhere else in the mythical tradition. In Homer's Odyssey, Menelaus and Helen are back in Sparta and living as husband and wife. The mythic tradition also has Paris being killed by Philoctetes during the tenth year of the war and before the episode of the wooden horse.

One quick, non-plot point to mention: the role of the gods in the movie is significantly decreased.

Countless other differences between the movie and Homer's epic poem exist, but those are probably numerous enough to fill an epic-sized tome.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What are the differences between the Trojan War in Homer's Iliad and the movie Troy?

In the movie, Briseis (Achilles's female captive) is related to Hector, which is not part of the epic. Briseis is taken away from Achilles very early on in the epic, but not until relatively later in the movie. On the other hand, absent from the movie is a dream sent by Zeus to Agamemnon, which alerts the king that Troy will fall if the Achaeans attack immediately. Another pivotal moment in the epic that is not represented in the film is when Aphrodite rescues Paris at the moment he is about to be killed in a one-on-one duel with Menelaus. In the film, it is Hector who intervenes and kills Menelaus. Many of the scenes omitted from the film involve representation of the gods' intervention—a hallmark of epic literature.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

There are many differences between Homer's Iliad and the 2004 movie Troy, starring Brad Pitt as Achilles. One, in particular, is the duration of the war. For cinematic purposes, all the key moments are compacted into a short time (just under three weeks) to create a sensational adventure. It's important to note that the siege of ancient Troy lasted ten years. When the wooden horse arrived at the gates of Troy, for instance, Achilles was already killed, so the timeline of events is skewed in the film.

Other examples of differences include the relationship between Achilles and Patroclus, played by the actor Garrett Hedlund. In Troy, Patroclus is referred to as a cousin. In the Iliad, however, Patroclus was Achilles close comrade, perhaps even his lover, and someone he would've fought to protect and ensure his safety.

The details are a little different between the book and film on how exactly Patroclus was killed. In the Iliad, the god Apollo intervenes during a battle and removes Patroclus's ability to fight skillfully; Euphorbos then hits him with a spear. After, Hector steps in and kills Patroclus by stabbing him in the stomach with another spear. In the film, however, Hector euthanized him. True to the book, Achilles's grief fuels his revenge on Hector in the film.

Lastly, it's important to note that the end of the film was not from the Iliad, which ends with Hector's death. Instead, the filmmakers took some liberties and used Homer's other book, The Odyssey, to recreate a new ending that delivers the victory and sack of Troy.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

This is a good question. All movies take liberties and there is nothing wrong with this. Let me give you a list of differences.

  • In Homer's Iliad, the gods are all over the place, in the movie the gods do not play a huge role. This is to be expected, because it would be difficult to depict the gods in a film.
  • In the movie Hector kills Menelaus. In the Iliad Menelaus does not die at all. Moreover, the movie portrays Menelaus as weak. In the ancient tradition, he is much more capable leader.
  • In the movie, Achilles and other Greeks are inside the Trojan Horse. The Iliad does not mention this; more importantly, Achilles before this action.
  • Ajax and Agamemnon both survive in the Greek tradition, whereas the movie kills them off. Also there is a great tragedy about the death of Agamemnon at the hand of his wife.
  • The role of prophecy is limited in the movie Troy. For example, Cassandra plays no role.
  • Many major characters are not mentioned in the movie, such as Diomede, who plays a large role in the book. Also there is mention of Aeneas, but he is little mentioned in the book. I suspect they may want to make a part two with Aeneas.

To be fair, a two hour movie cannot do justice to one of the greatest books of all time.

Approved by eNotes Editorial