Reality and the Imagination
Near the end of his career, just a year before his death, Stevens was asked to define the central theme of his poetry. As Lucy Beckett highlights in Wallace Stevens, Stevens explained that while "many poems relate to the interactions between reality and the imagination," these are secondary to the overarching theme of a supreme fiction. "The Idea of Order at Key West" examines both themes, primarily exploring the tension between human imagination and reality. The questions raised by the speaker address this fundamental conflict: Is the song and its impact simply an external reality, or does its power lie in our ability to transform it into something profoundly personal?
In the poem "Thirteen Ways of Looking at a Blackbird," Stevens writes, "I do not know which to prefer, 'the blackbird whistling / Or just after.'" Like "Key West," this poem uncovers Stevens' internal struggle between experiencing the songs and remembering them. Ultimately, Stevens suggests that one cannot fully prioritize one over the other, as the imagined world is intertwined with the real one. The woman's song is a fusion of melody and ocean, and its appreciation arises from a combination of personal reflection and external perception. Both the poet and the reader should not solely favor personal or public expressions but should engage with both. The poem's final stanzas offer a resolution to what Stevens describes as his "reality-imagination complex"—embrace and explore both realms, and you will find fulfillment.
Presence and Absence
As Stevens navigates the joys of imagination and reality, he also explores the themes of presence and absence. These concepts are naturally linked; reality suggests a tangible presence, whereas imagination hints at a lack of physical form. In the poem "Key West," the female singer embodies both presence and absence. The readers never actually see her, and it's unclear if the poet does either. There is no description of her appearance, nor is her location disclosed. She may very well be a figment of imagination. Despite her absence from the poem's physical setting, her song profoundly impacts both the speaker and the audience. Therefore, while her physical presence is missing, her voice is undeniably present. As shown in the earlier quote from "Thirteen Ways of Looking at a Blackbird," Stevens is attuned to the presence and absence of voices and songs. A voice cannot be seen or touched, yet it is experienced. Thus, a song embodies both presence and absence, akin to imagination.
Similarly, while the song delves into presence and absence, Stevens' poem also investigates the search for a spiritual essence. Both the speaker and Ramon Fernandez perceive a vast, transcendent spirit among them and the singer, but they find it difficult to identify, name, or verify it. This spirit is both present and absent. The idea that absence can transform into a profound presence is a crucial theme for Stevens and other modern writers, reflecting the broader cultural and spiritual dilemmas of the West in the early twentieth century. The search for God, meaning, balance, and purpose continues but remains ever elusive, much like the song and spirit in Stevens' poem.
Poetry
Much like many of Stevens' creations, "Key West" can be understood in different ways, but at its core, it revolves around the theme of poetry. A large portion of his work tackles the subject of poetry, frequently exploring the art of writing or the experience of reading and interpreting it. "The Idea of Order at Key West" undeniably acts as an allegory, portraying a smaller element of a larger picture. In this instance, the larger picture includes Stevens and his collection of works. Picture Stevens as...
(This entire section contains 288 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
the female singer, with her song symbolizing one of his poems, and the poem's narrator (the listener) representing the audience. In this framework, readers are drawn to his poetry, which deeply affects them and alters their view of the world. Ideally, the poem shifts their attention from the singer (Stevens) and the song (the poem) to their personal reaction to reading it and contemplating its effect. In an ideal scenario, the poem creates a link between Stevens, the world, his poem, and the readers. In one of his last and most celebrated poems, "The Planet on the Table," Stevens contemplates his work, stating that "his poems, although makings of his self, / Were no less makings of the sun." This implies that the poem emerges from the relationship between the poet and the world, which encompasses him, his poem, and the readers.
Furthermore, it's crucial to understand that for Stevens, poetry transcends mere lines, symbols, rhymes, and words; it acts as a metaphor for perception and connection. To Stevens, poetry embodies engagement and signifies the highest form of human interaction. Consequently, poetry provides fulfillment, understanding, awareness, beauty, and connection. Therefore, his poems about poetry also delve into what poetry can offer its readers.
Supreme Fiction
In the twilight of his life, Wallace Stevens eloquently encapsulated the essence of his poetic vision. In 1954, just a year before his passing, he was invited to elucidate his central theme for a contributor’s column. In a characteristically lucid manner, Stevens articulated a premise that might well have been lifted directly from the assessments of critics who had long studied his work. He spoke of the concept of a "supreme fiction," one acknowledged as such, through which individuals might aspire to find fulfillment. Within this construct, poetry was to play an indispensable role, serving as a conduit for crafting these existential narratives.
Stevens's assertion sheds light on the intricate interplay between reality and imagination that pervades his poetry. Among his many works, "The Idea of Order at Key West" emerges as a potent embodiment of this theme, despite being one of his earlier creations. It is a testament to his belief in the transformative power of poetic creation, highlighting how imagination can shape our understanding of the world and our place within it.
Self-Reflexiveness and Modernism
A defining feature of Wallace Stevens’s modernist poetry is its self-reflexiveness, a quality that positions his work as both a subject and an exploration of the act of creation itself. His poetry often turns its gaze inward, contemplating the very process of writing poetry. Particularly, Stevens’s work probes three fundamental questions central to the creative act. Firstly, it examines the intricate relationship between imagination and reality, pondering how art navigates and negotiates these realms. Secondly, Stevens's poetry considers the impact of art on its audience, questioning what transformations or insights it might provoke within the perceiver. Lastly, it delves into the origins of artistic inspiration, seeking to uncover the sources from which creative impulses spring.
Imagination and Reality
In the poetic exploration of the interplay between imagination and reality, the relationship between the sea and song serves as a vivid metaphor. This connection, as depicted in the poem, illustrates how art ideally brings reality into a human framework, doing so without distorting its essence. The speaker underscores the imagination’s role as a "maker," while acknowledging that the singer, referred to as "she," strives to remain faithful to her observations. Despite the inherent challenge of conveying her vision through the limited medium of language, she endeavors to capture the truth of what she perceives.
This delicate balance between imagination and reality is a recurring theme in the poet’s work. For instance, in "The Ordinary Women," a similar idea is presented, emphasizing the necessity for the imagined world to remain grounded in the real. Here, the artist’s task is not to fabricate or alter reality but to frame it within new perspectives that enhance our understanding. As the singer interacts with the sea, she is not merely creating an illusion; rather, she is crafting an interpretation that resonates with the authentic experience of the natural world. Through this synthesis, the poem suggests that true artistry lies in the ability to honor reality while simultaneously elevating it through the imaginative process.
Art's Impact on the Perceiver
The influence of art on its perceivers is profound, touching upon both the comprehension of the natural world and the introspective journey of self-awareness. Art acts as a translator, offering insights into the enigmatic language of nature that might otherwise remain indecipherable. It paints the intangible with clarity and offers a new lens through which the world can be understood. Simultaneously, art deepens our awareness of our own existence within this vast world, highlighting our unique place, even if it is marked by isolation or uncertainty. Through this dual capacity, art enriches our perception of the external world while fostering a more intimate understanding of ourselves.
Source of Art
Art emerges from a profound human desire that defies pure logic, embodying a quest for both truth and poetic beauty. This yearning manifests as an intense impulse, a "rage," to create harmony from the disarray of existence, symbolized by the "order words of the sea." It reflects a deep-seated need to trace the roots of human experience and uncover the enigmatic beginnings and transitions of life, referred to as "fragrant portals" that are only faintly discerned and enveloped in enigma. Engaging in this quest for understanding not only enhances human knowledge but also sharpens poetic expression, resulting in "ghostlier demarcations, keener sounds." Through this transformative process, the poet reshapes their own perception of reality, as well as that of others. The driving force behind this transformation is the "blessed rage," a combination of the poet's burden and their exceptional gift.