Summary
Wallace Stevens' poem "The Idea of Order at Key West" delves into the intricate relationship between the human mind and external reality, particularly through the interplay of nature and art. The poem examines the boundaries between the self and the world, exploring how they blur and merge to form a new understanding of existence. As the poem unfolds, Stevens challenges the traditional perception of nature, art, and human creativity.
Setting the Stage
From the outset, the poem establishes a complex tapestry of relationships. The opening stanza introduces the reader to a dualistic world where the mind and external reality, as well as the singer and the sea, are distinct yet intertwined. The female singer captures the immediate focus, described as singing "beyond the genius of the sea," which suggests a transcendence over natural boundaries. The sea is depicted as a "wholly body," a force resonating with a perpetual cry, which complicates the syntax and intertwines modifiers, contributing to a sense of merging. This fusion hints at a spiritual dimension where the cry of the sea unifies land, speaker, and singer, despite the speaker not fully grasping its significance.
The Sea's Role
In the second stanza, Stevens emphasizes that the sea "was not a mask," suggesting it's not merely a static entity or facade. Instead, it is a dynamic force, much like the speaker and the singer. The female singer's song is inspired by the sea's cry, reminiscent of Walt Whitman's experience in "Out of the Cradle Endlessly Rocking." This suggests a symbiotic relationship where the human and inhuman songs merge. By articulating the sea's cry "word by word," she humanizes the inhuman. Although her words seem to stir the natural elements, the poet's attention ultimately shifts from the sea to the woman, reinforcing a pivot from nature to human expression, a reversal from Romantic ideals placing nature above humanity. Stevens subtly argues that poetry is an inherently human pursuit.
The Power of Imagination
The third stanza posits that, while the singer might derive her song's inspiration from the sea, the song itself is undeniably hers. This assertion underscores the primacy of individual creation, paralleling Stevens' focus on the imagination's power. Although initially intertwined with the sea, the singer emerges as a solitary creator by this stanza. A lingering question about the "spirit" behind the song remains: Is it the woman's, the sea's, or the poet's own? Stevens suggests that grappling with this question may reveal insights into the blurred boundaries between imagination and reality, akin to searching for God. Understanding this spiritual force might unlock both human and divine mysteries.
Questioning Reality
Stanza four offers no clear answer to the previous inquiries, reflecting Stevens' penchant for raising unresolved questions. The speaker ponders whether the song is merely "the dark voice of the sea" or "the outer voice of sky / And cloud." This introspection recalls Romantic poetry's exploration of nature's revelatory power, as seen in works by Wordsworth, Shelley, and Keats. These poets found spiritual renewal through nature's unity, which also served as a creative vehicle. Stevens questions whether his experience mirrors such Romantic epiphanies, a notion seemingly distant in twentieth-century America.
A New Understanding
As the poem progresses, Stevens acknowledges that modern poets require more than nature for fulfillment. From earlier stanzas, it's clear that the song transcends merely the sea or the singer. By stanza five, the speaker realizes the song exceeds the sum of all present elements: the woman, the sea, and the speaker himself. The song's origins remain a mystery, but it is undeniably more than "meaningless plungings of water and the wind." This realization exemplifies...
(This entire section contains 1118 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
ineffability, a recurring theme in Stevens' work, highlighting the limitations of language and human understanding. The song's power extends beyond natural forces, offering an elusive glimpse of something greater than human grasp.
The Role of Language
Language emerges as the vehicle for understanding in this stanza. At first glance, Stevens' exploration of solipsism—a concept that suggests the self is the only knowable existence—could appear self-centered, as seen in "Tea at the Palaz of Hoon." However, upon closer examination, Stevens emphasizes not the imposition of order but the necessity of interpreting and articulating the world. These acts are inherently human, connecting individuals to themselves and their environment. Stevens draws a link between the song in the poem and the essence of poetry itself, asserting that the real value of poetry lies in what the reader learns about themselves through engagement.
Interconnection and Transformation
In these lines, Stevens vividly illustrates the interconnectedness of experience. According to his Adagia, "Poetry is not the same thing as the imagination taken alone. Nothing is itself taken alone. Things are because of interrelations or interactions." This philosophy manifests as the singer, sea, and listeners merge into a single shared experience. The previously distinct elements unify, highlighting that reality is co-created by these interactions. The woman's song refines the speaker's perception, and in turn, inspires him to craft his own song, fostering a dialogue with the imagination of others. The poetic endeavor resides not in isolation but within the collective human experience.
Turning Outward
The speaker turns his attention to others, notably his companion, Ramon Fernandez. This marks a departure from the introspective solipsism of earlier stanzas, moving toward a shared perspective with Fernandez and the nearby town. Initially, the song provoked inward reflection, but now it prompts the speaker to reconnect with both nature and society with a renewed viewpoint. He questions why the lights "arranging," "deepening," and "enchanting" the night seem transformed after the song concludes, seeking an answer in their shared experience.
While Fernandez remains silent, the poem itself hints at the answer. The speaker's focus shifts to human emotion and connection, implying a larger force that enriches human experiences. Though conclusive answers elude them, the joy of existence stems from engaging with these profound questions.
The "Rage for Order"
In the final stanza, Stevens underscores a fascination with words and their role in seeking order. The "rage for order" pertains to both "ourselves" and "our origins," encompassing the speaker, singer, and audience. The poem doesn't impose order on readers or urge them to structure others' worlds. Instead, it offers a framework for understanding a complex, often incomprehensible world. Philosophically, the poem demonstrates how people render the inhuman human. The "fragrant portals" symbolize openings to self-discovery and reflection. The song and poem act as guides, sharpening insights and acknowledging the coexistence of the human and inhuman, the expressible and ineffable, the ordered and chaotic. As Harold Bloom suggests in Wallace Stevens: The Poems of Our Climate, the poem affirms a "transcendental poetic spirit." By leaving discovery to the reader, Stevens invites them into his poetic world, blending experience, song, and imagination.