Themes
Claudius's personal history is one of survival. His father is murdered by Livia. Around him, friends and family are killed by those maneuvering for power. The strong die. The honorable die. So, too, the cruel and wicked die. Claudius survives by behaving as though he is a threat to no one. Indeed, when the palace guards declare him emperor, Claudius refuses to become emperor, but the guards force him. In a land in which the populace has no political power, a group of thugs — the guards — determine who will rule. In order to survive and save his wife and child, Claudius yields to the guards and becomes emperor.
The themes of I, Claudius are grim. Positive themes such as love and friendship are debased by the lust for power and the lusts of the flesh. Selfishness, cruelty, and treachery are the novel's dominant themes. At first. Emperor Augustus seems to rule honorably, but the poison of absolute power has infected his wife. She creates an atmosphere of treachery; those who would dare to tell Augustus of her murdering and deceit risk their lives because Augustus refuses to believe the truth about her. Characters must scheme and lie in order to evade Livia's treacherous plots. Those who remain honorable risk their lives in a world in which honesty makes one an easy target for Livia, Tiberius, Caligula, and other schemers. The dark themes add up to a world gone mad. Every moment may bring sudden death. A misspoken word, a poorly chosen friend, or simply being born into the wrong family may bring torture and murder. In an insane world madmen may be kings, and crazed Caligula is the logical result of a political system gone berserk.
Themes
Fatalism
The Romans believed that the Fates had already determined their futures, which
could not be altered. Claudius describes a visit to the Sybil of Cumae, who
foretells of his becoming emperor. He also describes how the Roman Senate would
order consultations with the books of prophecies whenever strange portents or
disasters occur. Tiberius consults Thrasyllus and acts in response to the
soothsayer’s prophecies. Livia, near her own death, calls Claudius to tell him
of the omens that point to him both becoming emperor and eventually avenging
Caligula’s death. As described by Claudius, these omens and prophecies were far
more than mere superstitions; they effectively guided the Romans in their
decision-making and actions. Both Livia and Caligula, for instance, had ample
opportunities to kill Claudius, and given all that Claudius knew about their
goings-on, it would have made sense to do so. But the fact that Claudius is
prophesied to become Emperor and one day avenge Caligula’s death helped explain
his ability to stay alive.
The Recording of History
Claudius is, first and foremost, a historian. His explicit aim with these
chronicles is to offer “readers of a hundred generations hence” this
“confidential history” of his life. In what seems at first a digression,
Claudius, shortly after his first marriage, meets the historians Pollio and
Livy in the library. While there, they have a discourse on the uses and abuses
of history. “Yes, Poetry is Poetry, and Oratory is Oratory, and History is
History, and you can’t mix them,” Pollio chides his fellow historian.
Ironically, Claudius, the narrator of I, Claudius, claims to be
following Pollio’s dictum, but Graves, in his creation of Claudius and his
imaginative turns of events, certainly mixes “poetry,” or imaginative
liberties, with “history.”
While Graves rightly argues that the characters and events of I, Claudius are all historically based, he nevertheless took great liberties in enhancing the characters’...
(This entire section contains 1336 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
traits and filling in the historical detail. Perhaps Graves’s most liberal use of “poetry” occurs in his depiction of Caligula. While there is general agreement as to the vicious and capricious nature of Caligula’s reign, there is no consensus as to Caligula’s psychological state. History certainly suggests that Caligula may have been certifiably mad, but Graves offers an extreme view of that madness that few others have previously, or since, depicted.
Nepotism
Much of the political power in the novel is relegated according to the
nepotistic desires of the characters, or the characters’ desire to secure the
emperor’s seat for their own blood relatives, resulting in conniving and
murderous competition. With the demise of the Republic, political power in Rome
has become concentrated in the hands of the emperor. It is through the
emperor’s will that a successor is chosen, and it is clear in Augustus’s case,
at least, that he wants at all costs to choose one of his direct descendants.
Unbeknownst to him, however, Livia is constantly scheming to place her own son,
Tiberius, in the line of succession. Throughout most of the narrative, it is
unclear exactly how Livia is doing this, but near her deathbed, she admits to
several poisonings and plots that effectively kept Augustus’s children and
grandchildren from being able to take over as Emperor. In fact, one could argue
that the primary tension that fuels the early action of I, Claudius is
the continual battle between the wills of Livia and Augustus in this regard.
Livia is able to manipulate Augustus through her strategic use of poisoning and
plotting, and she wins supremacy for her bloodline.
Paganism
Rome, during these years, is still a pantheistic pagan society, with multiple
gods. Christianity, as such, has not yet been established. The Senate, for
instance, allows Augustus to be deified in Asia Minor; Livia asks that Claudius
promise to deify her upon her death; Caligula believes himself to be a god and,
in fact, goes to war, like a god, against Neptune. Sibyls and oracles are
consulted, and the emperors retain astrologers to advise them on political
matters.
Political Tyranny
Under the Republic, a considerable amount of power was conferred upon the
elected officials of the Senate. When August was made emperor, the senate
conferred all power to him. As a result, Rome suffers under years of endless
plots and conspiracies as Augustus’s potential successors and their followers
vie with one another for advantage. The winners of these stratagems tend to be
those who are most merciless in their acts, such as Livia, Sejanus and Macro,
and otherwise innocent politicians, officials and citizens are denied their
basic rights and summarily exiled or executed. Although Augustus was generally
viewed as a just leader, the reigns of Tiberius and Caligula are noted for
their brutal and tyrannical characteristics.
Sexual Activity
Although Claudius is, on most accounts, remarkable for the objectivity of his
narration, he does not hesitate in passing judgment in regards to issues of
certain types of sexuality. In one noted digression, he states emphatically
that he has never engaged in homosexual practices, a sexual lifestyle he
considered degenerate. This digression is all the more odd considering that at
no time in the narration does he explicitly describe observing any homosexual
practices. Also, on several occasions he remarks that the depravity of Tiberius
was too revolting to describe, without actually stating what that depravity is,
though he does allude to the emperor’s practice of bestiality, and he describes
one of the Roman wives killing herself as a result of being forced to endure
unspeakable acts by Tiberius. Julia is described for her excessive wantonness,
and Caligula comes off as being the most depraved of them all, with his
inclination to sleep with his sisters and couple with whomever he desired. The
sexuality that Claudius describes is effectively used to enhance the atmosphere
of “depravity” in Rome; since Claudius makes little, if any, mention of his own
sexual activity, this effectively lends a greater air of objectivity to his
narrative. (Though it is interesting to note that Claudius is more judgmental
of Roman sexual practices than he is of his family’s proclivity for grisly
murders.) As is the case in virtually all aspects of his life, Claudius is a
passive observer of Rome’s sexuality; he only acts when acted upon.
War and Xenophobia
Part of the popularity of I, Claudius when it was first published may
have had to do with the historical and political context in which Graves was
writing. The year before the book’s publication, Hitler had just come to power
in Germany, and although it was still early, there was growing sentiment that
Germany would one day soon be on the march to war. I, Claudius depicts
one of the most aggressive imperial forces in world history. The Roman Empire
was able to expand throughout the world as a result of its continual military
incursions and victories. Augustus was one of the most successful emperors in
this regard, helping Rome to solidify its holdings in the Balkans and Germany.
Roman citizens were generally excited at the news of new military victories,
for it usually meant that they would soon profit from new supplies of food and
an infusion of new wealth into the Roman economy. War also provided military
leaders, such as Germanicus, with a way to advance themselves in the eyes of
the Roman Senate and emperor. And as in the case with most imperial forces,
Rome played on its citizens’ fear of the foreign “barbarians.” Such a fear of
foreigners is known as xenophobia. Without vigilance, these barbarians could
one day be knocking down Rome’s gates. In Rome’s particular case, just as it
already was for Graves to a large degree, the Germans were considered
particularly barbaric, and Augustus and Tiberius expend serious resources on
their German military incursions. Claudius describes massacres of Roman
regiments at the hands of the German barbarians, and he describes the fear of
the citizens when news of Rome’s losses spreads.