Hunger of Memory
Hunger of Memory, the intellectual autobiography of Richard Rodriguez, is a narrative that defies easy categorization. This work doesn't adhere to the traditional continuous narrative of autobiographies nor does it dive deeply into the books and intellectual encounters that have influenced Rodriguez, despite being subtitled "The Education of Richard Rodriguez." Instead, it quietly unfolds without dramatic climaxes, marking Rodriguez's decision to leave an academic career to embark on a writing journey as its pivotal moment.
Defying Expectations
Initially, one might question the prospects of such a book finding a publisher or a wide audience, regardless of its literary merit. Yet, Hunger of Memory has achieved both, becoming a widely discussed and reviewed text. This success owes much to the controversial stances Rodriguez takes, particularly his critiques of affirmative action and bilingual education. As a Hispanic-American, Rodriguez rejects the "Chicano" label and critiques these government programs based on his experiences, a position that has made him a sought-after speaker and a polarizing figure.
Controversial Perspectives
Rodriguez's opposition to affirmative action and bilingual education stems from his belief that these programs fail to address the fundamental issues at the core of educational disparities. He argues that affirmative action only benefits those who have already succeeded, like himself, by providing undue advantages. This realization comes to a head during a conversation with a fellow graduate student who, despite having an equally impressive academic record, receives no job offers, highlighting a disparity Rodriguez finds troubling.
His critique of bilingual education centers on the belief that education should forge a public identity and competence, distancing students from their private lives to integrate them into the broader society. Emphasizing that education involves a "radical self-reformation," Rodriguez argues against shielding students from the challenges of learning English or overly prioritizing "creativity" and "originality." He views primary education as a process of imitation, a perspective supported by historical examples of learned languages distinct from mother tongues.
Education and Transformation
The core theme of Hunger of Memory is the transformative power of education, which for Rodriguez, represented a gradual distancing from his Mexican heritage and working-class upbringing. The book's dedication to his parents underscores this distance while honoring them, encapsulating the tension between public success and private identity. A poignant letter from his mother, asking him not to write about their family, illustrates the personal cost of his educational journey.
Rodriguez's narrative highlights the universal nature of educational transformation, which involves navigating the divide between personal backgrounds and public success. This struggle informs his reflections on language, writing, and American culture, recognizing that his motivations will remain unexplained to his parents, yet shared with anonymous readers.
The Writer's Journey
Readers of Rodriguez's work will appreciate his candid reflections on the writing process—a task he performs while concurrently examining it. He brings to light the paradox of writing, where the act of sharing personal narratives with distant readers fosters a unique form of intimacy. This dynamic is captured in his acknowledgement of the reader's voice trailing his words, creating a dialogue that bridges private sentiments and public expression.
In an era rife with pretentious, jargon-filled self-reflection, Rodriguez offers a refreshing clarity. Hunger of Memory serves as an elegant "self-consuming artifact," akin to the works of Renaissance poets Rodriguez admires, blending reflection with creation. As he writes about becoming a writer, he undergoes the transformation himself, all executed with authenticity and grace.
Rodriguez's Unique Voice
Rodriguez's style is a harmonious blend of formal and conversational elements, with sentence fragments and parenthetical asides infusing his prose with a personal touch. He recounts moments from his life, such as being mistaken for...
(This entire section contains 635 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
a foreign student, to illustrate his journey through a public and personal lens. This distinctive voice invites readers—strangers through the medium of his writing—to anticipate future encounters with Rodriguez's insightful and engaging storytelling.
Historical Context
Affirmative Action
Affirmative action encompasses a range of federal initiatives designed to
combat historical discrimination against minority groups and women. These
programs aim to shield these groups from bias and enhance their representation
in both the workforce and educational institutions. Originating from a complex
and contentious mix of federal laws, presidential directives, and judicial
rulings, affirmative action began with the 1964 Civil Rights Act, which also
established the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. In 1968, the
U.S. Department of Labor mandated that employers should hire and promote women
and minorities in proportions that reflect their presence in qualified
applicant pools. In 1971, the Supreme Court interpreted the 1964 Civil Rights
Act as prohibiting employment practices that, regardless of intent, have a
discriminatory effect.
Between 1971 and 1989, several Supreme Court decisions set precedents that limited certain aspects of affirmative action. Notably, the 1978 decision in Bakke v. Regents of the University of California rejected the use of numerical quotas to boost minority enrollment in universities but allowed race to be considered as one among several factors in admissions.
Rodriguez’s book, which garnered significant national attention for its unexpected opposition to affirmative action, was written during a contentious period in American history regarding this issue. Rodriguez generally aligns with those who believe that affirmative action harms the individuals it aims to help by creating a class of people who are never fully integrated into mainstream American life. Others argue that such programs exacerbate hostilities toward minorities. Additionally, Rodriguez criticizes affirmative action in education for focusing solely on ethnicity and gender, ignoring the greater barrier posed by years of inadequate pre-college education.
Bilingual Education
The issue of bilingual education in the United States dates back to the
colonial era, when educators faced the challenge of teaching students who spoke
only German, Dutch, French, or Swedish. However, the modern federal push for
bilingual education began in 1967, with the introduction of a bill in the U.S.
Senate to amend the 1965 Elementary and Secondary Education Act to support
local jurisdictions in establishing bilingual education programs. The primary
aim was to assist children of new immigrants by providing initial school
lessons in their native languages. The first Bilingual Education Act was passed
in 1968 and renewed in 1974.
By the mid to late 1970s, significant concerns emerged regarding the effectiveness of bilingual education, particularly for Spanish-speaking students. The annual cost of the program increased from $7.5 million in its first year to $150 million by 1979.
Critics of bilingual education argue that English has become the global language and is essential for obtaining a good job in the United States. They also claim that maintaining multiculturalism through language undermines the "melting pot" role of public schools and fosters national disunity. In his book, Rodriguez aligns with these critics, contending that English proficiency is crucial for success in the U.S. "The bilingualists simplistically scorn the value and the necessity of assimilation," he writes. Rodriguez credits his own success to learning English early in his education, even though it distanced him from his Mexican heritage.
On the other hand, supporters of bilingual education argue that if children who do not speak English are not taught in their native languages at the beginning of their schooling, their education will suffer. They also believe that the U.S. education system should leverage the many languages spoken by new immigrants to expose students to an increasingly diverse world and nation.
Style and Technique
Richard Rodriguez’s Hunger of Memory: The Education of Richard Rodriguez is a compelling exploration of identity, education, and cultural dislocation, conveyed through a series of six introspective essays. Each essay unveils a different facet of Rodriguez’s journey, revealing the complexities of adapting to a new linguistic and cultural environment. The book is less a chronological account and more a tapestry of experiences and emotional growth, providing a profound insight into Rodriguez’s evolution as an individual.
Essays as Mirrors of Experience
The book's structure consists of essays that are individually self-contained yet collectively form a mosaic of Rodriguez’s life. "Aria" delves into his transition from Spanish to English, highlighting the cultural and familial ramifications of this linguistic shift. "The Achievement of Desire" reflects on Rodriguez’s deep love for education, juxtaposed with the tension it created between him and his uneducated parents. In "Credo," Rodriguez examines his Catholic upbringing, while "Complexion" addresses his identity as a dark-skinned Mexican American, offering insights into his self-perception and societal encounters.
"Profession" shifts focus to Rodriguez’s academic career decisions, showcasing the conflicts and resolutions that shaped his professional path. The concluding essay, "Mr. Secrets," touches on the repercussions of sharing his life in autobiographical form, particularly the discomfort it brought his family. These essays, while not chronologically aligned, collectively narrate Rodriguez’s intellectual and emotional journey, emphasizing the internal dialogues and external challenges he faced.
The Intellectual Autobiography
Rodriguez’s approach to storytelling is unconventional, eschewing linear progression in favor of thematic exploration. By describing his work as an "intellectual autobiography," Rodriguez underscores a narrative driven by emotional and intellectual maturation rather than a simple sequence of events. This structure allows Rodriguez to weave a complex narrative that navigates between past and present, offering insights into how specific experiences have shaped his consciousness and self-awareness.
The essays serve as a reflection of Rodriguez’s internal landscape, inviting readers to traverse the psychological and emotional terrain of his life. This exploration is both personal and universal, as Rodriguez articulates the struggle of reconciling divergent cultural identities within oneself.
Personal Perspective and Literary Tone
Written in the first person, Rodriguez’s essays provide an intimate window into his thoughts and emotions. His narrative voice is both authoritative and introspective, allowing readers to engage directly with his experiences. However, it is essential to recognize that this perspective is inherently subjective, molded by Rodriguez’s personal beliefs and interpretations. The absence of opposing viewpoints in his narrative underscores the personal nature of the autobiography.
Rodriguez’s tone oscillates between pride and self-deprecation, a duality that humanizes his persona. While he takes pride in his academic accomplishments, he candidly acknowledges the utilitarian nature of his success, attributing it to his ability to memorize and assimilate rather than pure intellect. His decision to attend Stanford University, motivated by its prestigious reputation and affluent student body, further exemplifies his desire for upward mobility and exposure to different social strata.
Navigating Cultural and Educational Landscapes
Each essay in Hunger of Memory not only captures a particular moment or theme in Rodriguez’s life but also reflects broader societal and cultural dynamics. The linguistic transition from Spanish to English in "Aria" is emblematic of the immigrant experience, illustrating the tension between cultural heritage and assimilation. This conflict is a recurring motif throughout the book, shedding light on the complexities of navigating multiple identities.
In "The Achievement of Desire," Rodriguez’s relationship with education is portrayed as both a refuge and a source of alienation. His portrayal of the "scholarship boy" archetype highlights the sacrifices and dichotomies inherent in striving for academic success, often at the expense of familial bonds. Similarly, his reflections on complexion and identity in "Complexion" resonate with broader themes of racial and cultural identity, probing the intersections of personal and collective experiences.
Through his essays, Rodriguez invites readers to contemplate the intricate interplay between personal identity and societal expectations. His narrative, while deeply personal, resonates with universal themes of belonging, ambition, and the quest for self-understanding. Rodriguez’s literary style, with its rich introspection and thematic depth, elevates Hunger of Memory as a profound exploration of the human condition.
Compare and Contrast
1950s: Between 1945 and 1950, five million new homes are constructed, leading to over 50 percent of Americans becoming homeowners. From 1950 to 1960, 75 percent of metropolitan expansion happens in suburban areas.
1970s: By 1970, nearly 40 percent of Americans reside in suburbs, while both urban and rural regions see population declines. During this period, about 65 percent of Americans own their homes.
Today: In the current post-suburban era, "edge cities" are emerging—planned developments on the outskirts of major cities that are physically, economically, and culturally independent. In 2000, approximately 67 percent of Americans are homeowners, but the homeownership rate for Hispanics is only around 46 percent.
1950s: The weekly comedy show I Love Lucy, starring Lucille Ball, becomes one of the most successful TV shows in American history. Debuting in 1951 on CBS, it gains a loyal audience with its humorous portrayal of the married life of Lucy and Ricky Ricardo, played by her real-life husband, Desi Arnaz.
1970s: From 1974 to 1978, NBC enjoys a major hit with the sitcom Chico and the Man, which features Freddie Prinze as Chico, a young Chicano, and Jack Albertson as Ed Brown, an older white man, living in East Los Angeles.
Today: According to various Hispanic groups, fewer network television roles are available for Hispanics. They note that one of the few prominent Hispanic actors in a leading role is Martin Sheen, who plays the U.S. president on NBC's West Wing. His birth name is Ramon Estevez.
1950s: The debate over government aid to parochial schools is intense. The Catholic Church opposes any legislation that explicitly bans public funds from being allocated to church-run schools. In 1950, over three million American students attend parochial elementary and secondary schools, similar to those attended by Rodriguez and his siblings in Sacramento.
1970s: The controversy over public support for parochial schools persists. In 1973, the Supreme Court rules that a New York State tax provision offering a tuition tax credit to parents of non-public school students is unconstitutional.
Today: The issue of government vouchers for private schools—payments made by the government to parents or educational institutions for students' education expenses—remains contentious. Many parents argue for the right to choose their children's schools and believe the government should support this choice through tax relief and vouchers.
1950s: The most debated issue in education is the desegregation of public schools. In 1954, the United States Supreme Court rules in Brown v. the Board of Education of Topeka, Kansas that racial segregation in schools is unconstitutional.
1970s: Following the success of desegregation, the nation's focus shifts to affirmative action. Throughout the decade, affirmative action policies in education are bolstered. However, in 1978, the United States Supreme Court narrows some of these measures in the case Bakke v. Regents of the University of California. The court's decision rejects the use of numerical quotas aimed at boosting minority enrollment in universities but allows for programs where race is one of several factors considered.
Today: Advocates of a color-blind society continue to challenge those who support race-conscious approaches to combating discrimination. Although the United States Supreme Court has previously upheld significant affirmative action policies, a series of recent rulings have cast uncertainty over the future of affirmative action.
Bibliography
Sources
Couser, G. Thomas, ‘‘Biculturalism in Contemporary Autobiography: Richard
Rodriguez and Maxine Hong Kingston,’’ in Altered Egos: Authority in
American Autobiography, Oxford University Press, 1989, pp. 210–45.
Crowley, Paul, ‘‘An Ancient Catholic: An Interview with Richard Rodriguez,’’ in America, Vol. 173, No. 8, September 23, 1995, pp. 8ff.(4).
Hortas, Carlos R., ‘‘Hunger of Memory: The Education of Richard Rodriguez: Book Review,’’ in Harvard Educational Review, Vol. 53, No. 3, August 1983, pp. 355–59.
Postrel, Virginia, and Nick Gillespie, ‘‘The New, New World: Richard Rodriguez on Culture and Assimilation,’’ in Reason, Vol. 26, August 1, 1994, pp. 35ff.(7).
Saldívar, Ramón, ‘‘Ideologies of the Self: Chicano Autobiography,’’ in Diacritics, Vol. 15, No. 3, Fall 1985, pp. 25–34.
Stavens, Ilan, ‘‘Hunger of Memory: The Education of Richard Rodriguez: Book Review,’’ in Commonweal, Vol. 120, No. 6, March 26, 1993, pp. 20ff.(3).
Woods, Richard D., ‘‘Richard Rodriguez,’’ in Dictionary of Literary Biography, Vol. 82: Chicano Writers, First Series, edited by Francisco A. Lomeli and Carl R. Shirley, Gale Research, 1989, pp. 214–16.
Zweig, Paul, ‘‘The Child of Two Cultures,’’ in New York Times Book Review, February 28, 1982, pp. 1, 26.
Further Reading
Beckwith, Frances J., and Todd E. Jones, eds., Affirmative Action: Social
Justice or Reverse Discrimination?, Prometheus Books, 1997.
Frances Beckwith opposes affirmative action, while Todd Jones supports it.
Together, they have compiled a collection of essays and articles that explore
this topic, offering readers a balanced perspective.
Kingston, Maxine Hong, The Woman Warrior: Memoirs of a Girlhood among
Ghosts, Vintage Books, 1989.
Maxine Hong Kingston’s memoir recounts her experience growing up as a Chinese
girl in Stockton, California. She navigates between her mother’s enchanting
stories of China and her life among the non-Chinese "ghosts" in America.
Stavens, Ilan, The Hispanic Condition: Reflections on Culture and
Identity in America, HarperPerennial Library, 1996.
Ilan Stavens shares his personal experiences to examine the history and
attitudes of Hispanics in the Americas. His background includes growing up as a
middle-class Jewish boy in Mexico City and later integrating into a diverse
Latino community in New York City.
Suro, Roberto, Strangers among Us: Latinos’ Lives in a Changing
America, Vintage Books, 1999.
Journalist Roberto Suro delves into critical issues surrounding Latino
immigration to the United States. He addresses topics such as poverty,
bilingual education, and the dynamics between Latinos and other ethnic
groups.