Discussion Topic
Themes in "Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard" by Kiran Desai
Summary:
Kiran Desai's Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard explores themes of tradition versus modernity, imagination versus reality, and individual versus society. Set in India, the novel juxtaposes traditional cultural values against modern influences, as seen through characters like Ammaji and Mr. Chawla. Sampath, the protagonist, seeks freedom in nature, escaping societal constraints by living in a guava tree. Themes of conformity and hunger for meaning are highlighted through characters like Kulfi, who seek fulfillment beyond societal norms. The novel humorously addresses these serious themes, illustrating the tension between personal desires and societal expectations.
What are the essential themes in Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard?
Traditional versus modern culture
India provides the perfect backdrop for the theme of sticking with traditional culture and customs versus entering the modern world. Ammaji is a traditional Indian woman who uses traditional remedies and astrology and folklore to solve problems. She has firm roots in this and wants the same for her family. In contrast, Sampath's father is a very proud bank employee. He wants to follow more modern Western culture and looks down upon his mother for her traditional values. In some ways, he is caught between the two worlds: at home he does yoga, but at work, he has Western manners. He wants to be a Western banker, but he wants his daughter to be an ideal Indian woman, instead of being like the movie stars she wishes to emulate. The town itself represents the contrast between traditional and modern ways of life. On the one hand, people scrounge for what they need, the electricity doesn't always work, and traditional religious practices are followed. In contrast, they have a modern movie theater, busses, cars, and a university.
Imagination versus reality
Kulfi and Sampath would like to spend much of their time in their imagination. Sampath, especially, has an artist's mind. He spends his time reading and finding beauty in words and shapes. This is further illustrated when he goes through rooms of the house smelling different smells and getting drunk on perfume and other various scents. He is "transported." This frequent transportation into his dream world causes him to fail his exams and get fired from his job.
Kulfi prefers to spend her time being a culinary artist. She spends her time finding herbs and spices to put into her dishes. She finds life a little boring and is almost obsessed with cooking something new and exciting, like a monkey. They both daydream about their future instead of spending time in the present. However, they learn that in order to be successful members of society, they have to suppress some of their imagination and live in the here and now.
In this society, most people do not spend their time dreaming of how things could be. They spend their energy worrying about their current position and how they can advance it. This can be seen by Mr. Chawla spending most of his energy figuring out ways to make money from his son's religious career. It is also seen when the ice cream boy is so busy thinking about himself that he doesn't realize Pinky has a crush on him.
One of the novel's themes is that nature affords freedom to certain individuals. Sampath is very much a free spirit, but in the town he cannot be himself, cannot express his true self. He feels constrained and restricted by society's petty rules and customs. It is only by going back to nature, as it were, by seeking refuge in the guava orchard, that Sampath can experience the freedom to be who he wants to be.
In the town, Sampath is a nobody, a humble worker toiling away at a menial job he cordially loathes. But in the guava orchard, it's a different story. Here, he's the center of attention, a local celebrity, someone whose apparent guru-like wisdom is much sought after. It says a lot about the petty-mindedness of the local townsfolk that Sampath had to take off to the guava orchard to achieve this exalted status.
One critical theme in Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard is the theme of conformity. Conformist notions of the good impact characters in the story in different ways. For example, Sampath cannot embrace the conformity and social expectations that are demanded from him. This becomes part of the motivating factor in his ascent to the tree in the first place. Kulfi also represents the theme of conformity and its impact on the individual. The metaphor of Kulfi's insatiable appetite is symbolic of her desire to strive for something more that socially prescribed elements of being in the world. Her "desperation for another landscape" and desire to see the freedom potential in food are aspects of her being that causes her to embrace a non- conformist mode of being in the world, another version of Sampath fleeing to the tree.
The flip side to this coin would be the father and sister of the family. Mr. Chawla perceives oddness and a lack of conformity to be akin to "aches and pains, fits of tears and lethargy." He is constantly driven to advance his own name, as seen in his initial repulsion towards Sampath climbing the tree and then recognizing that his perceived status as a guru can advance his own name. Pinky is another example of the conformist structure guiding individual choice and perception. While she experiences what might be a liberating notion of love with the ice cream boy, she ends up recalibrating this momentary distraction in moving her eyes on the brigadier and the notion of "societal gain" advancing her own desire.
How individuals deal with the conformist aspect of being is a critical theme in the novel. Through this, the themes of material advancement and spiritual identity, gender notions of identity, and the relationship between individuals and authority are all illuminated. The critical theme of social conformity impacts all of the main characters in the narrative. Their responses to it help to define much of their trajectory and the arc of their development.
What is the theme in "Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard" by Kiran Desai?
One of the prominent themes in Desai's novel is that of hunger and satisfaction in a place where hunger is common but satisfaction hard to come by. Though it is a serious theme, the author weaves a sense of humor throughout. (How many novels feature drunken monkeys??)
Food is an all-consuming issue for the protagonist, Samptha's mother, Kulfi. Throughout her pregnancy, she is "obsessed with food. Despite the drought engulfing Shahkot, Kulfi is determined to feed her insatiable desire. She bribes the vegetable and meat sellers at the bazaar, always driven by a fierce hunger she cannot stem. In the same way, when she begins to feel the movements of the baby inside of her, and with her hunger ever-increasing, Kulfi reacts by drawing pictures of eating scenes and pictures of food all over the walls of the Chawla family's home "in desperation for another landscape."
Both Samptha and Kulfi are dissatified with their unfullfilling lives, they "hunger" for purpose. It is fittingly ironic, then, that Kulfi winds up in a guava tree. Guavas are an important staple in the Indian diet, and his desire to both consume and transcend his place in the world is made manifest in his hunger.
How does Desai present the theme of "Individual VS Society" in Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard?
In Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard Desai presents the theme of "individual versus society" by showing the way in which the life of Sampath Chawla is negatively affected by each and every one of his social support systems. A worthless job, an unassertive family unit, and his estranged society, lead Sampath to finally act upon his true desires in life, resulting in the insane decision of leaving everything behind, climbing a guava tree and deciding to live in it.
This is a representation of how society can push someone so far that insane choices are made in order to preserve what is left of our sanity. However, the primary reason why we rebel against society is precisely to preserve and safeguard our individuality. This is the most important aspect of the theme of "individual versus society" in Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard.
An effective way to present your essay is by describing the ways in which society directly affected Sampath prior to his change as far as a) his family as a support system, b) his job, c) society at large.
Show how Sampath's philosophical intelligence and ability to tap on the true personalities of people represent intellectual and emotional gifts that went under-appreciated and ignored by society until the moment when he decided to live life the way that he chose to.
Desai also notes how, despite of the sensation and enigmatic reputation that Sampath creates as a result of his new lifestyle, he maintains his philosophy of life. Moreover, Sampath now lives in meditative contemplation, while the world around him tries to figure out how to financially benefit from his new-found fame and guru-type abilities.
This shows that, while Sampath removed himself from society to find himself, society now seems to want to move itself around Sampath's life precisely because he is perhaps one of the few who has succeeded at finding individuality! This is because Sampath's individuality becomes stronger and more assertive when he finally beats the rat race of society and follows his own mind, heart, and instinct to make life what he really wishes it to be.
Therefore, list the many contributors that led Sampath to make the abrupt choice of changing his life, and then compare Sampath's individuality before and after his lifestyle change. Note that he became a perfectly round character after finally moving away from the social pressures and expectations bestowed upon him. Moreover, explain that his choices are defensible considering his deep desire to maintain his individuality versus society's apparent agenda to ignore the uniqueness of each human being and treat everyone as mere money-making machines.
How does Desai portray "Nature versus Society" in Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard?
In Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard nature plays a very poignant role. "She" is the refuge to which society runs to to find succor, support, and peace. Nature, with its rich, protective, and supple elements, is basically ignored until the moment when individual (Sampath) finally takes the initiative to remove himself from an otherwise venomous and polluted society which rots the individual from the inside out. For your essay, outline the many obstacles that prevented Sampath from finding his voice and from finally liberating himself from oppression. Once he chose to do that, he became part of nature, or the Natural order of things. As a result, he is juxtaposed to the purpose of society versus his own purpose as an individual.
Like a silent and welcoming mother, Nature is always there on the sidelines awaiting with eager motivation the arrival of those who appreciate, remember, and love her. When Sampath finally chooses to lead a path toward individuality, he immediately escapes toward Mother Nature herself to hide him and save him from a life that was no longer worth sacrificing time or efforts for.
The moment Sampath climbs the guava tree he immediately declares the tree as "his home", and he begins a journey where he and nature are finally bound together as nature originally intended humanity to be. In the tree, he sleeps, the muses, he philosophizes, and he gets nourished by his earthly, real mother. Hence, note how Nature is the ultimate source of peace and inspiration in Sampath's life.
However, like Sampath, Nature is in danger of the rest of society. When the alcohol-addicted monkeys" attack the city, the now-formed alliance between Sampath and Nature are put at risk. When Sampath's father and the advertisers greedily look for ways to make money out of Sampath's new-found celebrity as a guru, their invasion of Sampath's new "space" in Nature is also put at risk. In all, Nature and Sampath represent "the individual", which is now uncorrupted and has found a purpose. Meanwhile such "individual" is in constant danger of extinction by the agendas of society as a whole.
What theme is present in the first four chapters of Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard?
You might like to consider how the theme of repression and the difficulty of finding meaning in a life that is otherwise characterised by meaningless labour is presented through the character of Sampath's mother, Kulfi, in these first few chapters. She of course has a direct impact on Sampath and his desire for something mroe out of life. Kulfi is a character who continuously expresses a sense of longing for some greater purpose. We are told, for example, that her house "was small for her big desire." This desire takes various forms, but at the beginning of the novel, we see this desire manifests itself in the form of food; as her pregnancy causes her to crave endless quantities of good. Even though there is a massive drought, Kulfi bribes the various market sellers to give her food and when she begins to feel the baby inside of her move, she begins to draw various scenes depicting eating that cover the walls of a family home.
What is interesting is that as her child continues to grow inside of her, she does not merely become awkward and uncomfortable, but we are told that:
She seemed to be claiming all the earth's energy for herself, sapping it dry, leaving it withered, shrivelled and yellow.
Kulfi is therefore a character who in her life seems to symbolise the search for meaning and significance against the backdrop of an uncaring world that thrusts menial tasks onto us that claim our lives. This is something that is shown to separate her from the rest of the townspeople, as she sits alone and focuses her mind on "a point invisible to everybody but herself." Clearly, in Kulfi, we can see the same desire to be significant that drives the character of her son and forms such a thematic basis of this novel.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.