Themes
Last Updated September 23, 2024.
Connection
The central theme of Howards End is connection—linking private and
public lives, connecting individuals—and the challenges in forming and
maintaining these connections. The novel centers on two families: the
Schlegels, who embody intellectualism, imagination, and idealism—the inner
workings of the mind—and the Wilcoxes, who symbolize English practicality,
expansionism, commercialism, and the external world of business and politics.
For the Schlegels, personal relationships take precedence over public ones, and
the individual is more significant than any organization. Conversely, for the
Wilcoxes, social formalities and business rules are paramount.
The marriage of Margaret Schlegel and Henry Wilcox bridges these two contrasting worlds. Unlike her extremely idealistic sister Helen, Margaret comes to understand the Wilcoxes. Helen's first interaction with the Wilcoxes ends disastrously, but Margaret realizes that many of the values she cherishes, such as art and culture, rely on the economic and social stability provided by people like the Wilcoxes. "More and more," she observes, "do I refuse to draw my income and sneer at those who guarantee it."
However, Margaret and Henry's marriage almost collapses when Henry fails to connect his own sexual indiscretion with Jacky Bast to Helen's affair with Leonard Bast. Margaret and Helen wish to spend the night at Howards End before Helen returns to Germany to have her baby. Yet, the hypocritical Henry cannot accept the presence of a "fallen woman" on his property and denies them permission to stay. As critic Malcolm Bradbury notes, Margaret upholds the "primacy of the standard of personal sympathy," whereas Henry emphasizes "the standard of social propriety." Defying Henry, Margaret and Helen stay the night at Howards End, rekindling their bond. By the novel's conclusion, circumstances compel Henry to reassess his values. He reconciles with Helen, and together with Margaret and Helen's illegitimate son, they make a home at Howards End under Margaret's care.
Class Conflict
Another significant theme in Howards End is the struggle and conflict
within the middle class. The aristocracy and the very poor are absent from this
novel; the author explicitly states, "[w]e are not concerned with the very
poor," but rather with "gentlefolk, or with those who are obliged to pretend
that they are gentlefolk." The three families in Howards End each
represent different strata of the middle class. The Schlegels occupy the middle
ground, situated between the Basts, who are on the lower fringes of the middle
class, and the Wilcoxes, who belong to the upper-middle class. Leonard Bast,
the clerk, lives near the "abyss" of poverty, while the Schlegels live
comfortably on inherited wealth, and Henry Wilcox, a prosperous businessman,
continually accumulates wealth, affording "motors" and country houses.
Leonard Bast is deeply concerned with class distinctions and strives to elevate himself by becoming "cultured." He reads works like Ruskin's Stones of Venice and attends musical performances. At a concert featuring Beethoven's Fifth Symphony, he encounters the Schlegel sisters and becomes intrigued by them, largely because they appear to respect his intellectual goals. The Schlegels, equally fascinated by Leonard and his circumstances, ultimately find their connection to him to be disastrous. When Margaret and Helen learn from Mr. Wilcox that Leonard's employer is on the brink of bankruptcy, they advise him to seek new employment. Although the information turns out to be incorrect, Leonard acts on it, securing and then losing another job, which leaves him and his wife Jacky nearly destitute. In a dramatic scene where Leonard, Jacky, and Helen disrupt Evie's lavish wedding, Forster vividly portrays the vast social and economic divide between the impoverished Basts and the affluent Wilcoxes. As critic Frederick P. W. McDowell notes, this scene "suggests that the...
(This entire section contains 952 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
impersonal forces by which the Wilcoxes prosper have operated at the expense of Leonard and his class."
Leonard's downfall is a result of the Wilcox family's indifference combined with Helen's compassion. Helen attempts to persuade Henry that he has a duty to assist Leonard since his advice led to Leonard's downfall. When this effort fails, Helen's empathy for Leonard leads her to sleep with him. Upon discovering that Leonard is Helen's "lover," the violent Charles Wilcox assaults Leonard with the flat side of the Schlegel family sword. Leonard does not die from the beating but from a weak heart. He collapses, toppling a bookcase and being buried under an avalanche of books, symbolizing his tragic pursuit of self-improvement.
Future of England
Connected to the themes of connection and class conflict in Howards End
is the theme of inheritance. The novel explores the question of who will
inherit England. When Howards End was published, England was
experiencing significant social changes. Issues such as women's emancipation,
commercial and imperial expansion, and the looming possibility of war with
Germany contributed to a widespread sense of uncertainty about England's
future.
According to critic Lionel Trilling, Howards End itself represents England. Ruth Wilcox, who hails from the yeoman class, symbolizes England's past. Before her death, Ruth befriends Margaret Schlegel and, on her deathbed, scribbles a note bequeathing Howards End to Margaret. Ruth cannot leave it to her family, who only view it as property and fail to grasp its spiritual significance, which she knows Margaret will appreciate. The Wilcoxes dismiss Ruth's note as impractical and ignore it, overlooking the rightful heir. However, Margaret's bond with Ruth Wilcox is profound. Not only does she become Ruth's spiritual successor, but she also ironically inherits Howards End through her marriage to Henry, becoming Mrs. Wilcox.
Foster's response to the question of who will inherit England appears to advocate for a collective inheritance. By the end of the novel, the intellectual Schlegels and the pragmatic Wilcoxes are living together at Howards End. The immediate heir, Helen's illegitimate son, seems to represent a future without class distinctions.