Themes: The Corrupting Power of Greed
The key theme of this short story is greed and its power to corrupt. At the beginning of the story, Pahom, the protagonist, believes that he would “not fear the Devil himself” if he only had enough land. The Devil begins to tempt him, and Pahom has opportunity after opportunity to acquire more land.
Though his land grows, Pahom is never satisfied, and he is increasingly willing to step over other people to get more and better land for himself; he fines those who were once his fellow peasants, tries to punish a peasant for a crime he didn’t commit, and takes advantage of a landowner in financial difficulty. Pahom thus begins to resemble his neighbor’s harsh steward, whom he initially loathed for fining the people of the commune.
The Bashkirs inform Pahom that they will sell him however much land he can walk around in a day, and he mentally plots out a tract of land that will take him the rest of the day to mark out and sets to work. Though selling land by the day is unconventional, the Bashkirs’ rate is reasonable: surely a plot of land that takes an entire day to walk around is plenty. However, not even this is enough to satisfy Pahom, and he alters his path to include more land as he goes along. He ultimately overestimates how far of a circuit he can walk, and his greed kills him.
Expert Q&A
How did Pahom's greed cause his downfall?
In "How Much Land Does a Man Need?" Pahom's greed leads directly to his downfall, as he dies from exhaustion after staking out a large plot of land. Pahom thought that the land represented a bargain, so he wanted to grab as much of it as possible. But Pahom dies in the attempt to get his greedy hands on yet another plot of land that is beyond what he needs in order to find contentment.
The moral and message about greed in "How Much Land Does a Man Need?"
The moral and message about greed in "How Much Land Does a Man Need?" emphasize that excessive desire for material possessions leads to one's downfall. The story illustrates that Pahom's insatiable greed ultimately results in his demise, teaching readers that true contentment and happiness come from appreciating what one already has.
What is the meaning and irony of the last line in Tolstoy's "How Much Land Does a Man Need?"
"Six feet from his head to his heels was all he needed."
The last line in Tolstoy's "How Much Land Does a Man Need?" is ironic because it reveals that despite Pahom's insatiable greed for land, ultimately, he only needed enough land for his grave. Throughout his life, Pahom believed more land would bring him contentment, but in the end, his endless pursuit led to his death, showing that a man truly only needs six feet of land to be buried.
Why does the Devil give land to Pahom?
In "How Much Land Does a Man Need?," the Devil gives Pahom land in order to corrupt his soul. The Devil overhears Pahom's assertion that if he had enough land, he should fear nothing, not even the Devil himself. The Devil then accepts this challenge and gives Pahom as much land as he wants, knowing that Pahom's soul will become so utterly corroded with greed that he'll effectively belong to him.
What happens when Pahom acquires more land?
When Pahom initially buys more land in "How Much Land Does a Man Need?," he is briefly satisfied. But his ambitious nature gets the best of him again, causing Pahom to want even more land. When Pahom seeks to purchase land from the Bashkirs, his greed ends up killing him, as he attempts to needlessly maximize the amount of land he can get and exhausts himself in the process.
Pahom's conflicts and the Devil's interest in "How Much Land Does a Man Need?"
Pahom's conflicts are driven by his insatiable greed for land. The Devil takes interest in Pahom because he declares that with enough land, he would not fear the Devil. This hubris sets the stage for Pahom's downfall, as his relentless pursuit of more land ultimately leads to his demise.
Is Pahom's greed for land justified?
Pahom's greed for land is not justified, as depicted in Tolstoy's "How Much Land Does a Man Need?" His desire is sparked by a conversation comparing peasant and tradesman lifestyles. Despite claiming peasants have no time for "nonsense," Pahom's quest for more land is seen as idle and unnecessary. Tolstoy emphasizes that Pahom's situation differs from many Russian peasants who needed more land, reinforcing the moral that Pahom's greed is unjustified.
Pahom's pursuit of land and its impact on his happiness and motivations
In Tolstoy's "How Much Land Does a Man Need?", Pahom's relentless pursuit of land reflects his insatiable greed and desire for wealth. Initially sparked by envy of a neighbor and discontent with his current life, Pahom seeks happiness through land ownership. His ambition leads him to the Bashkirs, who offer a deal to acquire as much land as he can traverse in a day. However, his greed ultimately leads to his downfall, as he dies from exhaustion, illustrating the futility of his desires.
The impact of land acquisition on Pahom's personality and evolving emotions in "How Much Land Does a Man Need?"
Land acquisition significantly impacts Pahom's personality and emotions, making him increasingly greedy and dissatisfied. As he acquires more land, his desire for even more grows, leading to a continuous cycle of dissatisfaction and ambition. This relentless pursuit eventually consumes him, highlighting the destructive power of greed.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
