Themes: Trapped and Oppressed Women
Esperanza finds beauty and friendship on Mango Street, but she is constantly afraid of being trapped there, as many other women are. The House on Mango Street is dedicated A las Mujeres, To the Women, and the most important, compelling figures in the book—Esperanza herself, Marin, Sally, Alicia, Ruthie, and Minerva—are all female. At the beginning of the book, Esperanza notes that “boys and girls live in separate worlds,” and it does not take her long to see that the world in which the girls and women live is far harsher and more restrictive.
The lives of the women in Mango Street form a litany of misery and oppression. At best, they endure lives of pointless drudgery; at worst, imprisonment and violence. Sally is beaten by her father, and Minerva by her husband. When Sally marries, her husband will not even allow her to look out of the window or talk on the telephone. Rafaela’s husband locks her in the house so she does not run away. Meanwhile, Earl, Esperanza’s neighbor, has a succession of women, probably sex workers, in his apartment, and the neighbors turn a blind eye, maintaining the fiction that all these different women are a single wife who visits him from time to time.
Toward the end of The House on Mango Street, Esperanza realizes that her mother is one of these trapped women, angry and bitter that she has not accomplished more in her life. She tells Esperanza to study so that she does not share the same fate. Esperanza does not think she is beautiful and concludes that she cannot rely on a man to save her from a life of poverty and drudgery. Moreover, her first sexual encounters, at work and at a carnival, frighten and disgust her. She knows that she will not only have to study hard, but also be assertive and forceful if she is to avoid becoming one of the trapped, downtrodden women of Mango Street and achieve her dream of owning a home of her own.
Expert Q&A
Why is Alicia in "The House on Mango Street" afraid of "four-legged fur, and fathers"?
Alicia fears "four-legged fur"—mice—because they symbolize the poverty she endures, suggesting she might never escape her grim circumstances. Her fear of "fathers" stems from her relationship with her father, who neglects their squalid living conditions and potentially subjects her to abuse. This dual fear highlights her vulnerability and the oppressive environment she faces, reflecting broader themes of poverty and abuse in "The House on Mango Street."
In The House on Mango Street, why does Esperanza find her name shameful and why did Cisneros choose it?
Esperanza finds her name shameful because it feels burdensome, associated with sadness, and reminds her of her great-grandmother's unfulfilled life. She wishes for a more vibrant name that fits her true self. Cisneros chose the name "Esperanza," meaning "hope," to symbolize the protagonist's need for hope to overcome life's challenges and to reflect the potential for a new generation of women to redefine their identities.
Why does The House on Mango Street end with "For the ones I left behind. For the ones who cannot out."?
The ending reflects Esperanza's journey throughout the novel, where she dreams of escaping her life on Mango Street for a better future. While her family initially hoped for an ideal home, the reality was disappointing. Esperanza meets others trapped by their circumstances, like Sally, and finds solace in writing as a means of escape. The final lines express her desire to help those left behind who cannot find a way out of their limiting environment.
When do race and gender conflict in The House on Mango Street? Which issue is emphasized more?
In "The House on Mango Street," gender issues are emphasized more than race, although both are present. Esperanza's struggle with gender roles within her Mexican-American community is a central theme, highlighting her efforts to defy cultural stereotypes and assert her independence as a woman. Race is less of a direct conflict, often serving as a backdrop rather than a focal point, with gender issues, particularly machismo, taking precedence in shaping Esperanza's experiences.
In The House on Mango Street, what are Esperanza and Marin's dreams?
Esperanza and Marin both dream of owning a big house, but their approaches differ. Marin hopes to achieve this by marrying a man who can provide it, reflecting the traditional path seen in her community. Esperanza, however, aspires to own her home independently, rejecting the cycle of dependency she observes. She aims to maintain her identity and roots while pursuing her dream, avoiding reliance on a man for fulfillment and stability.
How has Esperanza's awareness of her sexuality evolved since "Hips" and "My First Job"?
Esperanza's awareness of her sexuality evolves from a naive understanding in "Hips," where she views hips as a physical attribute without sexual connotations, to a more complex awareness in "My First Job." Initially, she sees hips as useful for balancing babies, not for attracting men. However, her experience at her first job, where a man kisses her without consent, exposes her to the harsh realities of male behavior. Ultimately, she dreams of independence, valuing personal space over traditional gender roles.
Why did Esperanza's great-grandmother in The House on Mango Street spend her life looking out the window?
Esperanza's great-grandmother spent her life looking out the window, symbolizing the confinement and unfulfilled potential faced by many women in The House on Mango Street. This imagery reflects women trapped by societal constraints, controlling relationships, and limited life choices, such as marrying young or not completing education. Esperanza, named after her great-grandmother, is determined not to inherit this fate and seeks to break free from these limitations.
Why does Rosa Vargas cry daily in The House on Mango Street?
Rosa Vargas cries daily because her husband abandoned her without support, leaving her overwhelmed by many unruly children. Her children lack discipline and respect, running wild in the neighborhood, which exhausts her. Initially, neighbors attempted to intervene but eventually gave up due to the children's disobedience. This situation reflects themes of Hispanic women's struggles and the cycle of poverty, highlighting the challenges faced by Rosa and her children on Mango Street.
What is the significance of the aunt's advice to Esperanza about the circle and her connection to Mango Street in "The Three Sisters" from The House on Mango Street?
The aunt's advice to Esperanza in "The Three Sisters" emphasizes the importance of remembering where she came from, Mango Street, as it is integral to her identity. She must return to help those who cannot escape, symbolizing a full circle. Despite the challenges faced there, these experiences have strengthened her. This advice highlights the theme of community responsibility and the influence of one's environment on personal growth.
Why isn't the house on Mango Street the dream home in Cisneros's "The House on Mango Street"?
The house on Mango Street is not Esperanza's dream home because it fails to meet her aspirations. It's small, cramped, and located in a rundown neighborhood with bums and drug dealers, making it unsafe. Esperanza dreams of a nicer, larger house in a better area, reflecting her desire to escape her current environment. Despite being her family's best option, it doesn't match the promised dream home, leaving Esperanza longing for a place she can truly call home.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
