Ideas for Group Discussions
Is The Hound of the Baskervilles the best mystery novel ever written? A group interested in the mystery genre in particular could debate that question long into the night, with each member advancing reasons why his or her favorite novel deserves the honor. But the question is not a shallow one. For nearly one hundred years readers young and old have been held in the powerfully suspenseful grip of the tale of a demonic hound and the efforts of mortal human beings to uncover its murderous secret. The novel is one of Conan Doyle's most inspired works, balancing traditional romance against harsh reality. Part of the novel's greatness lies in its testing of the human spirit; its characters are put under terrible stress, with some of them snapping under the strain, and others such as Holmes feeling the blows of an evil that almost defies rationality. That Holmes ultimately makes the evil yield to his scientific analysis is a triumph for him.
Even so, note how balanced the novel is. Holmes is not perfectly successful. His client lives through the experience, but at the cost of nearly losing his mind. Indeed, even though he is the center of his community's hopes for prosperity and peace, Sir Henry must travel away in an effort to regain his wits. The single-minded malevolence of Stapleton is particularly potent in a world in which images are uncertain, mysteries have multiple solutions, and mere human beings are uncertain of the truth and themselves. AH this make The Hound of the Baskervilles an exciting read and an excellent subject for discussion.
1. One of the most interesting aspects of The Hound of the Baskervilles is the absence of Sherlock Holmes for much of the narrative. Is he really the main character? Could one make a case for Watson actually being the main character? Does he not have more to do with the action than Holmes?
2. A common reaction of readers to The Hound of the Baskervilles is amazement at its tension and its ability to hold a reader in taut suspense. What about this novel leaves many readers breathless at the end, as if they had themselves been running from the dreaded hound? What makes this short novel so gripping? Is it Watson's unadorned writing style? Is it a well-balanced mixture of supernatural and man-made danger? Is it the choice of setting, dark and mysterious, threatening death to unwary walkers?
3. Note how Conan Doyle builds his images in the novel. Each image adds to a frightful atmosphere in which horrors may lurk anywhere. In the city a mysterious cane leads to a doctor with a disturbing tale to tell to a threatening letter. In the country of the mire, a pony dies an anguished death, and at that point any kind of evil seems possible. What other images does Conan Doyle use to pull his audience into his world of romance and mystery? How does Holmes himself deal with these images?
4. It can be fun to compare the novel to its motion picture...
(The entire section is 1,011 words.)