illustrated outline of a large, ferocious-looking dog with red eyes

The Hound of the Baskervilles

by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

Start Free Trial

Discussion Topic

Endings and alternate endings of The Hound of the Baskervilles

Summary:

In The Hound of the Baskervilles, the original ending reveals that the culprit behind the Baskerville family curse is Jack Stapleton, who used a trained hound to instill fear and commit murder. While there are no officially recognized alternate endings, various adaptations and retellings have introduced different conclusions, including scenarios where Stapleton escapes or meets different fates.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does The Hound of the Baskervilles end?

If you need a refresher on the ending, my best advice is to study Chapter 15: A Retrospection. In this chapter, Sherlock Holmes gives us a great summary of pertinent events in the Hound Of The Baskervilles. He ties up loose ends by explaining the whole case to Watson.

According to Watson, Mr. Stapleton was a Baskerville. He was actually the son of Rodger Baskerville, who was Sir Charles' younger brother. This Stapleton character married a Costa Rican beauty, Beryl Garcia. Being an avaricious man, Stapleton concluded that he needed to get rid of the two individuals who stood between him and the Baskerville fortune if he was to enjoy great wealth.

Stapleton accordingly settled near his ancestral home and started cultivating friendships with Sir Charles and the neighbors. Oblivious to Stapleton's true intentions, Sir Charles confided to his new friend his fears surrounding the legend of the Baskerville hound. Stapleton, having gained knowledge of Sir Charles' heart condition, plotted to use the legend as a means to facilitate the baronet's death. For this purpose, he purchased the fiercest and strongest hound money could buy in London.

However, Stapleton found it difficult to catch Sir Charles out of doors at night, on account of his fears regarding the legendary Baskerville hound. Stapleton tried to enlist his wife, Beryl, to sexually entice Sir Charles, but she refused to participate in his machinations. Holmes tells Watson that threats and blows from her husband were insufficient to change her mind. Stapleton soon turned to a Laura Lyons for help. He managed to enlist her help by hinting that he would marry her if she got a divorce. Stapleton manipulated Laura to arrange a meeting with Sir Charles and then perversely prevented her from showing up to the meeting. Instead, Stapleton showed up and let his hound loose upon Sir Charles. The hound chased the baronet relentlessly. Due to the fright, Sir Charles died of a heart attack.

Stapleton's next goal was to kill off Sir Henry Baskerville, the other possible heir to the Baskerville fortune. Despite her fear of her husband's terrible temper, Beryl secretly warned Sir Henry that his life was in danger. Meanwhile, Stapleton bribed employees of the hotel where Sir Henry was staying in order to obtain one of Sir Henry's boots. This was for the purpose of acclimating the hound to Sir Henry's scent. By this time, Holmes had ascertained that Stapleton was Sir Charles' murderer. He resolved that the only way to catch Stapleton was to use Sir Henry as bait. Poor Sir Henry!

On the day of Sir Henry's supposed murder, Beryl learned that she had a rival for her husband's affections. She was furious, and Stapleton suspected that she would betray him. So, he tied her up and rationalized his actions by resolving to woo her affections back after Sir Henry's murder. However, unluckily for Stapleton, he did not bargain for Holmes, Dr. Watson, and Lestrade, who stood ready to defend Sir Henry.

When Stapleton let the hound loose upon Sir Henry, all three men shot at the monstrous dog, which, on account of the phosphorus around its muzzle, seemed to be spewing fire out of its mouth. At the last moment, Holmes managed to save Sir Henry by firing five extra rounds into the animal. Stapleton himself was never caught, and his wife asserted that he had probably fled into the Grimpen Mire.

Watson's final question to Holmes was how Stapleton could have claimed the Baskerville fortune without 'causing suspicion or inquiry' if he had succeeded in killing off Sir Henry. Holmes answered that Stapleton could have done it by either claiming the fortune from abroad, by utilizing an elaborate disguise to conceal his true identity, or by hiring someone else to claim the fortune on his behalf.

The chapter ends with Holmes and Watson making plans to have dinner at a restaurant before going to the opera.

Approved by eNotes Editorial

Videos

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What are some possible alternate endings for The Hound of the Baskervilles?

We cannot write your assignment for you, but if we give you some ideas, you should be able to come up with a page of writing.

I have always thought that it was less than satisfying to have Stapleton fall over the cliff in his hideout at  Great Grimpen Mire. Don't you think you could write a much scarier ending by extending the gothic qualities of this novel by not having the hound meet his demise by being shot by Holmes and Watson and perhaps turning on Stapleton? It would be poetic justice. You could invent some way that the hound would have wanted to pursue Stapleton. Let's say that he has also stolen a jacket that belonged to Sir Henry, not just his boot. Let's say that Stapleton was wearing the jacket when he excaped to the Mire. The hound breaks loose from his fetters and, following the scent that he thinks is Sir Henry's, he pursues Stapleton to the Mire.

You can create some gothic drama. Have Stapleton sitting before a fire on the Mire. He is trying to keep warm and eating some beef jerky. He hears an eery howl from far away. No big deal, he tells himself. It is probably some stray dog that has wandered onto the Mire. But the howling gets louder. And closer. And soon, he hears rustling of leaves and twigs. He gets up to investigate. Nothing. He starts to hear the heavy breathing of an animal. He looks around. Nothing. Suddenly, he sees two bright yellow orbs right in front of his face. He then smells a hideous odor. He then comes face to face with the hideous beast. The beast bears his teeth and attacks, jumping on Stapleton and tearing his jacket to pieces, then tearing out his throat, just as in the legend of the Hound of the Baskervilles of long ago.

Get more ideas here on eNotes.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial