Ideas for Group Discussions

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Leonard's rich tapestry of Western tales, with Hombre as a standout example, offers a compelling opportunity to delve into the quintessentially American genre. Exploring multiple works of his could provide a fascinating gateway into this literary form. Moreover, since adaptations of Hombre and others have graced the silver screen, comparing the novels with their cinematic counterparts might spark engaging conversations about the contrasts between these art forms.

Exploring Narrative Perspectives

1. Dive into the narrative lens. Imagine how the story might transform if the all-seeing author, instead of Carl Everett Allen, took the reins as the storyteller.

The Enigmatic Loner

2. Uncover the influences that shaped John Russell into a solitary figure. Does his isolation detract from his character?

The Stagecoach Journey

3. In what particular ways does the journey by stagecoach mark a pivotal moment for Russell? Does it alter him in any way?

Passenger Interactions

4. A significant portion of the narrative focuses on the dynamics among the stagecoach passengers. What role does this interplay serve? Does it propel the story forward?

A Moral Force

5. The narrator paints Russell as a profound moral catalyst, suggesting he inspired transformation in others. How did his presence impact those around him?

Rivalry and Heroism

6. What makes Frank Braden the perfect adversary for Russell? Russell's demise during their dramatic showdown is seen as heroic. Can the same be said for Braden? Why or why not?

A Gritty Reality

7. Based on your understanding of the American West, does Leonard render the setting with authenticity?

Leonard's Distinctive Style

8. Leonard claims an aversion to metaphors and diligently strikes out adjectives and adverbs. Is Hombre distinguished by its minimalist style? How does this style intertwine with the novel's substance?

Responsibilities and Morality

9. The prologue of a 1989 edition declares that Russell "emerges as a central figure in a drama scrutinizing man's duties to his fellow man." What are these duties within the story's universe? Does any character fulfill them?

A Complex Hero

10. According to a Leonard biographer, "Russell is clearly no white-hatted Galahad seeking to right wrongs and rescue the defenseless." Does this portrayal ring true?

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Loading...