Student Question
How is the relationship between Lake-men and Wood-elves depicted in The Hobbit?
Quick answer:
The relationship between the Lake-men and the Wood-elves in The Hobbit is primarily based on trade and is generally amicable. They occasionally have disputes over river-trolls, although the details are not specified. The upkeep of the river, a crucial trade route, is a shared concern, especially as natural events have made it unpredictable. This mutual dependency for trade fosters a closer relationship compared to that between elves and dwarves, with intermarriage being more common among men and elves.
On average, the Lake-men and the Wood-elves had an easy relationship, primarily based on trade. The narrator mentions that there are occasional squabbles about river-trolls, but does not elaborate what role the elves or the men have in regards to these.
The wood-elves are responsible for the upkeep of the river, which has become especially difficult with recent changes. With earthquakes and flooding, the river channel has become unpredictable. As this is the major avenue of trade, it of course is a major focus of the relationship between the two races about whose responsibility it is to maintain it.
The road that the dwarves had initially started on from the west dwindled as it neared the eastern edge of Mirkwood. Thus the only reliable road is the river itself. This in effect cuts off the men and elves from the western regions of Middle-earth, making them more dependent on each other for trade. The relationship between men and elves has always been rather close, much more so than elves and dwarves, for instance. Men and elves do tend to intermarry, Elrond Half-elven being a prime example.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.