Why was Henry VIII denied a divorce from Catherine of Aragon by the Catholic Church?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Henry did not want a divorce, but an annulment.  The real reason Henry VIII could not get a papal annulment of his marriage was the political and military power of Catherine's nephew, Emperor Charles V. It was actually a bit more complicated than just wanting the dispensation, there were many complications involving the marriage itself, the balance of power in Europe and Catherine's family.  First of all, Catherine of Aragon had been wife to Henry's older brother, Arthur, the heir to the throne of Britain.  Arthur died four months later, and a treaty was signed between Henry VII and Catherine's parents (Ferdinand and Isabella of Columbus fame) allowing for a marriage between Catherine and the new heir to the throne Prince Henry (who of course became Henry VIII).  This marriage of a man to his brother's wife required a papal dispensation.  It was not a necessity, since Catherine swore her marriage to Arthur had never been consummated, but the monarchs requested and received dispensation as a formality This became important later during the annulment attempt.

The marriage was beset with political difficulties before it even took place, and afterwards produced no male heir to Henry VIII's throne.  A miscarriage was followed by a son who died very shortly, followed by a second miscarriage and a second son who died soon.  Mary was born next, followed by apparently two more miscarried pregnancies.  Henry wanted an heir (and had a keen eye for the ladies, anyway), and by the time his romance with Anne Boleyn became known Catherine was 42 and unable to bear children.  So Henry decided to petition the Pope for an annulment on the grounds of childlessness and her first marriage to his brother.  Of course, there had been three children, one of whom was still alive, but politically this didn't matter to Henry, he wanted a male heir.  As to the first marriage, a dispensation had been granted so it didn't matter, and Catherine swore all her life the marriage had not been consummated.  Given Prince Arthur's health issues that seems likely.

Henry's problem was that Catherine appealed to her nephew Charles of the House of Hapsburg.  He was son of Catherine's sister Joanna and Philip of Burgundy, and also happened to be King of Spain, Holy Roman Emperor and ruler of Burgundy, Naples, Milan, etc.  Essentially, Charles V was the major power on the mainland of Europe, and he let the pope know that if he granted an annulment to Henry VIII he, Charles V, would sack Rome. The pope spent six years prevaricating and wrangling over details with Henry until, in 1533, Anne Boleyn became pregnant.  Henry VIII simply ordered the Archbishop of Canterbury, Thomas Cranmer, to grant the annulment and broke with the Roman Church.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Divorce was not allowed. Henry fell in love with Anne Boleyn and this is one of the main reasons why he wanted an annulment. When Henry fell in love with Anne, Catherine was no longer able to bear him any more children. She had several miscarriages but had one healthy daughter. Not a son, but a daughter. Henry wanted a male heir and Catherine could not give him this heir. He petitioned the Pope, not for a divorce, but for an annulment. This is because he believed (or perhaps it was an excuse) that marrying his brothers wife was not seen right in the eyes of God.  Catherine swore she did not consummate the marriage to Henry's brother, therefore she was never really married to him. After 6 years of being denied the annulment by the Pope, Henry had Thomas Cranmer, the archbishop of Canterbury, grant the annulment.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

This sort of depends upon your own attitudes towards the Catholic Church and the values it stood for back in those days.

The official reason that the Church did not allow Henry to divorce is that divorce was absolutely forbidden in those days.  The Church simply did not allow them.

But lots of monarchs got divorces in similar circumstances --- they could petition the Pope to annul their marriages.  So why not Henry?  Historians who are more critical of the Church say that the Pope denied Henry because the Pope was related to the King of Spain, who was Henry's enemy.  The claim is that the Pope wanted to make sure Henry would have no heir so the King of Spain would have a better chance of taking England over.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Why did Pope Clement not allow Henry VIII to divorce Catherine of Aragon and marry Anne Boleyn?

The pope's reasons for refusing to grant a divorce were largely political. Henry VIII prided himself on being a good Catholic. He was awarded the title Fidei defensor—defender of the faith—by Pope Leo X for his withering attacks on Martin Luther. Not unreasonably, then, Henry believed that he was in good standing with the Church and could therefore count on papal support for his intended divorce.

However, Clement VII was unable to offer much in the way of assistance to Henry, even had he really wanted to. At that time, the pope had much more serious problems to worry about, such as his bitter political dispute with the Holy Roman Emperor Charles V. Relations between the pope and the emperor had deteriorated so much that imperial forces invaded and sacked the city of Rome, causing widespread death and destruction. Clement was forced to hide in the Castel Sant' Angelo, where he was eventually imprisoned for six months.

Unsurprisingly, Clement had other things on his mind than a highly improper request from a monarch who wasn't even a particularly major player in European politics. Besides, Charles V was Catherine of Aragon's nephew, and he was deeply upset at Henry's shabby treatment of his aunt. Had Clement granted Henry a divorce, it would have antagonized the Emperor even more, and that's the last thing he needed at that time.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Why did Pope Clement not allow Henry VIII to divorce Catherine of Aragon and marry Anne Boleyn?

The English King Henry VIII desired to divorce Catherine of Aragon to marry Anne Boleyn. However, Catholic teaching forbids divorce, so Henry had to receive special permission from Pope Clement VII. Aside from Catholic doctrine, Clement refused to grant Henry's request for two main reasons: it would reduce papal authority and it would offend Emperor Charles V.

Before he could marry Catherine, Henry had to receive special permission from the Pope (Catherine had briefly been married to Henry's brother, who died soon after the wedding. The Pope agreed to annul this marriage so Henry could wed Catherine). Henry asked Clement VII to declare his marriage to Catherine invalid, which would directly contradict the declaration which had allowed him to marry her originally. The result of this action would have been to weaken the authority of papal decrees.

Additionally, Catherine was the aunt of Charles V, the Emperor of the Holy Roman Empire. Charles' troops mutinied and sacked Rome in 1527--taking Clement VII prisoner in the process. Charles was embarrassed by this act, but it clearly showed the state had the upper hand if conflict arose with the Catholic Church. If Clement granted Henry's appeal, he would have incurred Charles' anger, and whom he clearly was in no position to openly oppose.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on