Student Question
What is the meaning of this quote about the welfare state and individual freedom?
"It seems equally logical to me that individuals cannot be free if they are beset by fear and insecurity. To my mind the welfare state is simply a state in which people are free to develop their individual capacities, pursue just awards for their talents and to engage in the pursuit of happinesss, unburdened by the fear of actual hunger, actual homelessness or oppression by reason of race creed or color."
Quick answer:
The quote, from Senator Herbert Lehman in 1950, argues that true individual freedom requires protection from fear and insecurity, which the welfare state provides. Lehman defends the welfare state against claims it limits freedom, asserting that it enables people to develop their capacities and pursue happiness without fear of hunger, homelessness, or discrimination. He contends that freedom is meaningless if basic needs are unmet, highlighting the importance of welfare reforms initiated during the New Deal.
This passage is an excerpt from a speech given by liberal New York Senator Herbert Lehman in 1950. Lehman supports expanding many of the reforms that had been initiated during the New Deal, and this quote is basically defending the concept of a welfare state from detractors who claim that it infringes on the rights of individuals. Lehman is speaking at the height of the second Red Scare of the late 1940s and early 1950s, and he is concerned that government regulation of economic activity has become identified with communism. Lehman argues that far from taking freedom away from individuals, the welfare state creates meaningful freedom for people. People are not truly free, he argues, if they suffer from economic "insecurity." By protecting people from "actual hunger,actual homelessness or oppression by reason of race creed or color," he is saying, the welfare state can provide people with true freedom--the freedom to pursue happiness, and to live a full life. Freedom, he suggests, is meaningless if one's basic needs are not being met, and the poverty of many people is not an acceptable price to pay for full economic freedom. In short, then, this quote is a defense of the welfare state whose foundations lay in FDR's New Deal.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.