Student Question
Is the information in Ancient Rome's artwork--from Roman Republic to Empire--reliable?
Quick answer:
Art from Ancient Rome is generally reliable for understanding contemporary fashion because it was created by artists with firsthand knowledge of their subjects. However, its reliability is limited by the fact that much of this art was produced for wealthy patrons, who might have influenced the portrayal of scenes to enhance their enjoyment rather than provide accurate documentation. Therefore, while the artwork offers valuable insights, it may not always depict an entirely accurate representation of historical reality.
Since you have been asking questions regarding fashion and clothing, I will answer this question with reference to that area.
The main thing that makes art work from ancient Rome reliable is that it was produced by people who would have had firsthand knowledge of what people in Ancient Rome were wearing. This was not artwork that was produced centuries after the fact. Since it is typically depicting contemporary subjects, it should be generally reliable.
The main thing that would make this kind of artwork unreliable is that it was not necessarily produced for the purpose of documenting fashion. Much of the art that was produced in ancient Rome was produced for the pleasure of rich patrons of the arts. Artists might, therefore, have produced art that would have appealed to those rich people, not art that documented how things really were. For example, if an artist happened to paint a scene that had slaves in it, he might not want to portray the slaves looking wretched since that might detract from the patron’s enjoyment of the painting. Thus, the fact that this art was not produced for documentary purposes might make it less reliable.
What makes Italian and Northern Renaissance artwork reliable or unreliable?
Three significant elements in both Northern and Italian Renaissance artwork that make them reliable are perspective and surface detail and anatomical detail.
Perspective renders space and locale depiction reliable as one can asertain how shapes fit together in a three dimensional space.
Surface detail, as to a lady's lace or the play of light and shadow, render materials and objects reliable as one can determine that quality of craftsmanship and workmanship in productions of the time.
Anatomical detail renders physical proportions and development reliable as one can see the accurate representation of the human form and of the forms of other species.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
References