Student Question
What if George Washington had become a king instead of a president?
Quick answer:
If George Washington had become a king, the United States' history might have mirrored that of Mexico, where civil wars erupted between monarchists and republicans. Although Washington was a popular leader, his acceptance of a monarchy could have led to internal conflict. Despite some support for the idea, Washington likely would have refused due to fatigue and his commitment to democratic principles, ultimately preventing the U.S. from becoming a monarchy.
We might well have let him do just that. As one of the only universally popular founding fathers, George Washington was considered a true American hero at the time. Alexander Hamilton was not averse to the idea of having our own King George as opposed to the British version.
Most likely, Washington would never have accepted such a position, if for no other reason than he was tired, having served his country in almost every manner he could since before the Revolution. If he had become King, it's also quite possible he would have been just as wise, just as considerate of individual rights as he was in his Presidency. That's what we call a "benevolent monarch". Luckily, he was also wise enough never to let us become a monarchy at all.
At the very least, the history of the United States would have been...
Unlock This Answer Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
very different.
It is not a direct analogy, but I think that the experience of Mexico might be helpful.
When they became independent, Augustin Iturbide allowed himself to be made emperor. From then on, instead of having elections, they pretty much had a series of civil wars between monarchists and people who wanted a republic.
So I can imagine Jefferson and his people leading a rebellion and Hamilton and his people fighting the Jeffersonians... Not good.