Student Question
What is the difference between a protectorate and a sphere of influence?
Quick answer:
A "sphere of influence" involves a foreign power claiming exclusive privileges in a region, such as economic or political influence, without formal control over the nation's internal affairs. Examples include the Monroe Doctrine. In contrast, a "protectorate" involves direct control, where a foreign power actively influences or controls certain governmental aspects, though the nation retains its internal government. The level of foreign involvement can range from defense guarantees to puppet governance.
A "sphere of influence" is an area in which a foreign power claims to have exclusive privileges (but does not play a formal role in the nation's internal affairs). These privileges may be economic, political, or cultural, and they do not necessarily require the approval of the "influenced" nation. For example, the United States declared a "sphere of influence" over the Western hemisphere when they passed the Monroe Doctrine in 1823. They threatened to view further European colonization of the Western hemisphere as acts of aggression.
In a "protectorate," the foreign power exerts formal control over the protected nation. The protected nation still retains its own internal government, but the foreign power exercises plays an active role in some aspect of its government (foreign policy, for example). The degree of control may vary. A foreign nation may simply guarantee to protect another nation from invasion, or the protected nation may function as little more than a puppet government ruled by the foreign one.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.