Student Question
What are the arguments for and against the existence of Israel?
Quick answer:
Arguments for Israel's existence include its recognition as a legitimate nation by much of the world, the impracticality of dissolving an established government, potential increased violence if dissolved, and its status as the traditional Jewish homeland. Arguments against include claims that Israel was illegitimately founded on land taken from Palestinians, leading to ongoing conflict. Detractors argue the land should be returned to Palestinians to end regional violence.
The current State of Israel was founded on May 14, 1948, as part of the Zionist movement and the settlements after World War II. However, there are some who believe that Israel should be dissolved due to the continuing violence in the region. Let's explore a few arguments on both sides of the question of Israel's continuing existence.
First, you might talk about Israel's official existence, which is recognized by much of the world. It is, in many people's eyes, a legitimate nation that cannot simply be dissolved. The Israelis have established a government of their own. The people have created lives for themselves in the land for almost seventy-five years. A dissolution at this point would simply not be practical and would cause much hardship and suffering. You could also think about the possibility of increased violence that might occur if such a move were attempted. Also, mention the fact that the area is the traditional homeland of the Jewish people.
On the other hand, though, others claim that Israel was never legitimate to start with and that the land it occupies was unfairly and even illegally taken from other people. They argue that the land should be restored to its rightful owners (the Palestinians). This would bring an end to the constant violence in the region, which is largely due to the original inhabitants protesting their lost land and trying to recover it.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.