Discussion Topic

The influence of the Enlightenment and the Great Awakening on the American colonies' religious diversity and democratic development

Summary:

The Enlightenment and the Great Awakening significantly influenced the American colonies by promoting religious diversity and democratic development. The Enlightenment emphasized reason and individualism, challenging traditional authority and encouraging religious tolerance. Meanwhile, the Great Awakening fostered a spirit of revivalism and personal faith, leading to the proliferation of various denominations. Together, these movements cultivated a more pluralistic and democratic society.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How did the Enlightenment and the Great Awakening influence the American colonies?

The Enlightenment's focus on individual rights and empirical science strongly influenced currents of political and economic development in both Europe and the American colonies. Enlightenment thinking treated the existence of both proper science and natural rights as objective facts that could be grasped by any rational person with a proper education.

The Enlightenment's focus on individualized natural rights and the power of reasoned persuasion created the conditions for the British colonists to see themselves as individuals who had the right to self-govern. The work of philosophers like John Locke and Montesquieu was particularly influential. In his Second Treatise, Locke made the case for life, liberty, and property as natural rights. He also argued that a government that did not respect citizens' natural rights could justifiably be overthrown.

The Enlightenment understanding of natural rights and the right to revolution is present in a number of colonial constitutions and treaties as well as the Declaration of Independence.

Empiricism and experimentation in all realms of physical science were also encouraged during the Enlightenment. The Enlightenment's embrace of something more akin to a modern scientific method laid the groundwork for a number of important inventions, like the cotton gin and steamboat engine, that revolutionized economic production and laid the groundwork for the American industrial revolution in the 19th century.

Historians have found that there are commonly reactions against profound political and economic changes, like the ones brought on by the Enlightenment. Most scholars believe both Great Awakenings (the first was in the 1730s and 40s and the second was in the early 19th century) were, in part, reactions to the revolutionary ideas and massive changes of the Enlightenment period.

The First Great Awakening emphasized the importance of subjective and emotional experiences. Faith and passion--which were contrary to the Enlightenment credo of rationality--were prized during these religious revivals. Preachers like George Whitefield and Jonathan Edwards gave spellbinding sermons that used highly charged rhetoric to paint pictures of ecstatic heavenly bliss or incomprehensibly terrifying damnation. (It is important to note that Edwards was also critical of some of the more excessive zealotry.)

The conflict that arose between the "New Lights," who preferred a subjective, emotional orientation in their sermons, and the "Old Lights," who used a more reason-based, analytic approach to religion, is arguably the ancestor of the current conflict between Evangelical and Mainline Protestants.

Another important thing about the First Great Awakening is that it provided some opportunities for women and slaves. The preachers of the Great Awakening took special care to reach out to slaves and promised slaves that they were equal before God (even if they weren't equal on earth). We know that the Black Christian Church was an extremely important force in the civil rights movement, which means the work that preachers like Whitefield did to convert slaves during the time of the Great Awakening had an extremely important historical impact. The Greak Awakening's focus on emotions also gave increased power and legitimacy to women, and more women were able to express themselves via literature and poetry.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Compare and contrast the Great Awakening and the Enlightenment.

Both the Great Awakening and the Enlightenment were eighteenth-century movements. They were both influential throughout the British Atlantic, including Great Britain's North American colonies. They both featured an emphasis on the individual, including a movement toward individual and universal rights. But in many ways the similarities end there. The Great Awakening, in fact, has been interpreted as a reaction to the Enlightenment. The Awakening was a series of religious revivals in the British Atlantic world. It emphasized emotion, pathos, and an individual and direct relationship with God. It also rejected what was seen as the cold rationalism of the Enlightenment, especially as it was expressed in the mechanistic religious philosophy known as Deism. The Enlightenment was ultimately a secular movement, and while its adherents varied widely in their religious beliefs, they generally eschewed what they called religious "enthusiasm," a term that meant something like "fanaticism" today. The rationalism and scientific worldview that characterized the mainstream of Enlightenment thought were very much at odds with the Great Awakening.

References

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How did the Enlightenment and the Great Awakening influence the growth of Christian denominations and democracy during the late colonial period in British America?

The Enlightenment was a movement founded on reason and science over superstition and tradition. Begun in Europe, the Enlightenment witnessed an improvement in science, a belief in the importance of experiments, and an awareness of natural law. In addition, many philosophes (or French philosophers) such as Voltaire applied these ideas to government, and they argued that reason and laws should govern the way rulers led their people. In America, many of the Founding Fathers, such as Jefferson, were followers of Enlightenment ideals. While many were raised in the Anglican Church (the Church of England), they began to turn to Deism. This is essentially the idea that God exists, but that God created the universe, as a watchmaker would, and then let people run the world themselves. This belief system allowed religion to co-exist with a belief in science. Deism also began to threaten or at least question the beliefs of the Bible and established religion.

There were two Great Awakenings in America. The first, which occurred in the 1730s and 1740s, returned to a belief in predestination, or the idea that one's fate was decided before birth, and it swept over New England. Many traditional preachers and teachings were abandoned in favor of a more spiritual approach to religion, and the Methodist, Baptist, and other religions gained popularity in the New World. The Second Great Awakening, which took place around 1800, featured an emphasis on good works, and led to the popularization of church revivals as well as reform movements such as abolitionism. Preachers began to try to include everyone in their revivals, whatever their background, race, or gender. As a result, many women became adherents in these new, more spiritual forms of religion, as did slaves and freed African-Americans. As a result, religion became more democratized, as these religions afforded a more powerful role to formerly marginalized groups. 

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial