How were the Indian Ocean routes and Silk routes similar and different?

Quick answer:

The Silk Road and Indian Ocean trading routes both facilitated the movement of luxury goods from East Asia to the Mediterranean and Europe, fostering cultural exchange and the spread of religions like Islam and Buddhism. Both were seasonal, with merchants timing their journeys around natural conditions. Differences included the type of goods transported, with the Indian Ocean route also carrying common goods such as grain due to higher capacity of ships. The mode of transportation also differed, with camels primarily used on the Silk Road and dhows, and later larger ships, used in the Indian Ocean.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The Silk Road and Indian Ocean trading routes were similar in that they both served the purpose of moving luxury goods from East Asia to the markets of the Mediterranean and Europe via the Middle East. Both routes specialized in luxury goods, namely silk, porcelain, and spices. This is because it was very expensive to transport goods over long distances and merchants could maximize their profits by focusing on smaller and more expensive products.

The routes also served to create stronger relations between the different regions involved based on mutual economic interests and cultural exchange. This led to the spread of various religions along the trade-routes, particularly Islam and Buddhism. As these religions were spread by merchants, they often underwent changes as they were adapted by the new populations which received them.

Both routes also operated on a seasonal basis. Merchants on the Silk Road had to time the various parts of their journey to coincide with clear mountain passes, full watering holes, and abundant forage. The sailors on the Indian Ocean were at the mercy of the Monsoon winds which would blow them northeast in the summer and southwest in the winter.

While both routes carried luxury goods to European markets, the Indian Ocean route also carried common goods, such as grain. This is because a ship can carry much more cargo for cheaper than a camel can. Also, because this sea route also involved the East Coast of Africa, African goods, such as ivory and gold were moved across the Indian Ocean, reaching markets in the East.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Both were similar in that they were seasonal, though the Indian sea voyage was more so than the Silk Road route. People on the Silk Road often tried to time their trips to take advantage of when the grass would be greenest on the steppe. The Indian Sea voyage required monsoon winds.

Both routes were partially controlled by Muslims at some point—this would be the primary incentive for Europeans to attempt to sail west in order to reach the East. Both trips were highly dangerous with both natural disasters and robbers being the primary dangers.

Both trade routes could make someone a great deal of money if one returned with enough silk, gold, and spices. Both trade routes were also known as early as the Roman era as Rome nearly bankrupted itself bringing in luxury goods from the East as the expense of shipping its gold abroad.

The primary difference was the mode of transportation. The initial trade in the Indian Ocean was carried out by traders using dhows, or small ocean-going vessels. These vessels often had shallow drafts which allowed them to stop in various small ports or in river deltas in order to refit the ships. Eventually, Portuguese and Spanish sailors would make the voyage around Africa to get to India using larger ships.

The Silk Road was mainly traversed by camels, though horses would be instrumental for part of the trip. These camels were used almost exclusively as pack animals, and the travelers often had to walk.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

There are many differences and similarities between the two routes. The type of goods is just one example. The benefactors of the routes also differed. The Chinese were the primary benefactors of the Silk Road, whereas the Indian Ocean route benefited the Chinese, Indian and the Middle East alike.

However, possibly the most important differences come from the mode of transport.

Transporting goods by sea, for example, was preferable during the Monsoon season. The Monsoons made travel via land difficult, but winds acted to hasten sea travel.

Both routes required 'stop overs'. These stops could provide safety, re-supply of goods, trade opportunities and rest.  For ships, these were simply ports - spread along the coastline. For road travel, the stops were 'Caravanserais'. These were placed roughly a day's ride apart - so that caravans could fully utilise their added security at night.

The differences in mode of transport also changed the length of the journey. To travel the entire silk road took approximately a year - but, there were significant trade opportunities along the way. The sea voyage was only ~six months long.  Boats could also be loaded with a larger volume of goods, compared to the camels and caravans of the silk road.

Image Credit: University of Chicago (see link under)

Image (1 of 1)
Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The Silk Road connected China with the West and facilitated trade between the different territories that stretched through the region. On the other hand, the Indian Ocean trade route connected Asia to Africa, from Java to Zanzibar and Mombasa. The route also facilitated trade exchanges between the different regions. The Silk Road route was predominantly on land and crossed water ways at the Mediterranean Sea while the Indian Ocean trade route moved predominantly on water (Indian Ocean) between ports. The Silk Road got its name from Silk because this was a major export from China which received wool and other textiles from Rome, while on the other hand the Indian Ocean trade route also known as the Cinnamon Route got its name because of the trade items which were majorly spices.

The Silk Route and the Indian Ocean trade route were both aimed at linking the West to the East. The products that went across both routes included silk and spices from the East and processed textiles from the West.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Many of their similarities appear in the goods that were transported and many of their major ports of call were also similar.  The dangers faced as they traversed their routes were obviously somewhat different, but they both faced pirates and thieves and they also had to deal with difficult weather conditions and terrible storms.

The Maritime route, or perhaps what you are referring to as the "Indian Ocean route" also allowed an extension of the silk (and spice and horses and everything else that was traded along the route) farther north through the Mediterranean Sea to Italy and other parts of Europe, a route that had not been established quite as thoroughly overland at the time.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial