Student Question
How did 19th and 20th-century scientific racism reinforce notions of racial hierarchy?
Quick answer:
Scientists in the 19th century like Samuel Morton sought to prove that there were meaningful biological distinctions between Black and White people to prove that White people were superior. These "data" were then used to justify slavery and Jim Crow laws. Even when slavery ended, attempts to prove the superiority of whiteness continued in studies like the one at the Tuskegee Institute, eventually leading to forced sterilization of those with "undesirable" traits.
Scientific racism was a major force that perpetuated inequality in the 19th and 20th centuries. Some examples focus on scientific experiments that aimed to "prove" the inferiority of nonwhite races while others aimed to curve the population growth among nonwhite people through measures like sterilization and eugenics.
As mentioned in the article, "race" was not commonly used to divide people into social groups until the 1500s. There is a general consensus today that race is not a biological reality, but a social construct; this means that there are no inherent differences in people based on the color of their skin. However, people have basically been socialized to believe that there are. In the 19th century, scientists sought to justify this belief through "experimentation." Samuel Morton used parameters like measurements of skull size to "prove" that people of African descent were intellectually, morally, and socially inferior to white people.
Though the...
Unlock
This Answer NowStart your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
science behind these conclusions was faulty, it was used to justify discrimination against Black people. For example, in the Supreme Court Case Dred Scott v. Sanford, the court ruled that Dred Scott had no legal standing to petition for his freedom because Black people were not viewed as citizens. Some people not only argued that Black people should be slaves because they were inferior, but that the institution of slavery served to "civilize them." Even when slavery was made illegal in 1865, racist ideologies fueled by this "science" created practices like segregation and sharecropping ensuring that Black people remained socially subordinate to their white counterparts. These policies were bolstered by the increasing prevalence of Social Darwinism, which asserted that people were bound to the same natural laws as other species; in other words, "survival of the fittest" meant that whichever race came out on top must be superior. White people had carefully constructed a society in which nonwhite people were subordinate, but they used this principle to contend that their social and economic status came from the natural order.
In the 20th century, this disturbing belief became the foundation of a practice called eugenics. White people wanted to manipulate genetics to "weed out" the inferior qualities of nonwhite people (specifically Black people) and create a truly superior race. (These were the same ideals that Hitler used to justify the genocide of Jews and other groups during the Holocaust). To enforce this belief, many poor Black women, as well as some poor or disabled white women, were forced to have their tubes tied so that they could not have children. Charles Davenport, the leader of the eugenics movement in the United States, conducted a longitudinal study on Black students at the Tuskegee Institute in Alabama. The study mostly consisted of taking yearly measurements of physical characteristics like weight, height, and face shape. (Source: Excerpt: The Banality of Eugenics). Like Samuel Morton's skull size studies in the 19th century, this study was used to argue that there were concrete biological distinctions between Black and White people, with those of White people being superior. In addition to fueling the unethical practice of forced sterilization, these beliefs were used to reinforce the segregation and discrimination that persisted well into the 20th century and still linger in American society today.