Discussion Topic

Comparing the rise to power and the regimes of Hitler and Stalin

Summary:

Hitler and Stalin both rose to power through exploiting political instability and economic turmoil. Hitler utilized nationalist and anti-Semitic sentiments in Germany, while Stalin leveraged his position within the Communist Party. Both regimes were marked by totalitarian control, extensive propaganda, and brutal repression of dissent. However, Hitler focused on racial ideologies and expansionism, while Stalin emphasized class struggle and industrialization.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What are four similarities and differences in Hitler's and Stalin's rise to power?

Hitler and Stalin emerged as dictators of Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union, respectively, in the same era. Stalin assumed power over the Soviet Union in the mid-1920s, while Hitler and his Nazi Party controlled Germany by 1933. Their regimes spanned World War II, in which the two dictators were main antagonists. Stalin, victorious in that conflict, lived until 1953. The main similarities between the two dictators lie in the methods they employed to rule. Both men used terror and mass propaganda in an attempt to control the lives of their people. They violently purged their own parties, including political allies, in an effort to consolidate power. Stalin's purges in 1934 cost hundreds of thousands of lives, and Hitler's so-called "Night of the Long Knives," among other brutal purges, killed many party members, including long-time supporters. Both leaders operated concentration and forced labor camps for perceived opponents of the state, and both used secret police to establish an atmosphere of fear and suspicion necessary to sustain their rule.

Despite these similarities, Stalin and Hitler were diametrically opposed in an ideological sense. Stalin had risen to power as a consequence of the Bolshevik Revolution, in the wake of Lenin. He went about modernizing the Soviet state through collective agriculture and state-run industries. He was, in short, a communist. Hitler had risen to power in no small part due to fears of communism, especially among German businessmen. While he definitely expanded the powers of the German state, he did not embark on the kind of collectivist program that Stalin did, because it was anathema to National Socialism. Stalin's ideology was fundamentally based upon class struggle, arguing that the world (and the Soviet state) was threatened by capitalists that had to be resisted. Likewise, he framed Soviet unity as a function of this class struggle. Hitler infamously viewed the world in radicalized terms, scapegoating Jews (who he often publicly associated with Bolshevism and socialism) in particular. German identity and unity was radicalized, with Hitler framing the nation as the expression of pure "Aryan" civilization.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What are the similarities and differences between Hitler's and Stalin's regimes?

Hitler and Stalin both rose to, and consolidated their power through a combination of ruthless politics and violence. Both men, once in power, purged their opponents, some of whom had been their allies on the way up. Hitler, for instance, had many of the leaders of his paramilitary "brownshirts" murdered, and Stalin's infamous purges were a naked attempt to solidify his control over the Soviet government. Additionally, both men skillfully used propaganda and a state bureaucracy to strengthen their one-party control. Both established police states, shipping dissidents, imagined or otherwise, to concentration camps and gulags. Both men murdered millions of people, Hitler in the Holocaust and Stalin as part of forced collectivization, as well as the brutal purges. 

Their differences were in the area of ideology as well as how they organized the societies they controlled. As a communist, Stalin's collectivization efforts, mentioned above, were part of his attempts to rapidly industrialize, taking control of peasant collective farms in an effort to support enormous government-run factories in the cities. Hitler, on the other hand, also set quotas for manufacturing, but forged alliances with industrial capitalists by allowing private ownership of factories. Indeed, part of Hitler's appeal to German elites was his opposition to Bolshevism. Hitler also emphasized a higly racialized form of nationalism, where Stalin, at least in theory, espoused a theory of communist revolution that rejected race and nation as constructs of capitalist society. 

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on