Student Question
Compare and contrast the causes, events, results, and policies of the US and Soviet Union in the Vietnam and Afghanistan wars.
Quick answer:
The Vietnam War and the Soviet-Afghan War both involved superpowers entering conflicts to support friendly governments and impose their ideologies, with the U.S. aiming to curb communism in Vietnam and the Soviet Union trying to maintain a communist regime in Afghanistan. Both wars faced resistance from local populations, leading to military stalemates and eventual withdrawals. The U.S. sought to eliminate terrorism in Afghanistan, while both conflicts revealed the challenges of imposing foreign policies on culturally distinct regions.
Both are wars in which the U.S. need not have entered and had/have little chance for complete victory or success. The U.S.'s entry into Vietnam was strictly about the attempt to restrict the spread of communism, though there was little chance that it would have directly affected America. Sending troops to Afghanistan at least had a more specific intent: to wipe out Al-Qaeda and halt the world's primary terrorist threat.
In both cases, the superpower went in with the assumption that the country would be eager to change and adopt the governmental style and economic philosophy of the superpower; in both cases, this was a false assumption. Superpowers have a bad habit of thinking that everyone else wants to be like them, which is not the case. We all need to learn to be more respectful of the importance of recognizing the history, culture, and values of other lands and peoples and not be in such a hurry to convert others to our way of doing things.
These wars were quite similar in that both superpowers got in to the wars to prop up governments that were friendly to them. Both ended up getting stuck trying to support these unpopular governments. Both lost because they had no way to defeat the enemy militarily because the enemy had too much political support among the people.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.