Discussion Topic
Causes of Westward Expansion in the 1840s and 1850s
Summary:
Westward expansion in the 1840s and 1850s was driven by a combination of economic, ideological, and social factors. The Gold Rush of 1848 attracted many seeking fortune, while the promise of cheap land and new opportunities drew settlers westward. The concept of Manifest Destiny provided ideological motivation, promoting the belief that the U.S. was destined to expand across the continent. Economic hardship, such as the Panic of 1837, and a desire for religious freedom also fueled migration. Expansion was further facilitated by treaties and infrastructure developments like the Oregon Trail and railroads.
Why did people migrate westward in the 1840s and 1850s?
The western expansion of the 1840s and 1850s is often discussed in the same breath as the Gold Rush, but, in fact, there were many other settlers who had already begun moving west before the Gold Rush began. In 1841, the first wagon trails began to move along the Oregon Trail into the West, the beginning of many similar journeys made by those who had heard tell of the cheap land and opportunities in the West for people to make something of themselves, free from the confinement and expense of the growing cities on the Eastern seaboard. While the Oregon Trail was long and dangerous, and many died of sickness and conflict with Native Americans along the way, stories continued to be told of the opportunities the unsettled West offered.
It was indeed the discovery of gold, however, which turned the steady trickle of westward settlers into a deluge. Gold...
Unlock
This Answer NowStart your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
was found in California in 1848; tens of thousands of would-be miners had arrived in California by the following year. These men were known as forty-niners, and many of them did make a fortune from gold. This sparked the root of the American Dream: any man, people came to think, could make his fortune if he would only put in the work. The miners soon sent for their wives and children, settled and intermarried, and the mining settlements became towns of some significance. By 1850, California had been set up with a governor as a state of the Union (it had to reach a population of 60,000 to do this, so a publicity campaign had helped encourage westward expansion until this point was reached).
Westward expansion continued well into the 1860s and 70s, after the Homestead Act was established to offer 160 acres of land in the West to anyone willing to work it for five years. Meanwhile, the establishment and spread of the railroads meant that the journey west was no longer the terrifying prospect it had once been when it had to be made by wagon trail. However, it was the Gold Rush which truly turned westward expansion into the dream of fortune and opportunity which continued to drive movement in that direction for decades afterwards.
References
What prompted westward expansion in the 1840s?
Ideologically, Manifest Destiny drove the westward expansion movement of the 1840's. Manifest Destiny was the concept that stated that it was the destiny of the United States to prevail over the entire American continent and spread its cultural values. Manifest Destiny was one of the reasons that the United States cited for taking Mexican and Native American territory in wars of conquest. Politically, the 1840's also marked a period of geographical expansion of the United States. The Mexican War settled the border between Texas and the United States and added valuable western territories. More Americans moved to California after it became an official American territory and a state in 1850. The United States and Britain also settled the Oregon border dispute during the 1840's, and this meant more emigration as well. Economically, the United States had just went through its worst depression up to that time with the Panic of 1837. Many people sought a new life in the West. Revolutions and famines in Europe in the 1840's led to increased immigration and many of these people sought new lives further West as well. The trails blazed by mountain men during the early part of the century were becoming well-traveled and the United States was starting to institute a system of forts along the trails west, most notably Fort Laramie on the Platte River. The discovery of gold at Sutter's Mill created a large land rush in 1849 as many emigrants sought quick riches in California.
The philosophical impetus for Western expansion had been provided long before the 1840s by Thomas Jefferson. His somewhat idealized conception of the republic was based upon a nation of independent, self-reliant farmers, both large and small. Jefferson shared the almost universal prejudice of his class that rural life was superior to life in the cities. Ownership of land gave people a stake in society; their connection to the soil provided stability and a sense of responsibility which, in turn, provided a large pool of citizens from which the nation's governing class could be drawn.
Expansionism is also prefigured in Madison's discussion of the dangers of factions in Federalist No. 10. Madison argued that the only way to minimize these dangers was to deal with their possible effects; one of the methods to achieve this was to greatly expand the size of the republic. This way, he believed, it would be harder for a majority of citizens to form themselves into a factional tyranny, as they would need to persuade more people of the justice of their cause.
Prior to the 1840s, Western expansion was not only a matter of theory, it was a reality for millions, both white settlers and Native Americans alike. However, in this particular decade, the process accelerated rapidly. One of the reasons for this was economic. In the eastern states, industrialization was growing apace, changing the very foundations of society, along with the nature of the economy. More and more people found themselves working for the first time in factories and large-scale manufacturing plants that spearheaded the new industrial revolution.
Inevitably, with such rapid industrialization came a number of serious social problems, such as crippling poverty, overcrowding, and disease. As conditions in the cities deteriorated, many looked to the wide open spaces west of the Mississippi. Many hoped to be able to live out the dream of Jefferson's rural idyll. The opportunity to lead a free, self-reliant life on one's very own land proved irresistible to millions.
However, a number of other factors prompted western expansion, not just those related to the acquisition of land. The Western territories' vast, largely unexploited mineral wealth held out the prospect of untold riches to those who previously could have only dreamed of getting rich. The greatest example of this insatiable lust for gold is the Gold Rush of 1848, which led to an enormous growth in California's population and the establishment of its eventual statehood.
The hunger for religious freedom must also be taken into account. In 1848, facing widespread persecution in the Midwest, the Mormon Church, under the leadership of Brigham Young, took part in an exodus to the Great Salt Lake Valley in order to establish their godly kingdom on earth.
In examining all these factors, we can detect a common element. All those who headed west, for whatever reason, were attempting to realize for themselves the promise of America. Land ownership, wealth, self-reliance, and religious freedom had long been integral components of the American psyche, taking on the character of almost a civic religion. When the journalist John O'Sullivan described Western expansion as the nation's "manifest destiny," he was simply coining a pithy expression that articulated how many Americans already felt. What the Founding Fathers had achieved back east, a new breed of pioneers would achieve in the wide open spaces of the West.
References