Discussion Topic
The relevance of the train's timing in "Hills Like White Elephants"
Summary:
The timing of the train in "Hills Like White Elephants" is significant because it symbolizes the urgency and pressure the couple feels in making a decision about the girl's pregnancy. The approaching train forces them to confront their situation and highlights the tension in their relationship. It also represents the inevitable passage of time and the impending change in their lives.
Why does Hemingway mention the train's timing in "Hills Like White Elephants"?
By saying that the train will come in forty minutes, Hemingway is creatinig a certain amount of dramatic tension. The issue between the man and woman has to be resolved in forty minutes. He wants her to go to Madrid and get an abortion. She doesn't want to go through with it, and he knows it. She has consented, but he is not sure she won't change her mind. So he keeps tallking to her, tryig to persuade her that it is the right thing to do and that it is a very simple procedure and that it won't change their relationship. Meanwhile the train is approaching, as it is in the classic movie High Noon starring Gary Cooper. A so-called "ticking clock" is a common device in stories.
The fact that the train will stop for only two minutes shows that this is a small, insignificant station. This young...
Unlock
This Answer NowStart your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
couple may be the only passengers boarding here. I believe it is only a way of portraying the setting, although it also suggests the time pressure. They don't have to do anything during the forty minutes the train is approaching, but once it stops they will only have two minutes to decide to get aboard or stay where they are.
In “Hills Like White Elephants, the unnamed American is having a serious
discussion with his girlfriend Jig about whether she should have an abortion.
This was a dangerous and illegal operation in the period, and the man wants her
to go through with it. She does not want an abortion, and is possibly more
interested in getting married or at least having some assurance that she will
be cared for if she undergoes it. This is a major and serious relationship
discussion, and, given how many women died or were permanently injured from
illegal abortions, a major life and health crisis for Jig. Having an
illegitimate baby in that time would not have been an easy choice either.
Confronted with this sort of huge dilemma for Jig, the mention that the train
leaves in 40 minutes and only stops for two suggests that the man is, to put it
really crassly, a major jerk. It limits the depth of the discussion and
suggests that he’s not willing to invest time in being supportive. Rather than
consider that he is the father of the baby and has responsibilities, it
suggests that he wants to deal with the pregnancy merely as a minor annoyance
that can be handled quickly and superficially.
In Hills Like White Elephants, is the train's timing relevant?
I don't see the time factor as immediately relevant in terms of the plot. Yet, I think that it is significant in terms of what Hemingway sets out to do in the short story. One of the reasons why this short story is so powerful is that it really shows an example of Hemingway wanting to recreate "a moment," an instant in the life of two people. He does this with a recreation of everything, a sense that he is the author but also one that prevents him from coloring this recreation with his own bias. He wants to use language to recreate "everything" about that moment, that instant where the couple endure this instant that happens in real time, but is one whose effect will be lasting. It is for this reason that Hemingway describes the situation with strong detail, and yet does not use this to construct something more elaborate. He is presenting reality, in all of its complexity and simultaneous simplicity. This style is one where time has to be recognized. Time is not used as a symbol or something to represent more than what it is. It is the undercurrent of the moment, the ticking reality that encompasses both the man and Jig. The train comes, stops, and moves on. The couple has to deal with these implications as their own relationship progresses. The choices that they have to make regarding Jig's pregnancy is a part of this. They simply cannot wish to remain "still," as time continually moves on. This recreation of the instant is made more meaningful with the presence of time, and Hemingway's use of it helps to bring out the idea that we might wish otherwise, but we are both bound by our actions and the construction of time which is inescapable. I think that this becomes the reason why time is important in the short story and in Hemingway's construction of it.