Critical Evaluation

(Critical Survey of Literature for Students)

Although Mikhail Lermontov is better known as a poet than as a novelist in his native Russia, A Hero of Our Time, his only completed novel, is widely considered to be one of Russia’s greatest novels. In Pechorin, the novel’s hero, Lermontov gives the first psychological portrait of the Russian literary type, the superfluous man. The superfluous man was to become a major figure in the novels and stories of Russian writers such as Alexander Herzen, Ivan Turgenev, and Ivan Gonchorov. Superfluous men, set apart from society by their superior talents or perceptions, are doomed to waste their lives, partly because of lack of opportunity to fulfill themselves but also because they lack any sense of purpose.

Lermontov is not the inventor of the superfluous man: The Russian poet Alexander Pushkin created the superfluous hero Eugene Onegin in the poem of that name (1825-1832, 1833). In creating Pechorin, Lermontov draws both on Pushkin and on the life and works of English poet Lord Byron. The cult of Byronism, which romanticized the stance of the cynical yet passionately rebellious outsider, was sweeping through Russia, along with the cult of Napoleon as the supposed liberator of the oppressed masses.

Lermontov looks into the concept of superfluity more deeply than Pushkin does, probing into its psychological and social origins and suggesting that it was the logical endpoint of many of the typical vices of his age. Hence the ironic label for Pechorin, “hero of our time.” Like the so-called lost generation of disillusioned idealists of the 1830’s following the abortive Decembrist Revolt against Czar Nicholas I’s oppressive regime, Pechorin’s creative genius finds no legitimate channel for expression and then thus turns in on itself and grows destructive. He wreaks destruction on all around him: He kills Grushnitski in a duel, reopens an old wound for Vera, and breaks Princess Mary’s heart.

In analyzing Pechorin, Lermontov analyzed the mal du siècle—the sickness of the age. Lermontov’s techniques of analysis are innovative and worthy of note. The first two of the five narratives, “Bela” and “Maksim Maksimich,” show Pechorin through the eyes of others. “Princess Mary” is in the form of Pechorin’s diary, providing a format that allows the character to reveal his complex inner life. “Taman” and “The Fatalist” are first-person narratives in which Pechorin records his adventures in the Crimea and the Caucasus.

In a...

(The entire section is 1023 words.)