Henry Lawes Essay - Critical Essays

Lawes, Henry


Henry Lawes 1596-1662

English songwriter.

The preeminent songwriter among the musicians associated with the court of Charles I, with more than 430 songs to his credit, Lawes was praised by contemporary poets for the style of song that he developed as a vehicle for lyric verse. His musical settings gave the greatest possible exposure to the poetic text in terms of meaning, imagery, and verbal play, qualities that were often summed up as “wit.” Lawes set to music poems by many literary luminaries of his time, and his prestige was such that contemporary printer-publishers included a reference to Lawes's settings on the title pages of volumes by John Milton, Thomas Carew, Edmund Waller, John Suckling, and William Cartwright. Lawes also set music to poems by Robert Herrick and Richard Lovelace. Many poets provided commendatory poems to the published volumes of Lawes's songs, the most famous being Milton's sonnet, “To My Friend, Mr. Henry Lawes, on His Airs,” printed in Lawes's Choice Psalmes (1648). Critical commentary on Lawes focuses on his relationship to the important poets whose lyrics he set to music and on his collaboration with them on their works.

Biographical Information

Little is known of Lawes's background and personal life. He was born on January 5, 1596 in Wiltshire, England. He was very close to his younger brother, William, who was to become the preeminent instrumental composer of the Caroline court. It is known that William at an early age was taught by Giovanni Coperario (John Cooper) in the household of Edward Seymour, Earl of Hertford. Lawes's musical education probably began in the same way, though possibly in the household of the other great Wiltshire patron of artists, William Herbert, third Earl of Pembroke. In either house he would have encountered Alfonso Ferrabosco, who, with Coperario and others, introduced the new Italian style of monody to Prince Charles's circle. These Wiltshire connections could also have been Lawes's entrée to the aristocratic households of London, where he was living by 1615, when he was nineteen years old. He received royal preferment soon after the accession of Prince Charles to the throne in 1625. In January 1626 Lawes was granted a probationary post in the Chapel Royal, followed within two years by full appointment as gentleman of the chapel. Five years later, in January 1631, he also became “Musician for Lutes and Voices” in the secular arm of the court musical establishment, the King's Musicke. In both posts his primary duties were to perform, but he was also called upon as a composer.

During the Interregnum, the period from 1649 to 1660 when Britain was a republic, Lawes supported himself primarily by teaching but continued to compose and permitted the publication of many of his songs. Personal allusions in commendatory poems and elsewhere depict Lawes as a sympathetic and convivial companion, and the number and quality of tributes to him by poets bespeak a genuine and widespread admiration. With the restoration of the monarchy to the throne, Lawes was returned to his former court positions, and he composed what has become one of the traditional coronation anthems, “Zadoc the Priest,” for the coronation of Charles II; but he was no longer an active force, and he died within two years, in 1662. His will mentions a “dear and loving wife Eleanor,” who served as executrix; he left no known descendants.

Major Works

Lawes is noteworthy not only because of his stature as a composer of songs but because of the range and variety of poets whose lyrics he set to music. His early compositions include settings of texts by Philip Sidney and John Donne as well as by Pembroke and his circle. His association with Milton is well documented, especially in relation to the masque Comus (1637), although it is seldom noted that at the time of these collaborations Lawes, not Milton, was the well-established artist sponsoring a young unknown. His principal collaboration was with the courtier George Sandys, for whose fashionable metrical paraphrases of the Psalms Lawes provided a set of new tunes in A Paraphrase Upon the Psalmes of David (1638). He also composed more elaborate, three-voice settings for Sandys's text that spoke to Royalist experiences of war, discouragement, and defeat in Choice Psalmes Put Into Musick (1648). Evidence of Lawes's personal association with other poets is sparse and inconclusive as to how long or how well he knew them. However, scholars have concluded that he was probably widely acquainted with the writers and wits of his time, working closely and fruitfully with some and on terms of long intimacy with a few. He worked almost entirely with the poems of contemporaries, and the preface to the first book of Ayres and Dialogues (1653), an anthology of miscellaneous airs and songs, makes the explicit claim that he received copies of the verses directly from their authors. If he was being accurate, this claim alone would establish an acquaintance with twenty-eight poets, including Herrick, Carew, Lovelace, Waller, William Davenant, Katherine Phillips, Sandys, Suckling, and George Herbert. Lawes's Second Booke of Ayres, and Dialogues (1655) is of particular interest because it reveals the composer's association with a group of gifted women, including his patron and student Lady Unton Dering and the distinguished singer Mary Knight, as well as Phillips. Many of the songs in Ayres and Dialogues express Royalist sentiments, and the third volume, which appeared in 1658, in particular displays an increasing confidence of the Royalist party and its hope for the restoration of the monarchy.

Critical Reception

During his lifetime Lawes was esteemed as a vocalist and composer of songs. He was praised highly by the poets with whom he associated for his special sensitivity to poetic structure and tone in his musical settings. Commendatory poems by Milton, Waller, and Herrick, among others, emphasize his ability to enhance the eloquence of their lyrics with his musical accompaniments. Modern musicologists point out that to the modern ear Lawes's settings might appear to be spare and lacking in substance, but his free rhythmic delivery, subtle ornamental figures, and slight variations in dynamics were calculated to convey a type of “charming negligence” that delighted seventeenth-century audiences. Modern studies of Lawes's work are limited, partly because he is overshadowed by his more well-known brother, but those that have appeared have emphasized his connection to the poets whose lyrics he set to music. Of particular interest to critics have been Lawes's collaboration on Comus and Milton's support of the composer. Scholars have also commended Lawes for his efforts to create a new music as an expression of the unique English language and character.

Principal Works

A Paraphrase Upon the Psalmes of David. By G. S. Set to new tunes for private Devotion [music by Lawes, text by George Sandys] (songs) 1638

Choice Psalmes Put Into Musick, For Three Voices [music by Lawes and William Lawes, text by George Sandys] (songs) 1648

Ayres and Dialogues for One, Two, and Three Voyces (songs) 1653

The Second Booke of Ayres, and Dialogues (songs) 1655

Ayres and Dialogues for One, Two, and Three Voices: The Third Booke (songs) 1658

The Treasury of Musick [contributor] (music anthology) 1669


Willa McClung Evans (essay date March 1936)

SOURCE: Evans, Willa McClung. “Lawes' Version of Shakespeare's Sonnet CXVI.” PMLA 51, no. 1 (March 1936): 120-22.

[In the following essay, Evans points out that Lawes set a version of Shakespeare's Sonnet 116 to music, which she says establishes that the composer was the only contemporary who collaborated with both Milton and Shakespeare.]

That Henry Lawes set to music a version of Shakespeare's Sonnet CXVI “Let me not to the marriage of true mindes / Admit impediments,” has apparently never been mentioned in print. Lawes' version, which retains seven lines intact, alters seven, and adds two couplets to form three six-line stanzas, is found in John Gamble's...

(The entire section is 881 words.)

Willa McClung Evans (essay date September 1938)

SOURCE: Evans, Willa McClung. “Henry Lawes and Charles Cotton.” PMLA 53, no. 3 (September 1938): 724-29.

[In the following excerpt, Evans shows that Lawes set to music a version of Charles Cotton's poem “The Picture.”]

Hearty, cheerful Mr. Cotton and pious Izaak Walton shared enthusiasms other than their common devotion to angling.1 Both of these seventeenth-century fishermen had some proficiency in singing, and wrote verse to be set to music. Walton, it will be recalled, “made a conversion of an old ketch, and added more to it,”2 for which Henry Lawes composed the melody of The Angler's Song.3 Charles Cotton in...

(The entire section is 1828 words.)

Morris Freedman (essay date summer 1963)

SOURCE: Freedman, Morris. “Milton's ‘On Shakespeare’ and Henry Lawes.” Shakespeare Quarterly 14, no. 3 (summer 1963): 279-81.

[In the following essay, Freedman provides evidence to show that Lawes may have been responsible for Miton's poem “On Shakespeare” appearing as a preface to the playwright's works in the Second Folio.]

Milton's first published work, “On Shakespeare”, appeared as one of the prefatory poems to the Second Folio, in 1632. At the time, Milton, twenty-four, was unknown as a poet; only his family, friends, classmates, and perhaps some of his teachers knew of his interest in writing. How did it happen that his lines came to preface the...

(The entire section is 1070 words.)

John T. Shawcross (essay date December 1964)

SOURCE: Shawcross, John T. “Henry Lawes's Settings of Songs for Milton's ‘Comus.’” Journal of the Rutgers University Library 28 (December 1964): 22-8.

[In the following essay, Shawcross discusses the music Lawes composed for Milton's masque Comus, arguing that the text may have been altered after the composition of the music.]

In a former article on the manuscripts of John Milton's mask called “Comus”1 I drew attention to the fact that the texts of the songs for which music written by Henry Lawes exists are derived from revisions of the basic transcription in Milton's manuscript in the library of Trinity College, Cambridge.2 The...

(The entire section is 2983 words.)

Audrey Davidson (essay date May 1968)

SOURCE: Davidson, Audrey. “Milton on the Music of Henry Lawes.” Milton Newsletter 2, no. 2 (May 1968): 19-23.

[In the following excerpt, Davidson speculates on the relationship between Milton and Lawes through a reading of Milton's sonnet of praise to the composer.]

Milton's encomiastic sonnet to Henry Lawes opens with the highest praise for his eminent contemporary:

Harry, whose tuneful and well measur'd Song
First taught our English Music how to span
Words with just note and accent, not to scan
With Midas' Ears, committing short and long …(1)

These lines, according to Donald Tovey, reveal a Milton who has forgotten the precise...

(The entire section is 2794 words.)

Nan Cooke Carpenter (essay date spring 1972)

SOURCE: Carpenter, Nan Cooke. “Milton and Music: Henry Lawes, Dante, and Casella.” English Literary Renaissance 2 (spring 1972): 237-42.

[In the following essay, Carpenter offers an interpretation of Milton's sonnet in praise of Lawes, arguing that the poem likens Lawes to Casella and the poet himself to Dante.]

Several of Milton's sonnets, Italian and English, rely for effect upon musical allusions and overtones; only one (XIII) is completely musical—“To Mr. H. Lawes, on his Aires.” Although, at first reading, the sonnet seems to be typical laudatory verse, couched in the classical imagery beloved of Milton, closer attention to the poem reveals...

(The entire section is 2959 words.)

Franklin R. Baruch (essay date 1973)

SOURCE: Baruch, Franklin R. “Milton's Comus: Skill, Virtue, and Henry Lawes.” Milton Studies 5 (1973): 289-308.

[In the following essay, Baruch argues that in his masque Comus Milton characterizes Lawes, who plays the role of the Attendant Spirit, as the teacher and dramatic guide for the Egerton children.]

Much of the attention given to Milton's Comus has sprung from a concern with the pairings seen as operative in the poem. Virginity and profligacy, natural and religious virtue, celibacy and marriage, order and disorder—the list is an abundant one, with results often richly suggestive.1 It is perhaps inevitable that this focus in...

(The entire section is 8642 words.)

Elizabeth A. Frost (essay date 1991)

SOURCE: Frost, Elizabeth A. “The Didactic Comus: Henry Lawes and the Trial of Virtue.” Comitatus: A Journal of Medieval and Renaissance Studies 22 (1991): 87-103.

[In the following essay, Frost elucidates the moral lessons provided in Milton's Comus, maintaining that in the didactic masque Lawes takes on the role of instructor.]

The Jacobean and Caroline court masque traditionally incorporated some moral message into the grandeur of its spectacle, but only as part of its elaborately conceived compliment. Both Jonson's Vision of Delight and Carew's Coelum Britannicum describe the restoration of order over disorder, virtue over...

(The entire section is 6885 words.)

Lydia Hamessley (essay date 1994)

SOURCE: Hamessley, Lydia. “Henry Lawes's Setting of Katherine Philips's Friendship Poetry in His Second Book of Ayres and Dialogues, 1655: A Musical Misreading?” In Queering the Pitch: The New Gay and Lesbian Musicology, edited by Philip Brett, Elizabeth Wood and Gary C. Thomas, pp. 115-38. New York: Routledge, 1994.

[In the following excerpt, an expanded version of a lecture delivered in 1991, Hamessley considers whether, in setting Katherine Philip's poetry to music, Lawes projected, masked, or suppressed the lesbian voice.]

But as the morning sun to drooping flowers,
As weary travellers a shade do find,
As to the parched violet evening showers;
Such is from...

(The entire section is 7931 words.)

Further Reading


Spink, Ian. Cavalier Songwriter. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000, 172 p.

Comprehensive account of Lawes's life, focusing on his work as a musician.


Evans, Willa McClung. “Lawes' and Lovelace's Loose Saraband.” PMLA 54, no. 3 (September 1939): 764-67.

Comments on Lawes's musical setting for a poem by Richard Lovelace.

———. Henry Lawes: Musician and Friend of Poets. New York: Modern Language Association of America, 1941, 250 p.

Full-length survey of Lawes's works from a literary perspective.


(The entire section is 167 words.)