Student Question

Does Henry V's war with France in Shakespeare's play pass Thomas Aquinas's "Doctrine of Just War"? Was this war necessary?

Quick answer:

It seems like you could reasonably argue that Henry V’s war with France was not necessary and didn’t meet the criteria for Thomas Aquinas’s just war. The English people were not facing imminent harm from the French. The war did not seem to tangibly improve the lives of regular British people. However, it did get Henry V a glorious battle victory, a wife, and a hero’s welcome.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

If you’re adapting or appropriating Thomas Aquinas’s thoughts about just war, it could be difficult to argue that Henry V’s war with France meets Aquinas’s criteria.

The one component that seems to align with Aquinas’s thoughts is that of a just authority. For Aquinas, a war is invalid if the government waging that war isn’t credible or legitimate. It seems like Henry V is valid and licit. He is the accepted king of England. It’s his throne, and it’s within his rights to declare war.

However, with that being said, you could adopt the perspective that Henry V shouldn’t be viewed as a legitimate authority. It’s not like Henry V became king because of a free election. The people of England didn’t choose Henry V to be their king. If you espouse a democratic perspective, you might conclude that Henry V is not a legitimate authority.

As for a just cause and a just intention, if you adopted Henry V’s perspective, perhaps you could argue that the cause and intention were just. The war netted Henry V an upset victory, a wife, and something like a hero’s welcome.

Yet if you take up the perspective of the common soldier, it might be hard to argue that this war was necessary. As Henry V’s undercover conversations with the rank-and-file soldiers indicate, the war was almost all risk and no reward for them.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial