Heinrich Böll

Start Free Trial

Children Are Civilians Too

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

In the following essay, Schwarz asserts that most of Böll's early stories depict the dreariness of war.
SOURCE: A review of Children Are Civilians Too, in The Saturday Review, New York, Vol. LIII, No. 13, March 28, 1970, pp. 38-40.

Heinrich Böll has written short stories, Novellen, novels, radio plays and drama, but his true talent lies in telling stories. His first "novel," Adam, Where Art Thou, is really a series of terse short stories, held together by a theme—the little man in war—rather than by central characters. In Böll's radio plays several stories are usually told by a commentator to amplify the dialogue. His Irish Journal likewise consists of a sequence of stories about life in Ireland.

Much less convicting than these early works are Böll's ambitious novels, Acquainted with the Night, Billiards at Half-Past Nine, and The Clown. Here Böll revels in contrived symbolism and in monotonous attacks on German nationalism and chauvinism. These are the works, of course, for which he won the widest acclaim behind the Iron Curtain, where he is celebrated as the foremost West German representative of the so-called Critical Realism; by 1962 more than 800,000 copies of his books had been sold in Communist countries. Unfortunately, the literary appeal of his writing is all too often diminished by the uncompromising hatred of the capitalist society in the Federal Republic that Heinrich Böll reiterates in his novels. The author here plays the fatal role of the Praceptor Germaniae, the moralist and prophet of his nation, the Nestor of our century. Böll's last two major publications, Absent Without Leave and End of a Mission are tendentious in an obtrusive manner, leaving little to the imagination in their overzealous criticism of West German militarism.

None of this is detectable in Children Are Civilians Too. Here speaks a true teller of tales, Böll at his best. These short sketches appeared between 1947 and 1951, when the author was trying to come to terms with the experiences of the Second World War. Böll is a devout Catholic—not an orthodox adherent of the official church doctrine, but an unwavering disciple of Christ. The six long years he was forced to fight in Hitler's war were against his inner convictions, certainly, yet he never openly took issue with Nazi despotism and crime. This contradiction, a prevalent one among the rank-and-file soldiers of the former German Wehrmacht, is reflected in most of Böll's early stories.

Twenty-six of them have been selected and well translated by Leila Vennewitz; together they present a valid testimony of the situation of those who do not really act in wartime, but are acted upon. Two of the stories do not actually belong to the collection. One of them, "My Sad Face," is a somewhat lame farce about modern totalitarianism, written in the parable form of the Kafka tradition. The second, "Black Sheep," is a humorous exploration of the artist's existence. For "Black Sheep," incidentally, Böll received, in 1951, the Gruppe 47 prize, which established his reputation as a writer in Germany and abroad. All twenty-six stories, originally conceived in the laconic, careless speech of the ordinary German, are impressive for their precise settings, firm structure, and forceful, pregnant dialogue.

In his presentation of war Heinreich Böll never depicts the real fighting; he never confronts the reader with gruesome pictures of human suffering as did Theodor Plievier and others. It goes without saying that any glorification of war in the fashion of Ernst Jünger is excluded from his writings. Böll prefers to show the monotony of war, the waste of time and effort—he talks of dirt and lice and boredom and of the little yet utterly frustrating privations. He describes the war from the...

(This entire section contains 869 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

perspective of the plain soldier who worries about finding a slice of bread or a cigarette. Böll places his anti-heroic heroes into sick bays, crowded trains, drafty railway stations, and destroyed cities. His characters are rootless, homeless figures that fight a day-to-day battle for survival. They are preoccupied with their petty problems to such a degree that they find no time to reflect on the larger issues of the war.

Böll's stories give a gray, grim picture of wartime and postwar Germany, but few of them are completely without light and hope. "My Pal with the Long Hair" ends with the significant phrase: "We have been together ever since—in these hard times." In the title story, "Children Are Civilians Too," Böll writes: "The snow fell on her fine blonde hair, powdering her with fleeting silver dust; her smile was utterly bewitching." A glance, a smile that two people exchange breaks the isolation and solitude in a strange, hostile world. It is in the encounter of two human beings that the miseries of war and after-war are overcome. And if there is no soul to communicate with, man still is not left in the cold because there is always God. In "Candles for the Madonna" a man reflects after a visit to the church: ". . . my heart was lighter than it had been for a long time." Böll's figures are weak—every one a sinner in his own way—but they are, at the same time, believers who know where they can find an answer to their anguish.

Previous

At the Fringes of the Miracle

Next

Böll—'A Miniature Dante'

Loading...