Download Hard Times Study Guide

Subscribe Now

Critical Evaluation

(Critical Survey of Literature for Students)

Dedicated to social critic Thomas Carlyle, Hard Times represents Charles Dickens’s first work of overt social criticism and reflects his contempt for utilitarian ideals of progress that valued that which produced the “greatest good for the greatest number.” Coketown, the setting for Hard Times, is a mill city that represents the worst aspects of what the Industrial Revolution was doing to British people in the nineteenth century. In Hard Times, it is this revolution that Dickens blames for England’s moral, legal, spiritual, and intellectual decay.

While all of the characters in this novel are flawed or damaged because of the changes brought about by the Industrial Revolution, Dickens holds Josiah Bounderby in the greatest contempt. In him, Dickens embodies the worst characteristics of the middle class: self-absorption, arrogance, and a lack of compassion for others in need of help. A self-made man, Bounderby demeans his family, claiming to have escaped an abusive childhood through his wits alone. While it makes for a heartrending story, Dickens eventually exposes Bounderby as a fraud. Rather than having been abandoned as a child, Bounderby actually grew up in a loving, comfortable home. The reason he presents his family as villains is that, in Bounderby’s eyes, they are not successful people because they do not prize self-reliance above all else, even love. In fact, Bounderby seems to think that love is just another acquisition, something he can have if he has the money to buy it. This is his attitude as he pursues Louisa Gradgrind to be his wife.

The Gradgrind children—Louisa, her younger brother, Tom, and their siblings—are raised and educated by a father who prizes the utilitarian values of reason at the expense of the imagination, a system that encourages the fostering of intellect but not the nurturing of the human heart. By some standards, it could be argued that Mr. Gradgrind has provided well for his family; however, when it comes to love, compassion, and supportive understanding—those things that Dickens sees as essential—the Gradgrind family appears much less blessed than either the mill workers or the economically disadvantaged—but loving—group of circus people, who provide Sissy Jupe with her extended family.

Throughout Louisa’s troubles with her husband and during her infatuation with James Harthouse, it is Sissy, not her father or brother, who recognizes the depth of Louisa’s unhappiness. Dickens clearly reviles a system such as the one practiced in Mr. Gradgrind’s home and private school, a system that inculcates only hard facts at the expense of compassion and imagination. Despite Louisa’s rearing and education, Dickens makes it clear that Louisa feels things deeply and needs someone to love, not only because she is attracted to the spoiled, idle dilettante James but also because she cannot contain her hungry imagination during her quiet musings before the fire. Sadly, Louisa can no more tell her father, her...

(The entire section is 1,050 words.)