Style and Technique
Whether children could grasp the occasionally long Faulknerian sentences in this story is debatable, but they could probably follow the switches of voice within the sentences better than adults. The switches of voice reflect the villagers’ thoughts, including what they think the corpse is thinking; this complexity is all subsumed and remarkably controlled by the humorous voice of the omniscient narrator, who makes it seem like child’s play. The style is known as García Márquez’s Magical Realism, made famous in One Hundred Years of Solitude. The style also features exaggeration (as in the size of the corpse here) and imaginative thrusts (“the men began to feel mistrust in their livers”) that now and then verge into fantasy.
It is certainly fantasy that the drowned man’s corpse does not stink, a fantasy that enables García Márquez to construct a symbolism of smells reminiscent of the one in William Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily” (1930). Although Faulkner is perhaps the greatest influence on García Márquez, here the pupil reverses the master. Whereas Faulkner’s story begins with a strong smell and ends with a decayed corpse, García Márquez’s story begins with a remarkably preserved corpse and ends up smelling like roses. The symbolism typifies García Márquez’s style, his gift to the world.
Historical Context
Political Background
Following Columbus's arrival in the New World, European imperialism made it
difficult for Colombia's indigenous tribes to resist Spanish conquest. Most of
these tribes eventually merged with their Spanish conquerors through
intermarriage and cohabitation. As a result, a significant portion of the
Colombian population is composed of mestizos—individuals of both native
Colombian and Spanish descent.
Colombia, once part of the Spanish colonial empire known as New Granada, gained independence from Spain in 1810. Throughout the 19th century, the country was plagued by numerous civil wars. By the mid-1800s, the political landscape was dominated by Liberals and Conservatives, whose conflicts led to frequent and bloody revolutions. The intense fighting peaked between 1899 and 1903 during the War of a Thousand Days. During this period, a clear division existed between the wealthy elite landowners, often of European descent, and the freed slaves and indigenous populations whose lands had been seized and redistributed. At the same time, Colombia struggled to expand its export trade, which primarily included coffee, petroleum, and bananas, under Conservative leadership.
Social Policies
The Great Depression of the 1930s brought severe economic challenges to
Colombia, primarily due to its increasing reliance on exports, whose values
dropped drastically on the global market. The Conservative government was
replaced by Liberal President Alfonso Lopez, who implemented significant land
reforms. His primary reform involved redistributing land from wealthy
landowners who were not using it productively to peasant "squatters" who
depended on it for survival. The Depression also spurred a rise in domestic
industry as competition from imported goods diminished. Assisting Colombia's
poorest citizens has been a persistent focus for the government, especially
under Liberal administrations.
La Violencia
The hostility between Colombia's Liberal and Conservative parties has been
extremely violent. This conflict intensified between 1948 and 1962, a period
known as La Violencia. Although triggered by the assassination of
Liberal leader Jorge Eliecer Gaitan, the subsequent fifteen years of fighting
were rooted in longstanding animosities between the two parties. Approximately
200,000 people died during this period, with many victims suffering extreme
cruelty.
La Violencia reflected a broad range of Colombian concerns. Peasants who had improved their land under the 1930s reforms faced exorbitant legal fees to obtain titles in certain regions. Guerilla leaders, often the sons...
(This entire section contains 881 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
of small farmers and merchants, garnered peasant support as they engaged in ambushes and retaliations rooted in family feuds, political affiliations (which are often inherited in Colombia), and government connections. Migrant peasants seeking work in other regions also became involved in the conflict. The government's loss of control in many areas resulted in multiple bids for power by local groups in towns and cities across the country.
During La Violencia, President Laureano Gomez, a Conservative, established a fascist government in an effort to regain control. However, he was overthrown by the military and populist President General Gustave Rojas Pinilla, who was also eventually removed from office by the military. Ultimately, the National Front, a coalition of Liberals and Conservatives, negotiated a truce. Garcia Marquez reported on many of these events as a journalist before incorporating them into his fictional works. La Violencia remains one of the most fictionalized events in Colombia's history.
The 1960s
In the 1960s, Colombia continued its struggle for economic development.
Increased intervention by the United States heightened Colombia's dependence on
foreign aid but did little to boost the economy. This decade was characterized
by high unemployment, low coffee export prices, and economic stagnation. Under
Conservative President Guillermo Leon Valencia, union workers received a forty
percent wage increase, which led to skyrocketing inflation. Deflationary
pricing resulted in significant unemployment. However, government policies
later improved, and by the late 1960s, Colombia's economy was growing again.
During this period, migration to urban areas persisted, and by 1970, over half
of Colombia's population lived in cities.
Colombia Today
Due to unevenly distributed development, a significant economic gap between
classes remains in Colombia. Approximately 20 percent of the population lives
below the poverty line, many residing in slums on the outskirts of urban areas.
Concerns about military intervention in the government, violence, and terrorism
persist. Additionally, the country continues to grapple with a substantial
drug-trafficking problem. Despite these challenges, the decades following La
Violencia have seen Colombia become one of the most urbanized and
modernized nations in Latin America.
Gabriel Garcia Marquez and History
Although little of Colombia's history is directly referenced in "The Handsomest
Drowned Man in the World," it plays a significant role in Garcia Marquez's
broader body of work. The village's isolation, the mythical sense of time, and
the anonymity of the characters make the absence of historical context so
pronounced that it prompts readers to question why Garcia Marquez chose to omit
it deliberately. This technique of omission is also found in other works of
magic realism. Critics suggest one reason for this approach is to protect the
author, especially when writing controversial material in countries where
freedom of speech is restricted by the government. By making the story "about"
something other than their own country, writers can safely express
controversial viewpoints. Another possibility is that Garcia Marquez avoids
specific historical references to make the characters and actions
representative of all people, rather than those of a particular place.
Nonetheless, the villagers' kindness and love towards the drowned man, when
contrasted against Colombia's violent and cruel past, become even more
striking.
Literary Style
The discovery of a large drowned man on their shore sparks the imagination of the residents in a small fishing village.
Point of View
The straightforward narration of "The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World"
hides a rather intricate narrative technique. When the villagers find a drowned
man on their beach, they soon begin to admire and eventually love him as they
prepare him for a proper burial. The third-person narrator, however, only
depicts the man through the villagers' perspectives. The reader sees the
drowned man through their eyes, not from an objective standpoint. Additionally,
the narrative occasionally shifts away from the villagers, such as when an
imaginary hostess frets over her chair, and he "never knowing perhaps that the
ones who said don't go, Esteban, at least wait till the coffee's ready, were
the ones who later on would whisper the big boob finally left, how nice, the
handsome fool has gone." This sophisticated narrative style reveals insights
not only about Esteban but also about the villagers as they perceive him within
the scope of their lives.
Setting
The story's setting is more intricate than it initially appears. The village,
unnamed and seemingly isolated from the outside world, evokes a sense of a
distant, mystical land. The absence of modern technology, exemplified by their
use of a primitive, wheelless sled to transport Esteban to his funeral, places
the story in a timeless, almost prehistoric era. However, the seaside village
closely resembles the coastal regions near Garcia Marquez's childhood home, and
the mention of ocean liners at the story's conclusion confirms that this is a
real location in the present day. Thus, the village exists as both a mythical,
far-off place and a tangible, real-world locale, embodying elements of both
magic and reality.
Magic Realism
Initially coined in the 1920s to describe a modern style of painting, the term
"magic realism" later became associated with a specific genre of fiction,
particularly that written by Latin American authors during the 1950s and 1960s.
Magic realist fiction blends fantastical elements with realistic details. For
instance, the arrival of a "Wednesday dead body" on the shore of a fishing
village might not be inherently magical. What elevates the narrative into the
realm of the extraordinary is the villagers' reaction, which is far from
ordinary. The idea that a deceased man can profoundly impact a community
accustomed to discovering drowning victims on their beach creates a sense of
exceptionalism. The village's mythical anonymity and the story's ambiguously
historical setting enhance this perception. Simultaneously, elements like the
ocean liner at the story’s conclusion anchor it in a tangible reality.
Therefore, the narrative straddles the line between fantasy and reality. The
roots of magic realism are often attributed to various factors, including the
superstitions of Latin America's indigenous peoples. In Garcia Marquez's case,
his grandmother's magical storytelling significantly influenced his imagination
from an early age.
Allusion
Allusion in literature happens when an element within a story hints at or
indirectly references something beyond the story itself. Garcia Marquez is
renowned for his skill in merging native South American legends with European
myths and narratives. Even in a brief story like "The Handsomest Drowned Man in
the World," one can detect allusions to the biblical story of Jonah (via the
children's belief that the object washing ashore is a beached whale), Jonathan
Swift's Gulliver's Travels (where a shipwrecked man washes ashore in a
land of tiny people), and the Greek god Zeus, known for his numerous romantic
exploits in Greek mythology. More explicit allusions include the idea that
Esteban symbolizes the ancient god Quetzalcoatl, who in Aztec mythology
embodies peace and self-sacrifice, emerging from the sea. Similar to Esteban,
Quetzalcoatl departs by sea, leaving behind a promise of return that fosters
lasting anticipation. Esteban's name also references two historical figures:
St. Stephen, the first Christian martyr, whose name translates to Esteban in
English, and Estevanico, an African explorer of parts of the New World in the
1500s.
Garcia Marquez also references the Greek warrior Odysseus, whose exploits are detailed in Homer's Odyssey. One of Odysseus's notable adventures involves sailing past the Sirens, whose enchanting songs could compel any listener to abandon their journey and turn towards them. The women's mourning at Esteban's funeral creates a similar effect: "Some sailors who heard the weeping from a distance went off course, and people heard of one who had himself tied to the mainmast, recalling ancient fables about sirens."
The numerous allusions in the story imply that the different cultures Garcia Marquez mentions are more interconnected than often perceived. Each culture has its own saints and heroes; "The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World" illustrates how these figures gain significance within their respective cultures.
Compare and Contrast
1940s: Garcia Marquez writes several short stories that merge realistic elements with the fantastical. This narrative style, known as magic realism, gains popularity among Hispanic authors.
1990s: The magic realist novel Como agua para chocolate by Mexican author Laura Esquivel is translated into English as Like Water for Chocolate. The novel becomes a bestseller and inspires a well-received film adaptation.
Colombia, 1950s: Colombia is experiencing La Violencia, a fifteen-year period of turmoil that claims the lives of over 200,000 individuals.
Colombia, 1990s: Cocaine kingpin Pablo Escobar Gavira surrenders to Colombian authorities to avoid extradition to the United States. The profitable cocaine trade has led to numerous murders in recent years, including the killings of high-ranking officials.
Colombia, 1950s: The country’s major exports include fishing, forestry, and petroleum products, with coffee being the top cash crop.
Colombia, today: Coffee remains the nation’s leading legal export. Millions of people work in the fields, harvesting coffee beans for as little as $1.50 per day.
Literary Precedents
One of the most significant influences on Garcia Marquez is Alejo Carpentier's The Kingdom of the World (1949). This magic realist novel explores Haiti's tumultuous history through the perspective of a slave. Additionally, the impact of Jonathan Swift's Gulliver's Travels (1726) is evident in the scene where Esteban arrives on the beach, characterized by his immense size.
Garcia Marquez was also inspired by the works of Argentine author Jorge Luis Borges. Borges' experimental short story collections, A Universal History of Infamy and Ficciones, notably influenced him. In these collections, Borges moved away from conventional realist narration, embracing more fantastical elements.
Bibliography and Further Reading
Sources
Frosch, Marta Morello, "The Common Wonders of Garcia Marquez's Recent Fiction,"
Books Abroad, Vol. 47, No. 3, 1973, pp. 496-501.
Kazin, Alfred, Review in The New York Times Book Review, February 20, 1972, pp. 1, 14, 16.
Kazin, Alfred, Review of Leaf Storm and Other Stories, in Critical Essays on Gabriel Garcia Marquez, edited by George R. McMurray, G. K. Hall & Co., 1987, pp. 26-29.
McNerney, Kathleen, Understanding Garcia Marquez, University of South Carolina Press, 1989, pp. 121-122.
Pritchett, V. S., "A Ruined Arcady: 'Leaf Storm and Other Stories,'" New Statesman, February 9, 1973, p. 200.
Sturrock, John, "Shorter Marquez," The New York Times Book Review, July 16, 1978, p. 3.
Williams, Raymond L., Gabriel Garcia Marquez, Twayne Publishers, 1984, pp. 96-98.
Further Reading
Byk, John, "From Fact to Fiction: Gabriel Garcia Marquez and the Short Story,"
in Mid-American Review, Vol. VI, No. 2, 1986, pp. 111-116.
Explores the evolution of Garcia Marquez's short stories from his early,
conventional style to his later, fully developed magical realism.
The Cambridge History of Latin America, Volume III, edited by Leslie
Bethel, Cambridge University Press, 1991.
Examines Latin America's history since 1930 from political and economic
perspectives.
Epstein, Joseph, "How Good is Gabriel Garcia Marquez?," in
Commentary, May 1983, pp. 59-65.
Epstein describes "The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World" as "charming" and
praises the author's significant ability to present things in unique ways.
Levitt, Morton P., "From Realism to Magic Realism: The Meticulous Modernist
Fictions of Garcia Marquez," in Gabriel Garcia Marquez, edited by Harold
Bloom, Chelsea House, 1989, pp. 227-242.
Levitt examines magical realism as a literary technique, provides examples from
Garcia Marquez's work, and discusses Garcia Marquez's connection to it through
the author's own quotes.
McMurray, George R., Introduction to Critical Essays on Gabriel Garcia
Marquez, edited by George R. McMurray, G. K. Hall, 1987, pp. 1-23.
McMurray outlines the history of Garcia Marquez's publications and offers an
overview of critical responses to his work.
Review in The Times Literary Supplement, September 29, 1927, p.
1140.
The reviewer characterizes Garcia Marquez as a "storyteller" rather than a
"short-story writer," discussing the unique nature of his fantastical approach
to mundane reality.