The Grotesque

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

"Hands" is the first of twenty-three stories in Winesburg, Ohio, all preceded by a section entitled "The Book of the Grotesque." In this introduction, an elderly man imagines a parade of men and women, a "procession of grotesques." He gets out of bed to write down their tales. Although the narrator of "Hands" and the other stories has never seen the old man's writings, they inspire him to tell his own stories of grotesques.

The word "grotesque" has traditionally been used in art and literature to describe fantastical distortions of human and animal forms. Typically, something labeled as "grotesque" is abnormal, ugly, or strange. However, Anderson uses the term in a distinctive way. The elderly man in "The Book of the Grotesque" notes that his grotesques are "not all horrible. Some were amusing, some almost beautiful."

Wing Biddlebaum is considered a grotesque, a man marked and altered by his past experiences in Pennsylvania. However, this label should not imply he is malicious. His hands, which have caused him much trouble, add "more grotesque an already grotesque and elusive individuality," but the true flaw lies in the world around Wing, not within him.

Alienation and Loneliness

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The central theme of the narrative is Wing Biddlebaum’s isolation. The story begins with a scene of him pacing alone on his porch, yearning for a visit from his sole friend. From his vantage point, he observes a group of people laughing and playing, yet his only interaction with them is when they ridicule him. The story concludes with Wing kneeling to pick up bread crumbs, still in solitude. Between these scenes are memories and moments filled with loneliness and seclusion. Wing lives alone, on the outskirts of town, and the only thing people know about him is his skill as a swift berry picker.

With George Willard, Wing experiences slightly less isolation, though he still cannot fully express himself. He continuously holds back, constrained by fear. He desperately hopes to see George at the story’s outset, but he can do nothing more than wish for a visit. He is unable to reach out and must wait for George to take the initiative. On one occasion, he crosses a field and gazes down the road, but even this act frightens him, prompting him to retreat to his porch. A man so fearful finds it challenging to break free from his loneliness.

Despite his seclusion, Wing has not grown resentful toward humanity. He does not embrace his isolation and dreams of sitting beneath a tree in a garden, surrounded by young men eager to converse with him. He needs George because he still yearns for human connection. George is ‘‘the medium through which he express[es] his love of man.’’

Appearances and Reality

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Wing Biddlebaum's limited interactions with the people of Winesburg lead them to judge him solely by his appearance. However, his true nature is quite different. His actual name is Adolph Myers, not Wing Biddlebaum. Although he appears to be sixty-five, his real age is just forty. The townsfolk see him as a skilled field worker, yet he is also educated and intelligent enough to have worked as a teacher. Anderson uses the contrast between appearance and reality in Wing’s character to challenge whether the perceived misconduct in Wing’s interactions with his students was based on truth. The parents accuse Myers due to the appearance of homosexuality, but the story reveals that looks can be deceiving.

Sex

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The core of Wing's issues stems from matters related to sex, or more precisely, how others perceive it. The parents of his students suspect Wing of being a pederast, interpreting...

(This entire section contains 205 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

his actions—such as touching the boys' shoulders and hair—as having inappropriate sexual connotations. Anderson intentionally leaves Wing's sexuality ambiguous. At times, the narrator implies that Wing might be homosexual, as evidenced by the statement, “in their feeling for the boys under their charge such men are not unlike the finer sort of women in their love of men.” At other times, the narrator suggests that the parents' suspicions arise from a “rare, little-understood” influence that skilled teachers wield.

Whether or not Wing is truly homosexual, he fails to grasp what he has supposedly done wrong. He feels neither guilt nor shame in his interactions with the boys, yet he becomes aware that others perceive his actions as disgraceful. The narrator defends Wing, asserting that he was “meant by nature to be a teacher of youth.” The narrative doesn't dwell on whether Wing is gay; rather, it delves into the repercussions of people assuming a man is homosexual and responding with fear and hostility. For two decades, with almost no one in the town...

Estrangement and Misfits

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

In Sherwood Anderson's collection Winesburg, Ohio (1919), the story "Hands" emerges as a vivid portrayal of individuals alienated from society. This narrative serves as an introduction to Anderson's exploration of "grotesques," a term he coined for the misfits who live in quiet desperation, disconnected from the human community. Each character in the collection embodies this sense of estrangement, revealing the emotional landscapes of those who exist on the fringes.

The interconnected stories of Winesburg, Ohio share a thematic resonance, as well as geographical continuity, all bound together by the character of George Willard. Willard moves through the stories like a thread, weaving together the lives of diverse characters and offering readers a cohesive glimpse into the world Anderson constructs. This structural choice highlights the shared sense of alienation among the residents of Winesburg, despite their proximity.

Anderson's work is part of the New Realism movement that emerged in the United States following World War I. This movement included writers such as Sinclair Lewis and Ernest Hemingway, who similarly tackled themes of disconnection and disillusionment. Anderson's stories, with their incisive focus on the nuances of human estrangement, reflect the broader societal shifts of the time, capturing the subtle yet profound isolation experienced by many in the post-war era.

Psychosexual Conflict and Misinterpretation

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

"Hands" unfolds as a narrative rich in psychological depth, portraying a man caught in the throes of societal misjudgment and personal isolation. The story intricately weaves themes of psychosexual conflict with the broader struggle of aligning the spiritual with the physical. At its core, it tells the tale of Adolph/Wing, a man ostracized from his community due to behavior that others misunderstood or found intolerable. This misinterpretation is tinged with a sexual undertone, as hinted at by accusations that drove him away from his town. Yet, critics suggest that the true conflict lies beyond the surface-level sexual implications; it is, instead, a profound collision between one's spiritual aspirations and physical manifestations.

The tragedy of Wing's life stems from the inability of the Pennsylvania townspeople to perceive the unity between his spiritual ideals and their physical expression. Wing's hands, emblematic of his physical being, were once conduits for sharing his dreams and wisdom with his students. When he spoke to George Willard, or when he had previously engaged with students, the harmony between his voice and his touch—stroking shoulders or caressing hair—was an attempt to implant his dreams in young minds. This gentle merging of spirit and body, however, proved intolerable to society.

As the years pass, the once vibrant teacher is transformed. George Willard encounters Wing as a man prematurely aged, his hands now symbolic of disgrace rather than inspiration. Wing's hands, once instruments of connection and expression, have become marks of shame and isolation. They serve as a constant reminder of his misunderstood actions and the societal rejection he endures. Wing himself remains in the dark about the precise nature of his transgressions, burdened by the belief that his hands are somehow culpable: "Although [Wing] did not understand what had happened he felt that the hands must be to blame." His human condition is one of profound loneliness, a tragic testament to the chasm between intention and perception, dream and reality.

Union of the Physical and Spiritual

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

In the concluding image of the narrative, the protagonist, Wing, is depicted in a pose reminiscent of a priest absorbed in the sacred rituals of his faith. Anderson masterfully intertwines the physical and spiritual realms as Wing kneels, with his "nervous expressive fingers, flashing in and out of the light." These hands, reminiscent of a devotee's, swiftly navigate "decade after decade of his rosary," emphasizing the fusion of tangible and ethereal elements. The story transcends its portrayal of a man's estrangement from society, inviting reflection on the rare and profound union of physical presence and spiritual transcendence in human existence.

Much like James Joyce’s "Araby," the story's religious symbolism crescendos into an epiphany, stirring a deep recognition within the reader. The narrative invites an empathy for Wing Biddlebaum that resonates with the universal theme of human isolation. Anderson's tale captures the essential loneliness inherent in the human condition, yet offers a glimpse into the potential for spiritual enlightenment and connection. This synthesis of the physical and spiritual invites the audience to identify with Wing’s plight, transforming the story into a profound exploration of the delicate balance between corporeal existence and spiritual awakening.

Previous

Summary

Next

Characters

Loading...